Fantom-S and Fantom-X

PC card with Ultra Compact Flash transfer speed to FX?

PC card with Ultra Compact Flash transfer speed to FX?

27 Apr 2004, 02:51
Hi guys,

Has anoyone tested the transfer speed of sample data _from_ a _ultra_ or _ultra II_ Compact Flash card with the FX?

BTW I noticed last night while uploading a .wav file to the FX that it took less time to upload to the Card than to the (sample?) RAM. For a 6MB file it took 36 seconds to RAM and 15 seconds to the card. Any idea why this would be?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Ultra Compact Flash is faster!

30 Apr 2004, 06:37
In case anyone else is interested, Garth from ChickenSys software was kind enough to forward my question to the Roland product manager for the Fantom and this was his response:

"I [product manager] have not tested yet, but [the engineer] indicates that the Ultra CF cards should be approx. 40% faster than the standard CF cards, per the Ultra specification. Also, I have a 1GB MicroDrive that appears to be up to 20%
faster than standard CF in some tests."

This is important to know for anyone who is planning to use large samples with his Fantom-X. Get ULTRA Compact Flash instead of regular compact flash if you want to speed up load times. No word yet about ULTRA II cards.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: PC card with Ultra Compact Flash transfer speed to FX?

30 Apr 2004, 12:02
I'm interested in learning more about the Micro Drives. Is 1 gig the limit of Micro Drive size...or just a limitaion of the Fantom X architecture? It sounds as if this the equivilent of installing a hard disc in the X, though a small one at that. BUt I wonder how fast they come?

Ron

Re: PC card with Ultra Compact Flash transfer speed to FX?

30 Apr 2004, 12:47
I know of several people who had micro drives for their cameras and 2 out of 3 died shortly after a year.

I love the concept of the microdrive, but I think compact flash is going to be more rugged. If you want another aspect of miniature hard disk reliability look at all of the new MP3 players and how many of those people have had drives die. My ipod drive died after 18 months.

Microdrives go up to 6 GIG I think for about $300. Fantom-X should be able to utilize all of the space, but you will have to do the project folder swapping trick Lawrence came up with.

Hope this helps...
Korg Oasys
Roland MV-8800

Re: PC card with Ultra Compact Flash transfer speed to FX?

30 Apr 2004, 14:23
MIDIGuru is correct. I have performed some limited tests with two 2 GB CF+ microdrives in my Fantom-X8 and can confirm that the Fantom recognizes the additional space. However, it seems that accessing the space, either because of a defect in the microdrive I'm using (quite possible) or in how the Fantom-X addresses space, the Fantom-X will frequently report that the card is either unformatted or, when trying to format it, that the card area is damaged.

I need to do further tests with different size microdrives. I cannot report for certain any speed increases. I have a 4x 64 MB real compact flash card that I've been using for a control test (4x = 150 kB/s x 4 = min. 600 kB/s transfer speed guaranteed). I can tell you that when the 2 GB microdrive is inserted (via the same PC card adaptor) into my laptop, it seems to work fine (except for after having been formatted by the Fantom).

I measured transfer rates of about 1.6 MB/s write and 1.5 MB/s read times with the microdrive in the computer. I measured about 1 MB/s read and write time with the 64 MB CF card in the computer.

In my audio importing tests with the 64 MB CF card on the Fantom, load times are SIGNIFICANTLY lower than 600 kB/s (generally around 100 to 150 kB/s). This may be due to the Fantom converting from AIFF/WAV format to a usable audio format inside the Fantom, though I tend to doubt it since saving native samples and reloading them takes place quite slowly as well (around the same transfer rate).

Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/
Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/

Re: PC card with Ultra Compact Flash transfer speed to FX?

30 Apr 2004, 22:14
In the hopes of speeding up load/save times I took my regular Sandisk 512 CF card back to Bestbuy and got the Ultra II. I tried it and got about the same 500KB/s read speed as the standard CF card. Very dissapointing.

One thing to note: I have the "regular" Sandisk PC card adapter. There is a special PC card adapter for Ultra/Extreme CF cards, but nobody has them. I looked all over town (Circuit Ciity, Best Buy, Staples, Compusa). Nobody seems to have them online either.

I sure would like to know if this adapter is different. I get the impression that all these adapters do is connect the wiring of the PC card connector to the CF (no active electronics on it, just wiring).

I found a website that tests CF cards (www.robgalbraith.com) and they have a pretty good forum discussing PC card adapters. Apparently the adapter is the bottleneck causing the slow transfer rates. If Fantom-X supports cardbus we may have more options.

Can someone ask Roland if the card slot is 16 bit or 32 bit (card bus compatible). In the meantime I will try to find the Ultra adapter and run more testing...
Korg Oasys
Roland MV-8800

Re: PC card with Ultra Compact Flash transfer speed to FX?

30 Apr 2004, 22:49
All indications are that the Fantom-X only implements the PCMCIA standard and does not support CardBus 32 bit addressing. See the discussion in this forum regarding this at

http://forum.fantomized.info/index.php?action=show_thread&thread=2581&fid=5&page=last

Yes, PCMCIA is a bottleneck, though this bottleneck is a bit higher than 500 kB/s (I used a PCMCIA CF+ adapter in my Mac G4 laptop and got about 1.5 MB/s from a microrive copying a 108 MB file).

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/
Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/

Re: PC card with Ultra Compact Flash transfer speed to FX?

1 May 2004, 05:15
> I'm interested in learning more about the Micro Drives. Is
> 1 gig the limit of Micro Drive size...or just a limitaion of the
> Fantom X architecture?

A while ago we had some threads on several collective questions that were relayed to a Roland rep by FatBoyJim. I cannot find all those threads but I remember that the Roland rep told us that the 1GB limit is in the brochure simply because there were no larger cards available for testing at that time (when they wrote the brochure/specs) and that it _may_ be possible to user larger cards as they become available. Obviously they will not claim it works until they have verified that it does.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: PC card with Ultra Compact Flash transfer speed to FX?

1 May 2004, 09:16
Here is some information on PCMCIA/PC card technology:

http://www.pcmcia.org/pccard.htm
http://www.pcmcia.org/faq.htm

Some quotes:

-------------------------------

"The only difference between the card types is thickness. The thicknesses are 3.3, 5.0, and 10.5 millimeters for Type I, Type II, and Type III cards respectively."

-------------------------------

"PC Card Standard-February 1995

The latest release of the PC Card Standard added information to improve compatibility and added support for features such as 3.3 volt operation, DMA support, and 32-bit CardBus busmastering. "

-------------------------------

What is the throughput of the PC Card interface?
Theoretical maximums are as follows:

CardBus (32 bit burst mode)
* Byte mode: 33 Mbytes/sec
* Word mode: 66 Mbytes/sec
* DWord mode: 132 Mbytes/sec

16-bit Memory Transfers (100 ns Minimum cycle)
* Byte mode: 10 Mbytes/sec
* Word mode: 20 Mbytes/sec

16-bit I/O Transfers (255 ns Minimum cycle)
* Byte mode: 3.92 Mbytes/sec
* Word mode: 7.84 Mbytes/sec

Please note that actual throughput may be substantially less than the theoretical maximums of the interface.

-------------------------------
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X