Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little revie

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

6 Feb 2005, 23:24
Whoa man.......First of all have you not heard the Ultimate Grand secondly have you not heard all the songs in the song section? haha if you want to bash please come with good info. Waynester has both a ES and a FX and he thinks the Fantom X's piano is amazing and he wants to buy the SRX-11 badly haha. Please dont bash unless you have good reason too. The Piano on the Fantom X that comes out of the box is amazing. Period. if you dont know how to setup your speakers ask how, but bashing saying it sounds like crap makes you look like an idiot no one else
PRS guitars
Mesa Boogie Amps
Roland Fantom X6

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

6 Feb 2005, 23:56
Sam, you have me wondering about how you manage to survive in this life.

You make a statement like "I am not the only one saying this", and "there have been several posts that stressed the disappointment with the piano patches in the fantom", as though your opinion and that of a few others who agree(d) with you is the end of the discussion, and that nobody else is entitled to their opinion because you, the "might arbiter of all piano sounds" have spoken!

Are you that stubborn about this issue that you cannot allow for such differences in opinion? You make these kinds of statements, but seemingly don't pay any attention to contrary opinions at all, even those who first had trouble with the Fantom piano, but managed to alter it to their taste or apply simple EQ changes (or whatever) to their liking.

As I have noted elsewhere on this forum, there are entire websites devoted to comparing sampled piano sounds. Please find your way around and note the varying opinions on this. For every person thinking that some piano sound is "the best ever", there are just as many who think it's not all that hot, or "sucks" or simply prefer something else.

I have a number of choices for pianos, for instance. Everything from hundred-megabyte samples running in Kontakt to SampleTankXL to the William Coakley "Perfect Piano" in my Ensoniq Halo. I don't like any of them as well as the FantomX, despite the fact that I have friends who prefer one or the other over the FantomX. It doesn't mean that any of us are stupid, tone-deaf or shills for any particular manufacturer. It just means that we are musicians with varying tastes.

You have your opinion, which you've continued to state over-n-over-n-over ad nauseum. You are entitled to your opinion, but please realize that it is an opinion, and others are entitled to theirs as well.

Please grow up and realize that you are not the "god of pianos", and a few posts that agree with you do not constitute holy writ, especially when many counter opinions exist.

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

7 Feb 2005, 00:03
I havent heard any bad comments on the Fantom X piano.....

Partho- BTD
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

7 Feb 2005, 00:30
Ok.. ok... why bother in argueing.... i didn't post my topic to create a war about the best piano sound... but to find a solution of my case... i do love the piano sound i recieve from my headphones... but i don't like the one i hear through the speakers... sounds totaly different.. i believe and (hope) it's a matter of configuration.. but what i can't believe is how much energy and words have been wasted to discuss something that will never get us to any point... why not use that energy in helping me in how to get.. through my speakers.. the sound i get through my headphones...

Antares_x
Antares_x

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

7 Feb 2005, 03:01
Well, let's start with the basics.

You say that you think the piano sounds great through the headphones. We can probably conclude one thing from this simple fact: the piano is a pretty good piano.

One of the first questions you might ask yourself is "OK, so what's different when I plug the Fantom X into some external amplification?"

The biggest thing that might be at issue - from what I can tell - is improper stereo separation. When you have headphones on, this is a no-brainer ... whatever come out of the Left speaker goes to your left ear, and the Right speaker goes to your left. Put your headphones on backwards sometime and notice how "weird" the piano sounds.

With external speakers this isn't so obvious. You need to be sure that the Right output goes to your right speaker (as you facr the keyboard) and that the Left output goes to the left speaker. (This might seem obvious, but please check it ... people screw this kind of thing up all of the time.) If you are runnning through a mixer, make sure that your inputs are panned hard-right and hard-left, or use the Left and Right inputs on a stereo channel.

From there, make sure that you are using decent monitors designed to reproduce a full range of sound. If you are using something like a surround-sound system, please disable any "simulated surround". Frankly, if you have more than 2 speakers (left & right) plus perhaps a subwoofer going, you are asking for sonic weirdness.

Understand the difference between the Fantom's "Ultimate Piano" and the pianos contained in some other workstations. The Fantom was designed to be an accurate rendering of a particular piano. Other workstations have ususally taken the approach of making an "impressive sounding piano patch". This usually means that they have a) applied a lot of compression to the patch to reduce it's overall dynamic range, and b) EQ'd the hell out of it (or applied other effects) to achieve some kind of really bright or resonant "presence" qualities not present in the original sample material.

When I play the Motif ES - for instance - I get a "really great piano sound", but not really a piano patch with a lot of dynamic range ot tonal variation compared to the Fantom X.

The Fantom is less compressed, and has greater variation in both timbre and loudness, IMHO. This is part of the reason why the Fantom seems to be more picky about having a properly setup sound system ... just like when amplifying "real" acoustic instruments.

Speaker placement is important, and even more so because the Fantom's "Ultimate Piano" is a true stereo patch. Improper speaker placement will result in an out-of-phase effect that is not all pleasant, and can rob the sound of some of it's character.

If you are using near-field studio monitors, I would suggest that they be placed approximately 6-feet or more apart, angled slightly in and at about ear level. Anything closer than that won't provide the proper separation, IMHO.

If you are using a P.A. System or dual keyboard amps (never use guitar or bass amps, please) you should place them at least 10 feet or mor apart. and pointing straight out. If you imagine the amps as two points of a triangle with equal-lenght sides, you should be positioned about right in front of the 3rd point.

These are a few tips. Experiment and see what you think.

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

7 Feb 2005, 12:09
Antares_x, first and foremost don't run the headphones out to your p.a. system. Use the obvious Line Outs. Even if you don't have a stereo p.a. still run both a and b out to two channels on your p.a. and turn the fantom volume all the way up and use your p.a. to control the volume. JMIO

Signed, "Nature is hard enough on us, let's not be hard on each other."
"Get a man drinkin' or get a man thinkin' he'll wind up looking for angles. Get a man smokin' or get a man chokin' he'll wind up looking for angels!"©2006 All rights reserved

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

7 Feb 2005, 16:21
Quote from dansgold: "The Fantom is less compressed, and has greater variation in both timbre and loudness, IMHO. This is part of the reason why the Fantom seems to be more picky about having a properly setup sound system ... just like when amplifying "real" acoustic instruments."

THANK YOU! Boy, that just makes so much sense!

For what it's worth, I just got my X8 and I'm running it into my VS2480 and then to my Mackie 824s.

The sound is incredible!!!!

I've never heard a better digital piano sound--yes, I'm a rookie at this, but not a rookie at listening to real pianos. And I LIKE WHAT I HEAR!!

Thank you, Roland!

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

7 Feb 2005, 19:47
Ok... i called roland today and got my answers....

Sound....:use monitors... better if they are synth monitors...


Aftertouch....: a fantom X8 personality.. it's hard like that and steep... those who say is not.. well looky you to get the keys to be like that... because.. the roland technician told me.. AT was like that on X8's...

so.. any recomendations for monitors? please.. a small ones... but reasonable quality and not so expensive.. with their own amp...

Antares_x
Antares_x

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

7 Feb 2005, 21:45
For inexpensive monitors which are a) Not crap, and b) Not too expensive, and c) Active/Self Powered:

Behringer 2031A

Re: Just Got my X8 and have some questions...(and a little r

8 Feb 2005, 00:46
thats umm really weird that the roland tech told you that lol....

Partho- BTD
Partho- BTD-
" Its not the Fall that kills you..........(thump) its the sudden stop at the end"- Vin Diesel

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X