Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software for

Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software for

10 Nov 2009, 08:57
UPDATE December April 5, 2010

I have just uploaded Fantom X Live Commander 0.7.5. Check out http://www.livecommander.com for a list of new features. Here's a screenshot of the new version:

Image

UPDATE December 24, 2009

I have just uploaded Fantom X Live Commander 0.7.0. Check out http://www.livecommander.com for a list of new features.

Enjoy and Merry Christmas!

UPDATE December 3, 2009

Fantom X Live Commander version 0.5 can now be downloaded from

http://www.livecommander.com

Have fun and let me know what you think. I have added copy&paste functions with full undo. You can also customize the keys or mouse buttons to use for advancing to the next or previous 'stage' (set of active sounds of the selected performance).
-------------------------------------------------


Hi everybody,

As some of you may know from this thread...

http://forums.rolandclan.info/index.php?action=show_thr...

...I have embarked on a mission to create the ultimate LIVE seamless switching solution for the Fantom using a Netbook. Or at least that would be the case if I had more time on my hands :-) But still, I have started working on this last Saturday and so far this is what I've come up with:

Image

First of all: it works and is functional (except for the 'User/Card' selector) but there's many things that can and should be improved.

Instead of controlling the Rx receive switch on the External page, as first pioneered by lazeeboy, I have decided (for now) to primarily control the KBD switch on the main Performance Layer page where you also set the keyboard range for each part. This is done by checking the required boxes in the kbd column.

The advantage of this is that it will turn on/off both internal parts as well as external parts played by external MIDI modules using the Fantom as the master keyboard. A small disadvantage is that Part 1 is the default when you select a Performance and that the internal Part that is the 'current' part will always respond, even if the KBD switch is off.

However, I have added an column int which has three options:

kbd: Internal part Rx switch is switched on/off along with the KBD switch
on: Internal part Rx switch is always on
off: Internal part RX switch is always off

So actually by default both the KBD and the Rx state are controlled by this program. So the disadvantage I just mentioned only applys to external modules that happen to receive on the channel for Part 1.

Of course I could duplicate the matrix for completely independent control of the KBD and Rx switch but that might make it difficult to keep an overview of what is going, especially if you put this on different tabs/screens but on the other hand I had to fit it all on one screen a touchscreen interface would probably become too small.

If you select a Performance on the Fantom the software automatically retrieves the Performance and Patch names from the fantom. Conversely you can also select a Performance through this software using the second dropdown box (has '1' in it in the screenshot).

The yellow bar is drawn around the current active column.

The Get state and Set state buttons can be used during programming to get the KBD state from the Fantom for all parts to the active column and vice versa.

Hitting >> will advance to the next column and if you enable [x] Auto set (LIVE play mode) the software will automatically transmit the KBD and Rx settings to the Fantom as defined by the check boxes. This is how you'd normally use it when playing live. You can hit > one time too many).

All settings are automaticallt stored to disk, there is no separate save function nor is it needed. I'm a little worried about the file size because I'm using .NET built-in support for persisting objects and the file gets relatively large compared to what's actually in it.

Like I said there are several things to do: fill the Program Select box with all the actual Performance names instead of just numbers 1-127. The screen layout could be optimized a bit more and there's lots of other things that I forgot.

I've seen people here using Photoshop to paint fantasy Fantom X/G interfaces so come, let me have your ideas how to make this the ultimate live switching solution. I will have to stop working on it for a few days as I have to start using it for our rehearsal next Friday. I'm sure I will have received many suggestions by then.

I will eventually release the source code but it's currently too messy so I'd like to do a little cleaning up before I upload it. There's also some problem that keeps the program from terminating completely, probably something to do with not properly shutting down the MIDI driver connection but I haven't looked into it yet.

Oh and btw the software should run on any XP, Vista or Windows 7 system, it doesn't have to be a netbook and it doesn't need a touchscreen either. In fact for live playing you can just hit the space bar to advance to the Rx/KBD colum.

On that subject, I'd still like recommendations for a Netbook, preferrably one that has no moving parts and does have a touch screen.

I've got my eyes set on an Asus EEE PC T91 which can be folded to act as a tablet PC but as luck would have it they have just released the T91MT which does multi-touch and runs Windows 7. It also has 32GB SSD instead of 16GB plus max 2GB RAM instead of 1GB (1GB is installed). Only trouble is I need it _now_ but it's not yet available in stores here. Perhaps I'll end up taking a regular PC to the next rehearsal while waiting for this thing to become available.

Have fun,
Arjan
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

10 Nov 2009, 09:04
Arjan, thanks for your work, I will post this in our news!

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

10 Nov 2009, 09:27
Just so you know, I haven't actually uploaded the software yet, not even an executable. That may have to wait until next week after I do some more cleaning up and testing.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

10 Nov 2009, 09:45
@ Arjan

A genius @ work!
This would be great to have this in the Fantom itself (OS). But what you have done is great.

