Fantom Platform

Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

22 Jan 2020, 15:14
I'm running out of polyphony it seems with sounds cutting off. And I am only using 3 zones.

Zone 1 Z-Core, CMN, 0016
Zone 2 Z-Core, PR-D, 004
Zone 3, Z-Core, PR-E, 0052

I have the same zone setup saved in two scenes. If I make a run holding sustain down with piano and pad the piano sound cuts off and the bass notes of the piano just stops. Sounds horrible =D. The pad however chugging along.

Can I make one zone prioritized some how to never ever steal focus and cut off?

I have same problem on even simpler Scenes with only a pad and a piano sound.

I thought I could solve it by not using a sample based piano, but, then the piano sound cuts off when switching scenes instead.

Also, I assume that If I layer zones, the zones not activated, doesn't steal polyfony, right? Or is there a bug or something.

Basically what I try to accomplish are the same three sounds, pad, organ and piano, but with different levels and/or not sounding at all with no cut offs between switching. Am I doing it wrong using different Scenes for each "set up"?

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

22 Jan 2020, 15:46
The Fantom only has 64 note polyphony for sample and VA based instruments (unlimited polyphony on the V-Piano). This can run out very fast, a fully filled up patch would only allow a single note to be played, a number of preset patches only allow 3 or 4 notes, which limits chords.

In order to control priority you can set each zone's polyphony limit if you go to Menu->Zone Edit->Voice Reserve. You can also adjust priority within the zone itself under Menu->Tone Edit->To Pro->Common->Priority, however i'm not sure how this parameter works.

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

23 Jan 2020, 10:53
Per wrote:
The Fantom only has 64 note polyphony for sample and VA based instruments (unlimited polyphony on the V-Piano).
Correct me if I'm wrong, but to be exact, I think the polyphony of the Fantom for ZEN-Core sounds is 256 partials. So if you have a ZEN-Core tone that utilizes all 4 partials, that tone can have 256/4 = 64 notes playing simultaneously. Many ZEN-Core tones use less than the maximum of 4 partials, and therefore take up less polyphony.

In any case, 3 simultaneously playing zones each using a tone with 4 partials means that each keypress takes away 12 notes of polyphony. If you play a chord of 5 notes, this totals to 60 "notes" of polyphony (out of 256) getting used. With some extended chords and hold pedal, you can run out of polyphony fast.

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

23 Jan 2020, 11:17
Per wrote:
unlimited polyphony on the V-Piano
Hmm, well that's good to hear. But, if I use a V-piano on Zone 1, Z-core sound on Zone 2&3. The piano still cuts off when switching scenes.

This also happens on Scenes where I only have a V-piano patch on Zone 1 (the same one). Wierd.

If it really is "unlimited" shouldn't anything already playing continue to play when you switch Scene? Is this a bug or just me doing something wrong?

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

23 Jan 2020, 12:54
First of all, V-Piano doesn't do smooth sound transitions.

Secondly, yes, you prioritize the voice stealing for certain sensitive notes. There are two variables to play with: Voice Reserve and Voice Assign Mode.

In "Zone Edit", go to the "Voice Reserve" page.

Here you can change the Voice Assign Mode which determines how many of the same note for a given instrument can play simultaneously. If you hold the pedal and play the same chords on top of each other, changing this to SINGLE or LIMIT can reduce redundant notes. FULL doesn't kill repeated notes. LIMIT is an in-between option. SINGLE is the most aggressive and you'll be more likely to hear the kills.

But the more likely one to help with what you want is the "Voice Reserve". Turn this up to 24 for a piano (that is playing on top of a pad) for example and you'll hear less kills of the piano.

Good luck.

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

23 Jan 2020, 13:05
Quartz wrote:
Per wrote:
The Fantom only has 64 note polyphony for sample and VA based instruments (unlimited polyphony on the V-Piano).
Correct me if I'm wrong, but to be exact, I think the polyphony of the Fantom for ZEN-Core sounds is 256 partials. So if you have a ZEN-Core tone that utilizes all 4 partials, that tone can have 256/4 = 64 notes playing simultaneously. Many ZEN-Core tones use less than the maximum of 4 partials, and therefore take up less polyphony.

