Fantom Platform

Acoustic sounds

Re: Acoustic sounds

11 Sep 2019, 09:12
dboulden wrote:
cello wrote:
In the above mentioned FB group Roland staff have confirmed the V-Piano does not cut off.


I have a Fantom 7 in front of me and can confirm the V-Piano *does* cutoff when changing to another patch.

Maybe it does not cut off when changing TO a V-Piano patch, but it does cut off when changing AWAY from a V-Piano patch? In that case, both of the above seemingly contradictory statements can be true.

Re: Acoustic sounds

11 Sep 2019, 09:41
You can see it here in Scott Tibbs demo https://youtu.be/zEE4EPAhNnY?t=960
0kk0p3kk4 wrote:
In zone mode it doesnt cut, otherwise it doeS
Right so if you change to a different part within a scene, the piano remains. If you switch scenes, it cuts off. That's not great. I can envision a couple workarounds but v piano should patch remain when the scene is switched.

Re: Acoustic sounds

1 Oct 2019, 22:48
Yes, the piano is definitely not a seamless transition. And I am really surprised my Kronos does it for all the sounds so smoothly and how come after so many years Roland can not do it. Also some of the acoustic sounds are fantastic and some are really bad. For example the Harmonicas and accordions sound so horrible where as some of the flutes and saxophones are phenomenal. The harmonicas sound better on my FA06. Roland should bring over the supernatural acoustic sounds with articulations. Also Pianos definitely need improvement. Fantom should have at least warm and full sounding Piano with bit woodyness in it.

Re: Acoustic sounds

2 Oct 2019, 20:39
swarupmahapatra wrote:
Yes, the piano is definitely not a seamless transition. And I am really surprised my Kronos does it for all the sounds so smoothly and how come after so many years Roland can not do it.
Because they use different technologies and architectures.

Roland's seamless transition is actually BETTER than Kronos, EXCEPT when using the V-Piano. Kronos patches only survive one transition, Roland allows you to hold a sound through multiple transitions. V-Piano has its own technology. If you must switch you piano sounds seamlessly, at least for now, the answer is to use a different piano sound.

Meanwhile on the lower end, Roland has seamless transition on the Juno DS (though you can hear effects glitches if you don't program your patches to avoid them), as they have had on many earlier keyboards as well... Korg does not have seamless transitions on their comparably priced Kross or even their more expensive Krome. So there is no correlation between what one company is doing at a certain price point vs. another, no matter how long one has been doing it. They just have different designs, each doing things the other does not.

Re: Acoustic sounds

3 Oct 2019, 11:09
Absolutely agree. Here’s some suggestions though -

1. Improve on the bread and butter acoustic sounds. Might be bring over the SN sounds some way to the zen core engine
2. Add copy paste feature to the scenes
3. Increase the side chain patch block sizes
4. Add few more effects like shimmer

Thanks

Re: Acoustic sounds

3 Oct 2019, 12:41
The Vpiano indeed cuts off when you transition to another sound, just like the RD-2000. But on the RD-2000 you have SN pianos that don't cut off... maybe SN will be added? For the price & market it's in that makes sense.

Re: Acoustic sounds

3 Oct 2019, 13:39
ElevenPhingahz wrote:
The Vpiano indeed cuts off when you transition to another sound, just like the RD-2000. But on the RD-2000 you have SN pianos that don't cut off... maybe SN will be added? For the price & market it's in that makes sense.
+1

Roland need to justify the price

Re: Acoustic sounds

29 Oct 2019, 11:51
It might not cutoff if you switch scenes, but changing a patch within a scene, the old patch cuts off immediately.

Re: Acoustic sounds

29 Oct 2019, 14:51
You can build a sub par draw bars using the sliders and inbuilt VA/samples yourself right now, you can also emulate a lot of the SN behaviors right now using zen-core if you are willing to explore in depth.

Despite this IMO the Fantom doesn’t justify its price by (with additional effort on the behalf of the user) being merely able to sound like a 20 year old digital workstation in 2019 when it comes to acoustic sounds.

Re: Acoustic sounds

29 Oct 2019, 15:43
Per wrote:
You can build a sub par draw bars using the sliders and inbuilt VA/samples yourself right now, ...


Yeah ... that's an awful lot of work (and odd use of resources) for a not-so-great payoff.

Re: Acoustic sounds

17 Nov 2019, 20:12
I tested this new keyboard in the store and this was my first surprise...No supernatural Acoustic engine...where is my strum guitar?where's that nice bass guitar simulation that played and sounded like a real one? admittedly the concept of natural instrument behaving was a brilliant idea!
But upon trying this expensive beast..I found my self playing back some old Roland patch...organ with helicopter leslie sim. hopefully an update will fix it all!

Re: Acoustic sounds

22 Nov 2019, 02:07
swarupmahapatra wrote:
ElevenPhingahz wrote:
The Vpiano indeed cuts off when you transition to another sound, just like the RD-2000. But on the RD-2000 you have SN pianos that don't cut off... maybe SN will be added? For the price & market it's in that makes sense.
+1

Roland need to justify the price
Yesterday, price was going down in every retailers.

Re: Acoustic sounds

22 Nov 2019, 02:14
Oh probably all she needs another firmware update ;) and nothing more !

Re: Acoustic sounds

23 Nov 2019, 21:14
jeanbart wrote:
[q

Yesterday, price was going down in every retailers.
Its a big world. Here in the US, all the major retail venues said $3999 for Fantom 8.
GregC

← Back to Fantom Platform