Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Organs in Fantoms

Organs in Fantoms

10 Dec 2004, 07:42
I'd love to hear the organ sounds on fantom and some organ players toughts about how they compare side to side with modern day organ modelling synths like Clavia and Native Instruments B4 and Voce V5.

I think it is pure insanity to put fantom against original B3 it's like comparing pocket calculator and mac g5.

I all out love organ sound, it just drives me crazy, from fusion to rock it's the instrument I just can't get enough of. But the lack of drawbars in Fantom brings me down, is it better for me to get fantom for workstation and then a clavia nord enectro rack? Or can Fantom top the EPs in NE?

___________________________________
Shows you not to hurry, there is a typo on my screen name, hehe.
___________________________________
Shows you not to hurry, there is a typo on my screen name, hehe.

Re: Organs in Fantoms

10 Dec 2004, 08:50
I'm sorry, but I have some bad news for you!

The worst sounds of Fantom are it's Organs, even the worst organs that I've ever heard are Fantom's!

So, get the Ultimate Keys expansion board with a Fantom or a VK-8M module, or stick to the B4. There is nothing quite like the B4 in the market, except the B3!!

Sam

March 14th 1984
Music student at Dalhousie
Fantom-X 7

Re: Organs in Fantoms

10 Dec 2004, 09:40
I won't completely agree with Sam here, the Fantoms do have very nice organ sounds, and you can synthesize very cool retro organs yourself (I hope to make some free patches available soon).

Though, I will argree that the SRX08 board has much better organs than the stocks ones. It has over 20 different B3 multisamples!


Artemio.

Re: Organs in Fantoms

10 Dec 2004, 09:46
I'm not so expert with organ sounds but
the grand pipe on X is awesome,
more for the superb reverb patched on the sound
rather than for the sample in itself i think.
Anyway imho all of the organ sound i got on the X
are good.

greets

Re: Organs in Fantoms

10 Dec 2004, 09:57
I like the sound of B4 and my friend uses it and it sounds great, we recorded some of our songs using that, on live we play the Voce V5 it is easily greatest organ box there is, the VK-8m is pretty soulless when it comes to percussion clicks and leslie simulation, I'm not a huge fan of the overdrive either.

But I think I'll shell on the clavia nord electro module and fantom since that seems to be the currently best option for me (I play live quite often so B4 doesn't do any good outside my home).

I appreciate your fast responses.

___________________________________
Shows you not to hurry, there is a typo on my screen name, hehe.
___________________________________
Shows you not to hurry, there is a typo on my screen name, hehe.

Re: Organs in Fantoms

10 Dec 2004, 10:08
If you're talking classic B3 sounds, I agree with Sam. The stock organs in the Fantoms are definitely a weak spot. I've tweaked some pretty good ones with the stock waveforms, but they are pretty good at best.

The Ultimate keys (which I have) is alot better. There are some really good waveform in that SRX.

I also have Triton Studio with the classic keys expansion, and there are some excellent organs there. The Korg has a grit and girth that the Roland just doesn't have, and it's rortary simulater is better. But the Roland beats the Korg in other areas.

My friend has a Roland VR-760 and the organs there are awesome. Very convincing. It has drawbars as well. Also, it has SRX expansion. It is worlds ahead of the Ultimate Keys for organ.

IMO, no rompler will suffice if you need the ultimate in authentic organs. I'm quite happy with the Fantom/Ultimate keys for most of my purposes. It depends on your needs.

If you need classic B3 tones and you have a Fantom, the Ultimate keys is essential IMO.


bb
bb

hope this helps you guys

10 Dec 2004, 14:47
I downloaded the samples from hollow sun that are samples of the native instruments b4 and made a multisample of it. in my opinion it is a perfect b3 sound.. exactly what i wanted. to modify the sound i used 3 of the fantom samples and used the knobs to control each part... good luck

looking for cheap sound modules/analog synths

JC THE MC...

JC THE MC...
Fantom X6 2.10,Garage Band,Kliptch Pro media monitors, sennheiser hd 280 pro headphones and a Mac Mini!

