Fantom-S and Fantom-X

X8 bouncy keys.

X8 bouncy keys.

10 May 2005, 07:08
Hi,

I'm new to this forum, and hopefully by this weekend, a new fantom owner. I had been waiting on the Alesis Fusion, but decided that the Fantom is more for me.

I spent nearly an hour playing around on the X8 this past Saturday. Sweetwater Sound is located here in my home town, making it convenient to have a good listen to new gear.

Although I like weighted piano keys, normally, the X8's board seemed sluggish and bouncy. The keys feel like they're rebounding off rubber, and actually double triggered a few notes as they bounce my finger up and then back down.

I had decided to fall back to the X7. But! My local shop has a X8 demo unit that they'll sell me for the same price as the X7..

Do any of you X8 owners have any long term critical thoughts about the X8's board? I wonder if I would, over time, get used to it and overcome my complaints about it. I sure know my hands would strengthen! After playing it for an hour, they were burning and sore the next day...

Q.

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

10 May 2005, 08:23
I agree with you, i used to own the Yamaha S80 which had a very nice feel to it, and have played the Yamaha Motif ES8 which has a superior keyboard feel also
(in my opinion)
Was almost tempted to buy the ES8 but decided on the X8 because i just preferred the sounds in general, and its other features, colour screen, more user friendly etc etc, expansion capabilities...



Wayne

Professional Keyboardist in UK`s Number 1 Tribute To Bon Jovi

www.wayneharris.co.uk

www.bongiovi.co.uk
Keyboardist in Bon Giovi

www.bongiovi.co.uk

www.wayneharris.co.uk

http://www.youtube.com/profile_videos?user=Waynester1973

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

10 May 2005, 09:33
If you were referring to the older Roland RD range I would agree about the bouncyness but the FX/RD700SX is a new keybed. It's not as firm as the Yamahas but I find the action suits me.

I got the X8 for hardly any more money than the the X7 so it was a lot of keyboard for the money, but weight was still a consideration. However, the feel of that action swung it for me.

It's a decision only you can make - we are all different in what suits us.

Either way, you will have a stimulating, intuitive, expressive piece of kit under your hands, not to mention a recording studio. I've done more stuff with this board in 3 weeks than for years. (I'm sure it's thinking for itself now!)

FantomX8, V-Combo, JV-90
FantomX7, V-Combo, JV-90
SRX-07

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

10 May 2005, 11:28
I have an X8 and a Yamaha GH1FP grand piano. I bought the Yamaha brand new in August 2003 and the X8 new in Sept. 2004. I play on both nearly every day. When I was deciding between the X8, the ES8, and the Triton Studio, I was interested in 2 main things: true piano feel and true piano sound. Several other things like sequencer ease of use, expandability, flexibility, ease of changing setups/layers/splits, programming performances, etc. were also important of course, but feel and sound were 95% of my decision.

I auditioned all three workstations extensively and for me & my ten fingers and two ears, the X8 had the overall best combination of "true-to-life" grand piano feel and sound of the 3 workstations.

At least once a month, I go down to my local piano store and play on their Schimmels, Boesendorfers, and Yamahas. I can now really tell the distinct difference between the Schimmel feel and the Boesendorfer feel (I like the Schimmel better, maybe someday if I win the Lottery!). I also go to my local Guitar Center on a regular basis and still sit down in front of the big 3 workstations and play on them. Back in February 2005, when I had to get my motherboard replaced, I was a little upset, but Roland treated me very, very well. I can honestly say that today I have absolutely no regrets on selecting the X8.

Bottom line here is that although I'm by no means any "expert" or official "authority" on the subject, I am very glad I got the X8. For me, it really does have the best overall value for what I am looking for, and the recent audio track expansion and new patches is like icing on the cake!

---------------------------
Learning to play like Sponge Bob !
---------------------------
When most people go to work they work. When musicians go to work they play. Which do you prefer?

