Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Controlling MFX with External Controller

Controlling MFX with External Controller

10 Mar 2009, 10:57
I use an original Roland AX-1 to control the fantom for some songs at live gigs. It tranmists on channel 2 and the fantom receives on channel 2 and it works fantastically well. I can select patches, control the volume, I'm very happy with it, except for one problem.

It has one knob which can be assigned to any midi controller, and by default it is set to [CC07:Volume].
This works for most patches, except for one that is going thru an MFX set to Guitar Amp Sim. (For example like in PRST06: Burning Lead)

Most of you probably already know that with the Guitar Amp Sim, for a smooth, acceptable volume curve, the volume needs to be controlled after the MFX, not before. Using controller [CC07:Volume] changes the volume BEFORE the MFX, and it is unacceptable - the difference from loud to soft is not smooth at all.
Also I cannot reach the Master Volume on the fantom when playing the AX-1.

Ideally i need to be able to control the level of the MFX.

So what I did was change the AX-1's knob to send [CC02:Breath] messages.
Accordingly, in the effects section in MFX Ctrl, SOURCE was set to CC02: Breath, and DESTINATION set to Level.
Of course MFX control channel is set to 2.

And does it work? ......
Of course not.

I've tried all the possible Sens settings.

Sens=0 No effect
Sens=+63 Causes something to happen, although it definately does not sound like level is changing. It sounds like its opening and closing a filter.
Sens=-63 Causes it to work as desired but in reverse: meaning volume up = level down, which is also unacceptable because i need to switch between sounds and this can cause some killer volume placements.

I've also tried other midi messages such as CC16:General-1 but this gives the same result.


Guys i know this is a rather tough one. It's got me completely stumped.
That red AX-1 is best suited to the guitar amp simmed sounds, but having no volume control over these makes it rather impractical which is a tragedy really.

To try and figure out a solution to this, someone would only need an external controller that has an assignable knob.

Any help would be hugely appreciated and if it works ill be eternally grateful.

Johnnykeys1978

PS I learned EVERYTHING about my fantom here. EVERTHING. I reckon even my job in the local music shop selling rolands was partly because of you guys.
This is my first post. Its the first time i have not been able to find the answer in previous answers.
How disappointing.

"PS I learned EVERYTHING about my fantom here."

Except how to control mfx externally ;D

Re: Controlling MFX with External Controller

29 Mar 2009, 22:50
Have we ignored you for 20 days? Sorry ;)

Is your remote keyboard switch set to "on"? I am not near my X right now so I cant test it at this moment but I think that may be the problem.

Re: Controlling MFX with External Controller

30 Mar 2009, 07:04
Judging by your description it should work.

Are you sure you are selecting the correct multiFX slot in the MFX control page (MFX1 or MFX2 in patch mode, MFX1, MFX2 or MFX3 in Performance mode)? To scroll through the available slots you have to press F4 repeatedly. You can see the currently selected slot on the Upper Left part of the display.

Paolo

Re: Controlling MFX with External Controller

30 Mar 2009, 22:21
I just checked this myself and it will work if you do one of two things. If you go to the USB tab in the system menu you might see that USB is set to MIDI. If this is so then the standard MIDI in is ignored as your keyboard is set to listen to USB MIDI in. So you either set USB to storage and then the standard MIDI port will work. Alternatively, set the Remote Keyboard switch to on as I said in my last post. This is found on the MIDI tab on the System menu.

Let us know if you get this to work for you.

Ok tried those... but...

3 Apr 2009, 00:58
Thankyou very much for getting back to me howardS and geppastro.

I finally have a chance to have all my gear here set up again and test your ideas.

*Remote keyboard switch - I did not have that set to on, however, when on, i seem to get the same result, which is:

Unable to control MFX (with the exception of it working in reverse when sens is set to -63, which is unnacceptable, but still able to perfectly control faders in the mixer screen with CC:07)

I did notice also with that with the remote keyboard switch on it takes all incoming midi data from the AX-1 (regardless of channel) and plays it on the channel that is currently selected on the fantom.

What really boggles me is that it works backwards with sens set to -63. This suggests to me that at least the AX-1 is talking to the MFX.

*USB is already set to midi.
I have a new audio/midi interface by Phonic with the good old fashioned 5-pin midi connectors. ;D

*Selecting correct MFX slot
I am 100% certain that i have this correct, although I can see how it could be easily overlooked so thankyou for your idea geppastro. :)

JK

Re: Controlling MFX with External Controller

3 Apr 2009, 07:40
Try setting USB to Storage? You will see from the diagram on the USB Tab in the System menu that is you leave it set to MIDI that the incoming MIDI path from the standard 5 pin port appears to be ignored. Give that a try.
*USB is already set to midi.............uh oh
What I meant was "already set to storage", but i typed midi by mistake. Whoopsie... sorry to make you repeat yourself howardS :)

*USB is already set to storage.
(thats better)

JK

Re: Controlling MFX with External Controller

3 Apr 2009, 23:30
If -63 works as desired except in reverse then my next guess is that you have set your level in the MFX screen to a high amount. So all that +63 can do is send the level from where it is to maximum. If you set it to 50 then you can only go from 50 to 127. If you set it to 0 then your pedal should take it from 0 to 127.
Mr. HowardS, you sir, are a genius.

Thankyou so very much, you were correct in suggesting that i set the level lower to begin with.
I guess i didnt really understand how the sens worked and now i do.
Thanks again i owe you a beer!

Ill post a video of me playing this at a gig when i can get a friend to film it next. :)

JK

Re: Controlling MFX with External Controller

5 Apr 2009, 08:54
That's great. I am glad it worked out. I also learned so much from this this forum. I look forward to watching that performance video.

Howard

Re: Controlling MFX with External Controller

20 Sep 2009, 09:03
Well i ...finally... remembered to get someone to film the keytar at a gig.

Its about a minute long.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=myZN5gICqzk

Thankyou again HowardS for your solution... all those months ago :)

EDIT: Another video with the keytar playing the fantom.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RXow4HzhaU

That keytar is fast becoming my favourite "instrument" now that it has a fantom to squeal on. :)

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X