Congratulation. Roland should hire you!

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

10 Nov 2009, 10:26
This would be great to have this in the Fantom itself (OS)


That version is called Fantom G :-) Seriously though, if the G had had support for SRX one way or another and Roland would fix and improve it in some other areas I'd trade in my X for a G in no time and not bother writing something like this. But the way things are I still prefer the X, mainly because of the SRX cards that I have.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

10 Nov 2009, 13:57
Nice work Arjan!
This seems like a neet tool!

If you want help, I would be happy to help you with the coding or with the design on my spare time.

I would also like to suggest to add a module that can handle an input from either a serial, USB or midi port that would be use to switch the presets instead of clicking on the screen or hit on the space bar.
So somebody could easily build a pedal module to interact with your software.

Let me know if you want something from me!
Phil

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

10 Nov 2009, 15:17
Phil,

In the other thread I suggest that a relatively easy way to let it respond to pedals would be to butcher a cheap old USB mouse and wire the pedal to the left, middle or right buttons on the mouse on the PCB. I will certainly look into ways to make the software respond to external events. Of course responding to MIDI events is a no-brainer so if you have a pedal that can transmit MIDI. I'm open for all other suggestions.

At this point I'm particularly interested in well thought out ideas on the GUI, especially in relation to keeping the interface simple but at the same time flexible enough to allow it be used for any application. I have plenty of ideas for alternative interfaces but they are just rough ideas, not true designs.

The coding itself borders on the trivial. Maybe if you have some concrete ideas what sort of USB devices to let it respond to (other than Frankenmice or Frankenkeyboards turned into pedals) and know how to code support for that. But before I hand this code over to anyone I should really clean it up a little.

Some ideas I currently have but didn't have time to implement yet:

Initialization:
- auto-check what physical MIDI ports the Fantom is connected to and indicate connection status visually
- auto-check what the Performance Control Channel is
- auto-check if the Fantom is set to respond to bankselect and program change message and offer to turn these on if they are not

Use:
-add more support for other non-Fantom gear. For example allow the name of the Patch to be overwritten if the internal part is turned off.

There's some other things that I forgot but they will come to me once I start using this thing.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

10 Nov 2009, 15:57
Hey Arjan,

As for the pedal thing, I was thinking about the project I did which sends midi messages when I press one of the four pedals i have. Now this thing is customized for my use with my setup, but it could work with your software easily with slight changes in my code.

Also, if you design your software so it can respond to midi messages, people could use it with something like Roland's FC-300 midi foot controller or any other pedal of this kind. (or something like this: http://www.midisolutions.com/prodfsw.htm) It could also respond to midi messages coming from a midi controller keyboard which has assignable buttons. Or maybe even respond to midi messages sent by pressing the pads on the X? (don't know if this is possible though since I own a Fantom XR only)

Just ideas...

As for serial interface it would be also nice so if somebody wants to build a custom pedal box using a serial connection to a computer it could be fine as well. As for USB, I never really played with that on the embedded side so I don't know, but it could be nice to have too.

I'm really looking foward to see your software in action!

Phil

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

10 Nov 2009, 16:42
people could use it with something like Roland's FC-300


I have one of those, it was an earlier attempt at better live switching. However I found it somewhat cumbersome and limiting and I found it difficult to press the pedals at just the right time. I'd prefer pedals that offer more resistance and give a sudden 'click'.

All the other stuff you mention is possible too without much effort I think. Responding to MIDI events is definitely a go. You could even use some of the lower keys on the keyboard to switch sounds if you don't need them.

Even the Fantom Pads could be used but they suffer from the same problem as the FC-300 pedals imho: lack of both tactile and visual feedback. Of course with this software visual feedback is provided but it would typically be on the other side of the keyboard so that's not really what you want. I don't know if it's possible to turn on/off the pad lights, haven't really checked yet but I don't think it can be done or lazeeboy would probably have used it.

As for the serial interface, this software runs on a computer so there are other ways than serial to communicate with yet another computer if that's what you want to do. I asssume that netbooks have ethernet and often wireless onboard.

I've been cleaning up the code a bit (removing lots of stuff from unrelated experiments like the pitch rounder for my ribbon controller) and have fixed the issue with it not shutting down completely. Very happy about that because for live use it better be reliable.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

11 Nov 2009, 07:20
Hello Arjan,

Great work. Would you consider a mac version? I'd be interested in tinkering around with the source code, granted that's ok with you.

FX rules!

