Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Piano Sounds

Re: Piano Sounds

6 Nov 2009, 14:09
Why are you bumping an obvious fail? It's unanimous -- too long to load, ru mad at someone expensive, and not new or original.

It sounded more interesting before you started defending it. Not to discourage you, I think there is room for another piano sample out there, but take what you've read and make it happen at a realistic price(you're not East/West).

Re: Piano Sounds

6 Nov 2009, 20:58
I think you misread my intention. I just bumped the topic once since i wanted to give the matter some more time, like two more weeks before deciding anything. I apreciate your comment, i just think it was a little harsh.
If there's no objection for forum members i would like this post to live a bit more. Thank you for your understanding.

Re: Piano Sounds

6 Nov 2009, 23:41
You bumped the thread to get more feedback, even though there hasn't been any positive response yet?

I didn't mean to sound overly harsh, fail is just one of those words.

The real insult, IMO, was the price. Why would your sampled piano be better for me than SRX-02? The challenges you have are pretty obvious.

That said, I support the effort by keeping the discusion going a few more hours ;)

ps. I really do like the idea and as I recall those free samples at the uni really are jacked.

Re: Piano Sounds

7 Nov 2009, 05:46
@dbijoux, by "jacked" do you mean good or bad?

I'd looked at those samples, but don't have time to create three multisamples from them (p, mf, ff or whatever they are) and then to create a patch or more from them.

Andy
Andy

Re: Piano Sounds

7 Nov 2009, 07:10
@dbijoux

Yeah, I just can't live without the balloon pop samples.

Hehehe

:)

Re: Piano Sounds

7 Nov 2009, 14:13
I didn't download them all, it was a bit ago I checked it out, but found the same as karloserio was saying, the samples need work before they'd be ready(chopping, etc.) Too much for me too, especially if not really good samples. They could have at least made a .zip file for each instrument. C'est la vie - they are free.

Yes, the ballon pop! Next to the missing Bach Chorales. Strange kids out there in Iowa.

Re: Piano Sounds

7 Nov 2009, 14:28
We knew about these samples (Iowa free ones) over 5 years ago, and even though the quality seems high at the first glance, later on you realize that the recording levels were very low, and when you bring them up you get way too much noise and this renders them totally useless. Not to mention that you'd need to do a lot of chopping and fading out to construct a multisample - but the sounds are not worth it at all.

Re: Piano Sounds

11 Nov 2009, 02:48
Artemey

I have no clue how you came up with so many ridiculous and unfounded statements concerning Coakley Pianos. How do you see quality “at first glance” and then suddenly discover you were wrong and the piano is “useless.” The pianos are gorgeous and they satisfy the most demanding keyboardists all over the world. But for you as an admin to disparage ANYONE’S product and misrepresent it to the public is worthy of your removal as admin. Shame on you.

You say the recording levels were very low and you speak of noise …but if you had an authentic version with a serial number you would know there is absolutely no noise. And making a multi-sample? What on earth for? Unless you got a scrambled bootleg version. The pianos are “fire and forget” and they equal anything Sony records can produce for a piano sound. Even the demos on “williamcoakley.com” show a much different story than you are telling here.

I will expect you to withdraw these unreasonable and unfounded comments saying “they aren’t worth it at all” or I will file a complaint with Roland for your trolling the board. Although it may be your board, I will be at the trade show to make sure Roland hears about it.

Re: Piano Sounds

11 Nov 2009, 03:27
@Coakley Pianos:

I don't want to speak for Art, but to me it was clear that he was talking about the samples from Iowa university, not yours....

Grandpa

Re: Piano Sounds

11 Nov 2009, 04:55
@ Coakley Pianos!
The pianos are gorgeous and they satisfy the most demanding keyboardists all over the world. . . The pianos are “fire and forget” and they equal anything Sony records can produce for a piano sound.


Sounds like a great advertising scheme to me!! (although, I'm not sure that falsely accusing the Owner and Administrator of this forum of defamation is the best way to go about achieving your goal! LOL!

sRa

Image
sRa

[img]http://www.piaknow.com/vacation/Animation%201.gif[/img]

Re: Piano Sounds

11 Nov 2009, 05:50
I read that as being aimed at the FREE University of Iowa samples, too, not Coakley. I don't remember any significant criticism of the Coakley pianos on this forum by anyone beyond some people's personal tastes in piano sounds.

Regards
Andy
Andy

Re: Piano Sounds

11 Nov 2009, 12:07
@ Coakley Pianos!
First post, nice threatening tone, and completely unfounded.
Perhaps you'll be apologizing to Artemiy....

Good job.
What we record in life, echoes in eternity.

Re: Piano Sounds

11 Nov 2009, 12:14
Coakley Pianos:

I am sorry but how can talk like that to the **forum administrator**?

Especially since you have no understanding of my post. You should follow the discussion with more attention, my friend. I was not talking about William's pianos, but about the free samples from the Iowa University website (or whatever it's called).

You're putting shame on William's works when you talk with such a tone publicly. I am not sure if he would appreciate such attitude. I patiently wait for your apologies. Oh and you misspelled my name too.

Artemey

I have no clue how you came up with so many ridiculous and unfounded statements concerning Coakley Pianos. How do you see quality “at first glance” and then suddenly discover you were wrong and the piano is “useless.” The pianos are gorgeous and they satisfy the most demanding keyboardists all over the world. But for you as an admin to disparage ANYONE’S product and misrepresent it to the public is worthy of your removal as admin. Shame on you.

You say the recording levels were very low and you speak of noise …but if you had an authentic version with a serial number you would know there is absolutely no noise. And making a multi-sample? What on earth for? Unless you got a scrambled bootleg version. The pianos are “fire and forget” and they equal anything Sony records can produce for a piano sound. Even the demos on “williamcoakley.com” show a much different story than you are telling here.

I will expect you to withdraw these unreasonable and unfounded comments saying “they aren’t worth it at all” or I will file a complaint with Roland for your trolling the board. Although it may be your board, I will be at the trade show to make sure Roland hears about it.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X