FA-06 / FA-07 / FA-08

midi controller for organ drawbars?

midi controller for organ drawbars?

29 Nov 2014, 10:16
I would like to know if it is possible to use a midi controller (I have an MPK-49) to activate the fa-06 organ draw bars in a live situation? I can assign any channel or cc number to the midi controller as required.

Thanks

Re: midi controller for organ drawbars?

5 Dec 2014, 03:56
Sadly, this cannot be done with an MPK49!!!!

Roland implemented the drawbars such that you have to transmit SysEx messages (something I don't really understand, they seem difficult and confusing) to modify the drawbars in real time. So you can't use MIDI CC's, only SysEx messages. The MPK49 (I have the MPK61) cannot transmit SysEx messages, only regular MIDI CC's as you mentioned. Therefore, this is impossible.

I wanted to do the exact same thing as you and set myself up a second manual. The MPK49 and MPK61 have great action for organs. I'm hoping my Kronos X's organs can be controlled with the faders, but I haven't dug deeply into that board yet as I'm a relatively new owner and still coming to grips with the basics.

-Tom

Re: midi controller for organ drawbars?

6 Dec 2014, 11:02
Thanks for the reply Tom! With so much emphasis placed on playing the FA keyboards live, I am surprised that it is so difficult to do this.

Re: midi controller for organ drawbars?

6 Dec 2014, 17:20
I know, right??? After some research, turns out the Kronos X uses SysEx to transmit drawbar information, too.... but the CX-3 clonewheel organ which Korg manufactured for a time, whose engine has been faithfully ported to the Kronos, used simple MIDI CC's for its drawbars.... 16-24 for the upper drawbars, 70-78 for the lower drawbars. Why they didn't maintain that system when putting the CX-3 engine in the Kronos is beyond me.

Reading through other forums, there is definitely a need to standardize and simplify tonewheel organ controls, not just the drawbars but everything else too, leakage, speed, percussion etc.

For those who want a solution, there are a few. M-Audio and Novation keyboards can transmit SysEx messages, and thus can be programmed to work with both Roland and Korg's organ engines. There might be other keyboard controllers or programmable MIDI controllers that can send SysEx messages, but I didn't look too hard. I like Novation's products and might go that route down the road.

As well, there are a couple other dedicated hardware solutions.

MIDI Solutions makes something called the MIDI Event Processor. This is a small MIDI box, powered by the MIDI cable itself so no external power supply is needed (caveat: some boards don't supply the correct voltage through their MIDI Out ports so you MIGHT need a power supply depending on what you use), which can be programmed essentially as a dedicated hardware filter and transformer. You can program it to convert MIDI CC's into SysEx messages, and I read one forum post about a fellow who did exactly this to allow a second keyboard to change the drawbars on the Kronos.

Ever heard of a little program called TransMIDIfier? The MIDI Event Processor is basically the hardware version of that program (btw, check out TransMIDIfier if you get a chance, it is FREE and an amazing piece of software that has allowed me to program custom keyswitches which unite all my softsynths and sample libraries under one universal control scheme).

The MIDI Event Processor is about a $170 dollar solution, and the second one costs twice as much, over 300 bucks or thereabouts. It's called the DB-1, and it is made by a company called Ocean Beach. It is a dedicated drawbar control box which can also be powered directly by the MIDI connection, and what is particularly cool about the DB-1 is that it interacts with configurator software on your computer and is ALREADY programmed to work with all of the major organ engines out there.... Nord, Roland, Korg, and even Hammond's own digital tonewheel system. Btw, you don't need your computer to run the DB-1, you just use your computer to select which control scheme the DB-1 is using, internally. It then functions as a standalone box.

So if you buy a DB-1, the work is done for you. Hook it up to your computer, toggle which control scheme you need, and then run your keyboard through the DB-1 and you got yourself an instant lower or upper manual with its own drawbars that will work with a Nord, a Jupiter or Integra-7 or an FA, or the Kronos. If you buy a MIDI Event Processor, you have to program it yourself which means digging through forum posts looking for accurate information on what kind of SysEx messages your chosen clonewheel engine generates (because they each do it their own way).

Personally, I'm not sure what I'm going to do yet. Probably the MIDI Event Processor. It's cheaper, and I don't have to essentially admit my MPK61's faders are just for show. As long as I can figure out the SysEx messages, and there are a few forums with helpful and knowledgeable folks whose brains I might have to pick for this, I'd rather have a small black box that can sit on a blank patch of keyboard chassis somewhere in my rig (maybe even Velcro'ed on but I hate attaching adhesives to my beautiful instruments!!), and use the MPK61's faders for drawbar control, converting the MIDI CC's of the faders into SysEx messages the FA and Kronos can understand.

But depending on how many boards and modules I add to my rig going forward (right now my existing hardware supports the possibility for dozens of MIDI units, if I had all that stuff), I might grab a DB-1 for a board that doesn't have its own faders, or not enough of them, for drawbar control.

-Tom

Re: midi controller for organ drawbars?

24 Dec 2014, 15:45
I totally agree that the DB-1 is exactly what we want. My only issue is with its price. I already have several controllers with sliders. It is a shame that the only solution is to buy another controller.

Thanks for your reply.

Re: midi controller for organ drawbars?

25 Dec 2014, 14:56
Mgrmartinvavra wrote:
I agree with you. The price is very high.

What you must remember are two things before you say its too high

Ocean Beach is a one man operation, Dave himself.

The controller is a boutique product with a small market target, albeit most clonewheels respond to the DB1 .

I think for the amount of work he put into the product and the support he provides, it is an equitable price.
I followed him from his meager beginnings and he wont get rich from this product, for sure.

Sure you could find a control surface, kludge a mid events processor (for the CC capable drawbars) or a PC to generate sys-ex, and do basically the same thing, but certainly not as elegant and as easy to reprogram/
I move my DB1 between a Jupiter 80, an FA06 and a Kronos with just a quick reprogram from a PC.
X6, V-Combo, JV1010,, S330, S550, SP202

Re: midi controller for organ drawbars?

25 Dec 2014, 18:43
Point well taken. I did not want to imply that the db1 wasn't worth the money - I was simply hoping that I could control the drawbars with the equipment that I already have.
I have an idea for a possible workaround - not perfect- I haven't tried it yet.
My akai mpk49 in cubase mode adjusts the volume of channels 1 through 8 with the sliders. If you were to assign different slider settings to each of the first eight channels then the effect of moving the drawbars could be simulated with the midi sliders.

Re: midi controller for organ drawbars?

9 Apr 2015, 20:35
Just curious to know if anyone has successfully used the midi solutions event processor (in combination with a standard midi controller) to move the fa drawbars in real time.

Re: midi controller for organ drawbars?

19 Apr 2015, 05:25
Ed diaz mentions in a video promoting the roland fa that maybe they make the knobs work as drawbars when using supernatural organs...

Lets see!!!

← Back to FA-06 / FA-07 / FA-08