Samuel
I bring more than a song

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

11 Nov 2009, 07:51
Would you consider a mac version?


It's Microsoft .NET based, I have zero programming experience on Macs, I don't have any access to a Mac and too little time on my hands. That's all just a rounadabout way of saying no ;-)

But feel free to have a stab at it yourself once I release the source code. At least you won't have to re-invent the SysEx sequences to get and set parameters on the Fantom but the framework and GUI will probably be totally useless to you.

Perhaps you could run it in a Windows VM like Parallels but I'm not sure if the Macs MIDI ports are available to applications running in the VM. If they are you may not have to port or rewrite anything. I read something about virtualized USB access so it may be possible. if you use a USB MIDI interface and basically let the Windows drivers for the USB MIDI device inside the VM talk to the USB interface.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

11 Nov 2009, 12:44
Implemented a 'Soft MIDI THRU' feature today which allows forwarding the MIDI data stream that is received from the Fantom to any available MIDI out port.

I needed this function because my JP-8000 doesn't have it's own MIDI THRU port and I have a bunch of other gear that needs to be daisy chained to the Fantom OUT for setting them up with the correct sounds when I change the Performance on the Fantom.

Tomorrow I hope to start using this thing for real.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

12 Nov 2009, 05:42
Guys (and gals, if any),

Some input on the following please. Used it this morning to setup a song and found out that using the KBD switch has one drawback: it actually cuts off the internal sound engine.

Two alternatives exist: use the Rx switch or set the Key Range to something like C0-C0. The latter would also affect external modules, the former doesn't. if I do change the Keyoard range this way I'd have to make sure to restore it too when you advance to the next phase where the part is turned on again.

Using the Rx switch will work just fine for internal sounds but if you also want to play and control an external module on that same channel/part you will still have to use either KBD or Key Range to turn off the external part, unless you connect the external modules to the soft midi through output of the FXLC. I'm not sure I'm comfortable with that, I'd rather have the FXLC be the last in the chain: Fantom out ->module->module->FLXC.

Opinions/suggestions?

I have also though about the following. Instead of the current interface with checkboxes I could also implement a kind of tri-state checkbox:

[off]
[external]
[both]

This could be some color-and-shape coded checkbox type control. Clicking on it will cycle through these three options. It's not possible to support [internal] (only) unless you again use the FLXC to filter out the note on/off events that the Fantom will send even if you have KDB on and Rx off. Correct me if I'm wrong.

There are acutally some other filters that I could use like not setting hold pedal info to the external module which could be handy if you are holding a bass note in the lower octaves with your hold pedal but want to play a non-sustained sound on the upper octaves through an external module. The filter page on the Fantom only applies to the internal parts so that won't help you. Again this would require FXLC to be the first device connected to the Fantom MIDI out.

I could do something like this perhaps:

KBD switch is always ON

[off] Set KBD range to C0-C0 turn off both internal and external without internal cutting off
[external] Rx=off, restore KBD range
[both] Restore KBD range if necessary, turn Rx=on
[int] Rx=on, restore KBD range if necessary, filter out MIDI events (warn user that FXLC must be first in chain)

Let me have your thoughts please.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

12 Nov 2009, 06:15
Another approach would be:


Part....Sound source
1.........[internal/external].........[ ]....[ ].....[ ]
2.........[internal/external].........[ ]....[ ].....[ ]
3.........[internal/external].........[ ]....[ ].....[ ]

If sound source is set to internal the [ ] checks control Rx.
If sound source is set to external the [ ] checks control KBD
Having both internal and external is not supported in this scheme, the user is repsonsible for selecting a muted patch on the external module if the part is set to [internal] (or again FXLC could filter out note on/off events if it's the first in the chain).

If sound source is set to [external] it might be possible to let the user type a custom name for that part since he won't be playing the internal part anyway.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X Live Commander - LIVE sound switching software

12 Nov 2009, 06:30
And here's yet another wild idea:

Instrument Sound generator On/off
....1......................[Part 2 (internal)]........................[ ].......[ ].......[ ].......[ ]
....2......................[MIDI channel 5 (external].........[ ].......[ ].......[ ].......[ ]
....3......................[Par 5 (internal]...........................[ ].......[ ].......[ ].......[ ]
....4......................[.....not used....]...........................[ ].......[ ].......[ ].......[ ]

So here we dispense completely with the 1:1 relation between rows in the interface and Fantom parts or MIDI channels. Instead you can add 'instruments' and and instrument can be either an internal part or an external midi channel (which still requires a parts keyboard zone to transmit data,although if the FXLC is the first connected tot he Fantom it could use data from one part/channel and convert (channel/transpose etc) and transmit it to whatever exernal channels are enabled). The checkboxes only control that particular instrument. This way FXLC becomes a kind of advanced MIDI router/translator.

This would be much more work and trickier to implement so it would be something for version 2.0.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X