In any case, 3 simultaneously playing zones each using a tone with 4 partials means that each keypress takes away 12 notes of polyphony. If you play a chord of 5 notes, this totals to 60 "notes" of polyphony (out of 256) getting used. With some extended chords and hold pedal, you can run out of polyphony fast.
I was surprised too, but It's 64 partials (voices), the Voice Reserve controls also back this up. Check out some of the patches like Metropolis to see this in action. Metropolis has 6 active zones made up of 20 active partials. The most notes you can play without cutoff occurring are 3 (60 voices), at 4 (80) you will lose some of the partials of the first note then 5 a complete other note. If it were per zone rather than per partial voice then it shouldn't run out till you hit 11 notes, and if it had 256 voice polyphony it shouldn't run out till you hit 13 notes.

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

23 Jan 2020, 16:01
Ugh, that's a bummer. I was under the impression there were more voices.

I guess one could argue that with smooth transitions it's 2X what we're discussing, but that's no help for a single complex scene.

Personally, I'd gladly give up the V-Piano to get more Zen-Core polyphony.

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

23 Jan 2020, 19:14
Nope ... it's 256 partials. A "tone" in Roland-speak can use up to 4 partials per voice however.

So, as a practical matter, you can get up to 256 notes of polyphony if you are using single-partial tones. If you are using 4-partial tones, you are limited to 64 voices total. (256/4 = 64). If you are layering 3 X 4-partial tones ... you are down to 21 voices of polyphony or 16 voice if you are layering 4 X 4-partial tones.

You can test this pretty readily by assigning some zones to Sub-Outs, thereby allowing you to monitor directly when a particular tone cuts out. I've done so ... repeatedly.

The V-Piano engine is its own pool of "virtually unlimited" polyphony. So using a V-Piano tone (Zone 1 only) leaves you with 256 partials still available. So a V-Piano layered with 3 X 4-partial tones would be unlimited polyphony for the piano, 21-voices for the remaining "layered-stack".

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

23 Jan 2020, 20:43
I'd be interested to find out why those patches are unable to handle that amount of polyphony then.

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

23 Jan 2020, 21:31
Per wrote:
I'd be interested to find out why those patches are unable to handle that amount of polyphony then.

I find this a bit interesting. So it might be the subject of a demonstration/how-to/exploration video. I know you are not daft or incompetent ... far from it ... so it piques my interest.

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

24 Jan 2020, 01:56
I'd be interested in seeing this as well! I'd try it out myself, but my Fantom is currently firmly in its case among a small chaos, as I'm moving to a new apartment tomorrow :D

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

24 Jan 2020, 05:58
That should still leave twice as many notes as it plays before a note gets dropped when played from load in without having hit a note before so there's no bleed over from previous notes still playing.

You can examine the patch, all parts are poly, there's no unison, only a few of the PCM partials contains stereo PCM's, the reserve is off and set to the default of limit (of 0), changing it makes no difference, the priorities are mostly last rather than loudest.

There'd be no reason to take half the polyphony away from patch spillover. Even if you did you'd still expect more polyphony than you get.

I don't really have time to explore much deeper, but as said I would be interested to know exactly why this patch and others behave this way.

Re: Sound cuts off (lack of polyphony?)

25 Jan 2020, 08:46
maphill wrote:
First of all, V-Piano doesn't do smooth sound transitions.
I really hope they can fix this in with a future update. Like reserve Zone 1 for V-Piano or something. So when if you switch Scenes that have the same V-piano on Zone 1, leave it alone. Now it feels a bit like: "Here you go, have as much polyphony as you like. But, don't you dare use it, if you do, then we're cutting you off!" ;)
maphill wrote:
In "Zone Edit", go to the "Voice Reserve" page.

Here you can change the Voice Assign Mode which determines how many of the same note for a given instrument can play simultaneously. If you hold the pedal and play the same chords on top of each other, changing this to SINGLE or LIMIT can reduce redundant notes. FULL doesn't kill repeated notes. LIMIT is an in-between option. SINGLE is the most aggressive and you'll be more likely to hear the kills.

But the more likely one to help with what you want is the "Voice Reserve". Turn this up to 24 for a piano (that is playing on top of a pad) for example and you'll hear less kills of the piano.
This helped a lot. Thank you!

← Back to Fantom Platform