Cobra Commander

12 Dec 2004, 16:13
I think the organ sounds on the Fathom are terrible. I use a Hammond xk2 and have heard nothing better. The Leslie simulator on both keyboards suck, so I purchased a Motion Sound Amp. It has a true operable leslie style horn and a simulated bass rotor. It is also a stereo amp so I can take full advantage of the stereo patches in each keyboard.
I have heard that the organs in Voce V5 through Hughes&kettner Rotosphere pedal is closest you can get in hardware, amy pros use that, but you'd have to get some waterfall keyboards to back that setup to get the feel.

Many say that the sounds and specially the leslie sim in current hammond organs are pretty lifeless, I have tested the awful Roland VK-7/8 myself and I know that it doesn't get anywhere near the real deal.

Many organ players have been changing from B3 to Clavia Nordelectro 2 in search for authentic sound in compact package, and I must say, the more I hear it the more I like it, plus it's not bad to look either. But after Hammon brought new B3 and the gig version of the B3, some have taken the hammond road.

___________________________________
Shows you not to hurry, there is a typo on my screen name, hehe.
___________________________________
Shows you not to hurry, there is a typo on my screen name, hehe.

Re: Organs in Fantoms

12 Dec 2004, 18:32
mm.. Clavia Nordelectro has the advantage of being hardware, but in the case of sound and editable parameters its way behind the NI B4.

In my opinion the only thing that is not "EXACTLY" the same in B3 and B4 is the warm overdrive sound. B4 has a greaaaat overdrive sound, but I could tell the difference between B3 and B4 with naked ears! In other aspects, I couldn't.

You can also read Sound On Sound reviews.

Sam

March 14th 1984
Music student at Dalhousie
Fantom-X 7

Re: Organs in Fantoms

13 Dec 2004, 02:18
For me, nothing even come close to the sound of real B3 with leslie especially in live performances. True to some extent as well in the mix too. Seem like the acoustic of that Leslie speakers is the big factor here. SoftsynthB4 sounds more like a recording.
SRX7 is a must for FantomX if you want some more organ sounds. Good thing is that you can mix different waves to make new organ sounds, not just to have a clone sounds.

Re: Organs in Fantoms

13 Dec 2004, 10:58
I'll agree with most of the posters here about the Fantom's organs being lame. If you really want to sound like a B3, you'll need to look elsewhere...the Fantom doesn't have a Leslie simulation, selectable chorus/vibrato, programmable leakage, or drawbars. The Ultimate Keys board gives you more options, and they'll do in a pinch.

If you have a computer, NI's B4 is a very good choice...I've been recording with it for years, and most people would never know the difference. If you don't want to use a computer, then I'd suggest a clone. There are many out there, but of the current lot, the Korg CX-3 probably comes the closest. The Roland VKs are nice, but their Leslie simulations are not that good (that includes the VR760). Unfortunately, "clone" shopping is a nightmare. Unless you live in NYC or LA, you probably won't find a music store that carries more than one of the clones. I settled on a CX-3 after owning a VK-7, two VK-8s, and a VK-8M.

Re: Organs in Fantoms

13 Dec 2004, 13:37
Yeah, The XK-3 & Motion Sound might do the trick if you have more than $3000 to spend. It boils down to what you want to do with it. For Joey, the XK-3 might be the answer. If you're trying to sound like Deep Purple or Spock's Beard or Boston or Kansas, the CX-3 will get you by. A b-stock CX-3 is under $1500, and a VK-8 can be had for $1425. Both are far superior to the Fantom's organs, and the CX-3 has the better Leslie simulation.

sms pardon me but,,,

14 Dec 2004, 19:38
I have an opportunity to trade for a Xk2 and was wondering what the value of it might be. The owner wants to trade for a paul reed smith guitar that I have. His board also includes a good road case. Can you help me out here please. Thanks in advance.
"Get a man drinkin' or get a man thinkin' he'll wind up looking for angles. Get a man smokin' or get a man chokin' he'll wind up looking for angels!"©2006 All rights reserved

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X