SH-01

Using double LFO

Using double LFO

28 Aug 2020, 00:46
I have a question that I suspect the answer to is no, but I just wanted to check. Is it possible to get both oscillators (or all three oscillators to go through both a filter depth LFO and amp depth LFO, with different rates? If it's possible I'll try to figure out how to do it.

Re: Using double LFO

28 Aug 2020, 05:01
As you likely know, the GAIA has 3 separate complete synthesizer engines, each complete with an oscillator, filter, LFO, and amplifier. So, with any one of the synth engines, you cannot have the filter, oscillator, or amp have different LFO speeds, because they are all controlled by one LFO. However, the LFO's of each of the 3 synth engines are independent and CAN be separate speeds. So, for example, you can have a sound on synth engine (or tone) number 1 have its LFO modulate its oscillator at one speed, and then have a sound on synth engine/tone number 2 have its LFO modulate its filter at a different speed.

Additionally, as far as I know, the joystick controller activates yet another LFO that can be set to its own speed and can by programmed to modulate the oscillator, filter, and amp. Now, I'm not sure, but I think that LFO controlled by the joystick modulates all three synth engines/tones at the same speed. And of course, it is only active when you push that joystick controller away from you to enable its modulation.

Re: Using double LFO

30 Aug 2020, 23:17
Thanks. I was asking because I was trying to recreate the keyboard sound from Won't Get Fooled Again, and it is (originally) a Mellotron that has the equivalent of a slow-moving lowpass filter, and then that signal is sent into a device that is filtering the amplitude at a higher speed. I guess it would be difficult to make that without an external device.

Re: Using double LFO

31 Aug 2020, 05:01
Oh, is that what you're going after? Well, I know that is possible on the GAIA because at Sweetwater.com, where they sell the GAIA, they also include a set of patches with various classic rock sounds, and that is one of them. If you go to the Sweetwater website and look up the GAIA, they also post a video with a demonstration of these sounds.

I think the original was done on a home organ -- but I guess it could've been a Mellotron -- that was ran through an external sweeping filter. I'm not sure where you're hearing the different rates, unless you're talking about the way the chords are repeated at one rate (as if they are being hit over and over as eighth notes) and the slow sweeping filter is a slowly changing the timbre of the chords as they are being played. And actually, I'm not sure how they're getting that effect on the GAIA. Of course, you can just play the eighth note chords manually, but maybe one of the arpeggios does repeating notes or chords. Or, it may be possible to have the main LFO control the slowly sweeping filter, and then have the modulation-lever LFO set to a square wave at the appropriate rate to turn those chords on and off (play them over and over) at the appropriate rate. Of course, in that case, you would have to activate the modulation lever to get the repeating-chord effect.

EDIT: I just checked that Sweetwater demo -- and the "Won't Get Fooled Again" sound is right near the beginning, maybe the third patch demonstrated -- and the keyboardist was not manipulating the modulation lever, and he is not hitting the chords over and over either, so maybe one of the arpeggios does the repeating effect.

Re: Using double LFO

31 Aug 2020, 19:40
I suspect that the LFO is being used to create the eighth notes (I can recreate that pretty well but putting the amp through the filter), and maybe the tone change is being done some other way, like by using two oscillators to modulate each other. I don't think it's an arpeggio, because it's basically a chord where the bottom note stays the same and the top notes change, so it's not regular. There is actually a video where Pete Townshend is explaining how he did it, but he just mentions one filter. Actually, I was wrong about the Mellotron, it was a Lowrey spinnet organ, run through two LFOs, one controlling the brightness and the other the amp.

Re: Using double LFO

31 Aug 2020, 22:12
The GAIA doesn't have cross modulation between oscillators. It has sync (which forces mono mode) and ring modulation, neither of which really sounds like that Who song effect. But as far as the notes of the chords being played and the possibility of an arpeggio being used -- in the Sweetwater demo, the keyboardist IS changing the notes that are being played -- he's just not hitting the resulting chords over and over -- the GAIA is somehow doing that. That's why, if there is an arpeggio that simply repeats whatever notes are being held down, I think that an arpeggio is causing the repeating effect. In other words, the arpeggiator would strictly be used to repeat whatever notes are being held down on the keyboard -- it would not be used to fully automate the chord progression of that part of the song.

So, for example, if such an arpeggio were set to eighth notes, and the keyboardist held down C-E-G (a C chord) for a whole 4/4 measure, and then kept the C but moved the other notes to F and A (for C-F-A, an F chord) for another 4/4 measure, while he would actually only be playing two whole-note chords, the GAIA would be sounding 8 eighth-note C chords, then 8 eighth-note F chords (sounding the chords as C C C C C C C C F F F F F F F F), which is the effect of the Who song.

I will also say that, until I read recently that this sound was originally done by running an organ through a sweeping filter, I had always thought the sweeping effect was a phase-shifter. As the GAIA does have a phase-shifter, with a speed setting that is independent of any of the LFO's, I wonder how close it would sound to use the phase-shifter for the sweeping effect, and then use the LFO set to a square wave on the amp section of the tones for the repeating note effect.

Re: Using double LFO

1 Sep 2020, 01:25
Thanks a lot. That really does the trick. I hadn't thought of that, but using either the phaser or flanger with the LFO doing the pulsing really makes a sound that's similar. Now all I have to do is get the oscillators and filters right to make it sound like an organ. :)

Re: Using double LFO

1 Sep 2020, 08:42
And the trick to that depends on how many drawbars or "flutes" that the organ in the Who song uses. If it's three or less, then you can just use a triangle wave, or perhaps even a sine wave, on each tone (oscillator) set to the different octaves. And that may be enough -- perhaps one oscillator/tone set to 16', another set to 8' or 4' (one or two octaves higher than 16'), and the third set to 4' or 2' (two or three octaves higher than 16'). I don't really think it's got any "off octave" harmonic drawbars in that sound, but if it did, then one of the oscillator/tones would likely just have to be set to a fifth above the main note -- and depending on the octave range of that note, that could give you a 5 1/3', a 2 2/3', or even a 1 1/3' pitch.

However, if more drawbar/flutes are needed, then I would suggest the technique that I used to make my Hammond-type sounds in my other thread. There, I start with a square wave (as the filter will be filtering that down, anyway). Then set the filter to low-pass (LPF), and turn up the resonance until the filter self-oscillates (but not so high that the original tone is muted). Set the filter's key-follow to maximum positive. Turn down the volume/amp output as you tune this sound, as the resonance can make a shrieking sound at some settings. And then carefully tune the self-oscillating resonance to the extra pitch you need, using the filter's cutoff frequency control. Then, set the volume/amp output to the desired level after you get the pitch you want. Do this with all three oscillator/tones, and you can have up to 6 distinct drawbar/flutes, but I'm thinking the organ sound in the Who song isn't really that complex. I bet a basic 16' - 8' - 2' or 16' - 4' - 2' setting would do the job.

Re: Using double LFO

2 Sep 2020, 19:57
Thanks for the suggestion about self-oscillation. I'm kind of new to synthesizers (I'm actually originally a guitar player, but I always liked synths, and now the band I'm in has a really good guitar player, so I'm concentrating a bit more on keyboards). It's really cool to find out how to actually learn about making sounds. I got a pretty nice sound using the three oscillators, all with the resonance making another note.

← Back to SH-01