Fantom-S and Fantom-X

MIDI offline message

MIDI offline message

18 Dec 2004, 13:13
Hello everyone. I've been reading these boards for a weeks now and have gathered alot of great and useful information. Being the proud owner of a new Fantom XR, this site has been very beneficial to the learning process. There is one topic that I haven't found covered though. I ocassionally receive the "MIDI OFFLINE" message on the XR. It only lasts for a second or two at most and then normal operation continues. Now, according to the manual, this is a MIDI cord problem. I've tried several, but the problem has happened with them all. I'm using a Roland A-50 controller and EV expression pedal. I'm playing it as a solo instrument in patch mode. Has anyone experienced this?

Thanks for any help.
Steve

Re: MIDI offline message

18 Dec 2004, 17:35
Technically, the MIDI Offline message means that the Fantom did not receive an Active Sensing message in time. Roland is probably the only MIDI instrument manufacturer that actually properly implements the Active Sensing functionality of the MIDI standard.

Active Sensing is basically a way for MIDI instruments to detect faulty MIDI connections. The idea is that MIDI instrument A sends out a one-byte MIDI Active Sensing message (FE in hexadecimal) through the MIDI OUT port about 4 times a second. MIDI instrument B receives these messages via the MIDI IN port and begins measuring the time interval between each message. If MIDI instrument B detects that no Active Sensing message has been received for more than 420 milliseconds (about half a second), MIDI instrument B assumes that there is a faulty MIDI connection and, to avoid stuck notes and stuck controllers, stops all notes and resets all controllers then resumes normal operation while no longer monitoring Active Sensing messages.

Roland synths and controllers are generally, by default, set to transmit those messages and to look for them. So when connecting a Roland controller (your A-50) to your Roland sound module (your Fantom-XR), the XR notices the Active Sensing messages and starts measuring time intervals between each message. If you turn off your A-50, disconnect the MIDI cable going from it's MIDI OUT to your Fantom-XR's MIDI IN jack, or otherwise interrupt MIDI transmissions from the A-50, the XR assumes a problem with the MIDI connection and resets itself. The manual is correct in that if you are receiving this "MIDI OFFLINE" message, there is likely something wrong with the MIDI cable. Either that or there is something wrong with the MIDI OUT jack on your A-50 or the MIDI IN jack on the XR.

It is possible to disable Active Sensing (both transmitting of Active Sensing messages and reception of those messages) on the Fantom-X. Not sure how to get to it on the XR as I have an X8, but it can be disabled. That won't fix the underlying problem though. :-)

Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/
Regards,

Nathan Sheldon
http://www.nathansheldon.com/

Re: MIDI offline message

18 Dec 2004, 18:14
Hi Duffage.

I've read that some commercially available MIDI cables are incorrectly wired. Specifically, all five of the pins on the DIN plug are connected. Only three pins are supposed to be used.

To find out if your MIDI cables are wired correctly, disconnect both ends of the cable and get a continuity tester. Find out which pins at one end are connected to which pins at the other end.

The five pins in the plug are numbered like this:

2
5 4
3 1

Pin 2 is supposed to be connected to pin 2 at the other end. In fact, this pin is ground and is supposed to be connected to the shielding in the cable.

Pin 5 at one end connects to pin 5 at the other end. Pin 4 at one end connects to pin 4 at the other end.

Pins 1 and 3 should not be connected to anything at all!

Notice that the above implies that the cable itself only contains two wires and a wire-mesh shield. That's right, it's microphone cable also known as shielded, twisted-pair.

50 feet is the maximum cable length according to the MIDI standard.

If your pins 1 and 3 are connected to 1 and 3 at the other end, it'll probably work most of the time, but it might be noisy. This means that the signal might drop out occassionally - which is what you're experiencing.

I made all my own cables and I haven't had one instant of trouble. If you want to try making your own cables, post here and I'll point you at detailed instructions.

Harvey

Re: MIDI offline message

18 Dec 2004, 18:17
Sorry, I don't know how to get this BBS to format the pins in a semi-circle.

Pins 3 and 1 are on the outside of the semi-circle.

Pin 2 is in the middle.

Pins 4 and 5 are one in from each end.

Let me know if that's not clear.

Harvey

Re: MIDI offline message

18 Dec 2004, 19:00
Thanks Harvey. Your description was quite clear. I have a continuity tester and will test all the cables.
Thank you too Nathan. That was a very detailed explanation. If the problem persists, I will MIDI into a different controller and try again. (There just can't be a problem with my 1988 A-50. :() The error message has occurred during the course of playing and even in an idle state.
Tonight will be the first job played with the XR, so my toes will be crossed.

Thanks again.
Steve

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X