Fantom Platform

Always Wanted Fantom G....Does New Fantom Stand Up?

Always Wanted Fantom G....Does New Fantom Stand Up?

28 Aug 2020, 14:05
I have always wanted the Fantom G of yesteryear. At the time, I could not afford one. However, it is such a beautiful instrument, and I've always liked the sounds in there when I would play at the store. I also want a Korg Kronos, but I refuse to buy one in hopes of them coming out with a new flagship, preferably 64-bit and not use hardware from 2008. It's ridiculous, but I digress.

There are many people selling Fantom Gs. Should I stick to my guns and unload the money on one, or does the new Fantom hold up to the "G" and more???

Thanks for the input and your time.

Re: Always Wanted Fantom G....Does New Fantom Stand Up?

28 Aug 2020, 17:15
Don't know anything about the G...

But I have a Fantom 8 and I am so happy I cannot tell...
Easy to understand once you know I am upgrading from 1996 technology (Yamaha CVP 96). Anyone needs 3.5 floppy disks?

Anyway, there are some things that could be improved, just see the forum, and I hope they will.

It is September...1.6 is current and perhaps 1.7 coming soon.

Or the jump could be a great one indeed and a splash for 2.0 be made right away.

I understand you, since I tried to replace my keyboard along so many years, but kept saying no to very many options....Yamaha Montage, MODX, Tyros 5...4....3...

Re: Always Wanted Fantom G....Does New Fantom Stand Up?

2 Sep 2020, 18:57
The new Fantom's sounds, UI/UX are excellent. However, it lacks all of the linear recording capability of the Fantom-G (no 24-track digital audio recorder to RAM).

Re: Always Wanted Fantom G....Does New Fantom Stand Up?

27 Dec 2020, 01:30
As someone who now owns both, I can offer an opinion.

I've only had my new Fantom a few days and my G for going on 11 years. There are sounds I've been able to get out of it that I don't think are possible on the new Fantom and sounds I really, really wish Roland had decided to keep all of the previous waveforms and add new ones but they didn't.

Having said that, the sonic palette that is on the new hardware is probably worth going for verses something that is years older.

I really wish the new fantom had a linear sequencer and not more like someone put ableton or fruity loops on there. I like having a pattern mode but it's really a step back to have only pattern based sequencing. As I move forward with my new fantom, I forsee doing most of my work on a real daw.

I plan on keeping both so I have the best of both. If you have to choose one, get the newer hardware.

Re: Always Wanted Fantom G....Does New Fantom Stand Up?

27 Dec 2020, 11:41
Talking the old missing waves, it went the same for Montage/Motif.
After many complaints Yamaha finally arranged things and now Montage have all 512 of the original Motif XF performances in a bank converted for the Montage.
So, software permitting, let's see what Roland does in this regard with next updates.

Re: Always Wanted Fantom G....Does New Fantom Stand Up?

31 Dec 2020, 14:17
I really miss the guitar partials from the G + linear recording + audio-to-track recording. Fantom definitely has improved resolution in sequencer compared to G.

Re: Always Wanted Fantom G....Does New Fantom Stand Up?

22 Feb 2021, 09:58
They added some of the missing samples in the expansion packs, but not all. I'd like them to create an "X" and a "G" expansion pack that includes all the missing waveforms from the X and G so those of us who owned or own them can bring our custom sounds forward into the new hardware. A patch converter would be awesome too, even if built it into the vst, it would be awesome to take your old custom patches and convert them to new hardware. You know they have one somewhere in their development environment. No one is manually converting all of the old xv5080 patches to the newer parameters by hand.

Re: Always Wanted Fantom G....Does New Fantom Stand Up?

11 Apr 2021, 13:17
Tejaso wrote:
They added some of the missing samples in the expansion packs, but not all. I'd like them to create an "X" and a "G" expansion pack that includes all the missing waveforms from the X and G so those of us who owned or own them can bring our custom sounds forward into the new hardware. A patch converter would be awesome too, even if built it into the vst, it would be awesome to take your old custom patches and convert them to new hardware. You know they have one somewhere in their development environment. No one is manually converting all of the old xv5080 patches to the newer parameters by hand.
It's not possible to convert* XV-5080 (or older JV/XP) patches into Zen-Core. Nutshell: Zen-Core does not contain "Tone Structures" of the past. See my explanation here.

While the base PCM may be added, the method by which they were routed through filters, ring-mod, and boosters, as well as the various TVA/TVF arrangements are gone.

Unless Roland adds these structures to Zen-Core, it will be difficult to translate older JV/XV patches.

*Zen-Core's "OFF" structure is similar to the JV/XV "Structure 1", so those may be fairly easy to translate.

← Back to Fantom Platform