Other gear

Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

28 Jan 2005, 17:23
Hey Synthguy;

I think you're a little off base here in prices, I bought the Fantom XR with 2 SRX cards, and I didn't even pay $1500.00 where do you get $1800 from, no wonder your total is $12,000.00 or more, you're shopping at the wrong place buddy.

Jimi Jones

Jimi Jones
Jimi Jones

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

28 Jan 2005, 17:35
Hey Synthguy;

Furthermore your prices on the Korg Karma are WAY OFF, my friend just bought a brand new Karma here in California for $1,850.00 out the door, you can get expansion cards for $150.00 now, Kurzweil K2600S is selling for $3,3300.00, a used Wavestation can be had for $350.00 they don't make these anymore so you're not buying one new, the Emu LIST for $599.00 but it doesn't sell for that amount, GET REAL OK.

Jimi Jones

Jimi Jones
Jimi Jones

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

28 Jan 2005, 17:37
Given that the OASYS is - in fact - a Pentium 4 2.8Ghz PC with a high-quality audio interface, running some softsynth/sequencer/DAW software, attached to a keyboard and control surfaces ... stacking up multiple keyboards and modules is not the closest comparsion. There's just too much duplication of DACs and other hardware to make it a realistic case.

ALSO: An exact comparison is likely impossible. Duplicating the exact functionality of the KARMA implementation is an example. Any reasonable comparision will have to be of similar, but not exact capability.

Here's a repost of a possible contender, as first post on TritonHaven:

M-Audio Keystation Pro88
Novation X-Station 61
Suitably Powerful Laptop
NI Komplete2 (FM7, B4, Kontakt, Absynth, Battery2, Pro53)
Tracktion2
Korg Legacy Collection (ditch the controller if you like)
G-Media ImpOSCar

... comes to about $4600.00 or less.

You'd have 2 keyboard surfaces, plenty of knobs/sliders, FM synthesis, a great modeled Hammond Organ, awesome sampler with HUGE library, a few different VA types, Wavestation capability, MUCH better audio-recording (up to 24-bit, 96k), TREMENDOUS flexibility, and the option to expand or upgrade in limitless ways.

Frankly, it walks all over an OASYS in several respects, IMHO.

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

28 Jan 2005, 18:09
it seems the korg oasys pads do not even have Polyphonic after touch. Bummer!

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

28 Jan 2005, 19:04
Dan, that's your opinion, and I respectfully disagree. There are people who love softsynths, but for the most part they aren't the ones looking for accurate Moog or Arp filter models. And softsynths are very good at what they do, but they do have issues, as do laptops. Desktop PCs are a much better way to go, especially when you can have a much more powerful system for less.

And Jimmi J, sure bargains can be had, and ebay is a marvelous resource for affordable used gear. Most of my stuff is from ebay. But let's look at that Kurzweil 2600S. You can undoubtedly find bargains around the net as lines are sold off and on ebay, but most places I can find are selling the stock basic 2600S for $3700. If you want expansions, like all of them, it's about another $1500 or so.

How about the Karma? Yeah, I can find them all over for $1500, so I don't know where you're shopping either. But if I want the Vintage Archive with it and a MOSS board, that's another $650 or so. An expression pedal might be $70, I can't remember what I paid for mine. And I want a Karma badly, which you can't replace it with a VSTi as much as Dan insists that all things are equal. Add that to his pile of goodies, and you have $6800, very close to the price of an Oasys.

If you can find an Emu Emulator X Studio for less than $600, point me to it. I think that's the sound system/DAW I'm going to buy.

I also think this subject has been beaten to death, and is based almost entirely on personal preference. I also also think that when Eventide came out with yet another $3000 rackmount, none of you said a peep about it. ;-)

I love the future
I love the future

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

28 Jan 2005, 19:16
"... And I want a Karma badly, which you can't replace it with a VSTi as much as Dan insists that all things are equal ..."

OK, let's be fair and read carefully.

What I actually wrote:
"... An exact comparison is likely impossible. Duplicating the exact functionality of the KARMA implementation is an example. Any reasonable comparision will have to be of similar, but not exact capability ...

If we are going to have a polite exchange of ideas, let's at least not misrepresent each other's opinions, OK?

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

28 Jan 2005, 19:36
Okay Dan, I guess I did get a bit too smart-mouthed. I'm sorry. :-|

I love the future
I love the future

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

28 Jan 2005, 19:45
No problem - it's totally cool.

You're a megalomaniac on a mission ... just like me!

(I respect that)

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

29 Jan 2005, 04:24
dont forget the 10.4 touchscreen on the korg-O, which itself would cost $1,000-$1,725 depending on the brand, which i think would be a nice feature on any music DAW screen, reach up and slide your finger down screen to reduce a slider level, hell, that itself would give it a whole new feel
its not the size of your kit, its what you do with it!

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

29 Jan 2005, 05:51
I'm glad I started this thread. The more I read it the more I feel happy with my X... :-)

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

29 Jan 2005, 11:23
Hey Synthguy;

Here they call me "SynthMan" and they don't call me that for nothing, call "Guitar Center" in San Jose, CA ask for Jack Ortalani in keyboards and software, tell him Jimi Jones sent you, now I don't know about you, but they will sell me a new Emu Emulator X for $400.00 out the door, and thats my relationship with them......you I don't know, so again buddy get real, I can get MOSS cards for $380.00 out the door, I can buy 3 Triton Extreme 61's and pay barely over $3,300.00, then buy 3 MOSS cards for them and pay less than $1,100.00....hence the more you buy the less you pay, do you know anything about that.

Jimi Jones
Jimi Jones

Re: Everybody who's not buying the OASYS...

11 Feb 2005, 20:23
I wouldnt for one reason, the quoted price!

For that much I could get soooo much more for less. Open Labs *Cough*

Phil

← Back to Other gear