Fantom Platform

I Think VSTs Have Ruined Me for Pre-Loaded Keyboards

I Think VSTs Have Ruined Me for Pre-Loaded Keyboards

5 May 2021, 14:57
I want to love the Fantom as much as I loved the Fantom G at the time, but man, I am not really impressed at all with its acoustic sounds. Not sure if I will ever be gigging again anytime soon, and if I do, I think the Fantom will be great for that, but just recording in my studio, I think I will stick with Kontakt Komplete, CineSamples, etc. I already use a DAW, so there is no need for me to have a sequencer on board. Sorry, I'm just typing "out loud" now.

Anyone else disappointed with the acoustic sounds? Maybe videos don't do it justice. Guitar Center by me does not carry this, so I can't play it for myself.

Re: I Think VSTs Have Ruined Me for Pre-Loaded Keyboards

5 May 2021, 16:06
Kevbo wrote:

Anyone else disappointed with the acoustic sounds? Maybe videos don't do it justice. Guitar Center by me does not carry this, so I can't play it for myself.


You're not wrong. I noticed this also, and it's not just the Fantom falling short. I was able to demo the Fantom, Kronos, and Montage, and I was specifically listening to the pianos and orchestral instruments. IMO, none of them are on the same level as what you get from software instruments. The best software options like Synthogy Ivory II and Miroslav Philharmonik completely blow away all hardware keyboards, no contest. Ivory's Fazioli has something like 28GB of best-in-class multisample data; no keyboard has that much memory for all its instruments, let alone just their piano. If you have--or are willing to buy--a decently high-end PC/Mac and load it up with RAM, the upper bounds on realism and quality are a lot higher than for hardware keyboards.
Last edited by Diaphone on 5 May 2021, 19:54, edited 1 time in total.

Re: I Think VSTs Have Ruined Me for Pre-Loaded Keyboards

5 May 2021, 17:07
You’re not alone, to me the Fantom samples are just outdated and the PCM system lacks round robins and velocity layers as part of the sampler, so you have to use up partials to create one or the other (not both), which results in a much higher overhead than VSTs so then to get the equivalent quality you end up with lower polyphony. On top of that you also have no support for external storage for samples and very little onboard memory.

There’s still room for innovation from hardware manufacturers but right now it feels like someone has their foot stuck firmly in the past.

← Back to Fantom Platform