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

10 May 2005, 13:06
I must agree, the main reason i bought an Fantom X8 was also because of the action, it feels just like my old Acoustic Piano and when i tried the big three out i was easily pulled towards the X8 rather than the ES8's weighted action, it just felt more real to me and heavier, i found es8s to light and more bouncy...

Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

10 May 2005, 15:17
I tried the Triton and the Yammy weighted boards and rejected both within a couple of mins. I chose the X8 because of its action - to me it just felt better. Also the keyboard sounds great and i've not been disappointed. I think its been said before in here a few hundred times, but go for what you feel is right for you and don't ponder over reviews in retrospect.



Matthew

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

11 May 2005, 00:13
I enjoy the weighted action, they don't feel sluggish or bouncy, thats personal opinion; I guess, and have not double triggered any notes. If you don't like the action, wether the 8 is the same price or not, go for the 7. If however you feel you could get used to the 'progressive hammer action' (as roland calls it) buy the 8.

To summurize: If you really don't like the action buy the 7 regardless of the price, the force will help you make the right decision, go with your instincts young Luke.

X8 with Audio Expansion and Lovin' it like the Lovin' Spoonful.

Good Luck!
Cragglerock X8 - Audio Exp...

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

11 May 2005, 01:35
first of all before asking make sure you go and try it out, because when it really depends on what pianos your comfortable with, i was playing a Bosendorfer at a Store downtown and it wasnt very comfortable to me sounded great, then i tried the steinway and it felt much nicer..

Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

11 May 2005, 07:11
On the day I went to buy my keyboard I still had to make the decision between the X7 and X8. Until that day I hadn't tried the X8. When I did (coming from a non-piano background) the first thing I noticed was the 'heavy' keys and a sort of slimy feel to the keys too, a bit slipery. Well, I ended up shutting my eyes and taking a leap towards the X8 - I haven't looked back. I spend 75% of my time in Piano Mode and I believe the feel of the keys allow me to be a lot more expressive, especially with the jazz numbers I enjoy playing. The 'bounce' that was mentioned before is, in my opinion, a good bounce :)

Okay, only complaint is (and I knew about this when I compared the X7 and X8 in-store so I'm not disappointed) I think that aftertouch is more difficult to achieve with the X8 - though there is probably a setting somewhere that I haven't discovered yet.

~
Roland Fantom X8
DP-8, EV-5, 128MB PC-150
replacing my
Casio CTK-601
~
Roland Fantom X8 w/ Audio Track Expansion 2.02, SRX-05 (Supreme Dance) & SRX-10 (Big Brass Ensemble) replacing my Casio CTK-601
DP-8, EV-5, 128MB PC-150, SRX-05 (Supreme Dance), SRX-10 (Big Brass Ensemble)
Yamaha HS80M Powered Monitor Speakers

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

13 May 2005, 12:33
I have my X8 parked right next to to my baby grand. An acoustic piano by nature always has had a bouncy feel to me. I don't know how to describe it, real piano keys kind of float when you play them. The Roland while not as heavy of an action as my grand has that same "floating feeling" IMO.

I played a ensoniq TS12 for 10 years and though it was ok, it had a definate start stop feel...

I bought the X7 first and took it back. After having the TS12 and a real piano I just could not get used to the organ keys of the x7. X8 is a good blend of electronic and acoustic feel..

-PK
-PK
Mad-X,
Aftertouch sensitivity can be set in the main menu under System/Keyboard.

It's also set as a default for one of the realtime control knobs in performance mode. You can set it where you want on the fly to almost rediculous levels of sensitivity (should you want!)

FantomX8, V-Combo, JV-90
FantomX7, V-Combo, JV-90
SRX-07

Re: X8 bouncy keys.

14 May 2005, 17:05
I had a Triton Studio 88 before the X8 and I found the keys on that too heavy, good for piano but not much else. I find the X8 keyboard to be a good compromise for piano/keyboard/synth sounds.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X