Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Piano Sounds

Piano Sounds

26 Oct 2009, 18:11
My subject is as follow: i have been developing my own piano sound and i'm thinking going the comercial way, making it available for everyone. The quality is excellent for a sound module, with a 3 layered sound comprising of 3 full sampled 88 key multisamples covering pp, mf and ff. Unfortunatly, such quality makes the loading time high, more or less 13,5 min.
The question is if this loading time will make the product uninteresting for users or not. Tell me your opinion.

Re: Piano Sounds

31 Oct 2009, 07:55
Its not too long, I always use a 10+ minutes to boot with a collection of samples from pianos, organs & strings. What type of piano is it sampled from? And what kind of price will it have? Any sound demos?

Re: Piano Sounds

1 Nov 2009, 21:06
The piano sound is still on the making, but i think it will be around 200 to 250 dollars. What i can say it's that it's going to have 3 layered, full sampled 88 keys with 10 seconds non-looped (some keys have shorter times, this is an average) .
I'm still in the first stage of this project since the next step is convincing thhe manufacturer that this is economically viable. I need more feedback at this point from Fantom x users.

Re: Piano Sounds

1 Nov 2009, 21:45
Hi Karlosserio,

Check it out!

Why do this when the 'X' series already contains a patch with a very high quality sample set containing 704 samples and 4 layers, not to mention that, in my opinion, the majority of Fantom X owners are very happy with the existing piano patches? Then there is the extended load time. (Around 44 Mb of sample data?) I, for one, would not find this single piano sample set to be tempting at ths price, even if the patch was exceptional. Sorry. Just a inquiry; not meant to discourage.

Cheers!
PiaKnowGuy
Please listen to 'Pirates' done entirely on the Fantom X8

Image
PiaKnow
PiaKnowGuy
Please feel free to listen to Pirates
[img]http://www.piaknow.com/1goldpiaknowlogonew-thumbnail-thumbnail.jpg[/img]
PiaKnow

Re: Piano Sounds

2 Nov 2009, 05:32
Thanks for your feedback on this. I know what your saying piaknowguy, piano sounds are personal choices and so what one musician likes is another musicians disapointment. For me i started this because i played a lot of good pianos in the Fantom X, but live when doing piano solo parts (especially classical orientated) they just fell short. Because of this i started to explore the sampled pianos. Now i have some good results, but wanted to share the product. The only problem is the Fantom x seems to be getting out-dated so if no interest is shown i'll not go the comercial way.

Re: Piano Sounds

2 Nov 2009, 05:40
Grandpa, answering your question about that freeware piano, that was one of my first choices. The problem is that you only can have one layer if i remember, because of the size of the library itself; aditionally the samples are untreated so you have a lot of diferences between samples of the same set.
I've seen some products and the first drawbacks is that most piano sample libraries have not been totally filtered, de-hissed and noise-to-sound ratio corrected. If you listen to individual sample of well know manufacturers sometimes you hear strangest things: door slaming; technician talking, mechanism clicks, etc. Just put headphones and crank the volume and you'll be amazed.

Re: Piano Sounds

2 Nov 2009, 08:34
At times I have looked at Perfect Piano from William Coakley which has a load time of around 5 minutes (I think) and sells for $349. Have you tried any of his libraries?

Re: Piano Sounds

2 Nov 2009, 09:43
I bought a second hand version, so i can't realy say it's legitimate. I contacted William after buying this thru ebay and he explained to me that due to intelectual property rights this buy would be consider illegal so he couldn't assist me. So i can't really comment because i don't know 100% if i have the original product or not.
But do a search and you'll find a topic i started with the "Perfect Piano" some months back.

Re: Piano Sounds

2 Nov 2009, 10:46
I don't want to deal with the issue of whether or not it is legitimate copy of the software. The original licence might not be transferable or perhaps it is transferable but without support however it looks from this link that you were able to install it. Funny enough, I responded to that thread but had forgotten that you had bought a second hand copy of it.

Anyhow, in your original post on this thread you asked whether we would find your product interesting given the cost and the time to load it. My response was more to do with that question. How do your pianos compare to his? A lot of people seem to not have the patience for the 5 - 6 minutes it takes for Perfect Piano to load so I wonder how many more people will lose patience if it takes 13 or more minute, even if your product is superior.

Re: Piano Sounds

2 Nov 2009, 11:39
Again i think i can't compare a product that i can't say i own. I can say that for me it wasn't the end of the road. The question you raise is my own too, for me having a more realistic piano makes me not to worry about a + - 13 min loading time, but maybe others have different opinions. My original post is to understand if this piano library is an interesting perspective or not. As a piano player and live performer i always try to excel with my gear, so having better piano sound was something i started as a personal project and ended up in a 7 months evolving project.

Re: Piano Sounds

3 Nov 2009, 21:31
well, if your purpose is realistic piano (I do mean only realistic, not musically impressive), I'm afraid you can't make one that's comparable with Roland's UltimatGrand patch. As I have pointed out previously, you, as a user, do not have access to certain edit settings, which help to creat a realistic piano patch. Or you may use the spare tone for the Above G5 ( or G6 as referred to in other system) behavior, this method is used by other Roland's piano patches, but then you don't have 3 layer samples at this area.

Re: Piano Sounds

3 Nov 2009, 21:54
compusic, you can use 4 or more layers by using the piano patch in a performance. I have an X6 and an S88 with SRX11 in it so after reading that other thread regarding that behaviour above G5 and testing it on my X6 I then simply put the piano patch I like into a performance and reduced the Part Release Time Offset for the part which plays above G5.

Re: Piano Sounds

3 Nov 2009, 23:27
The piano sounds are pretty subjective so i prefer staying with the first topic regarding interest in this project.
I can forward one data, the piano patch i'm working is using 380 mb of samples non-looped, so you can expect a lot of detail in there.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X