Review of Fantom
29 Oct 2019, 11:39I’ve been a Roland synth owner since my first d series, a d110 that I mated to an old hp5500 my parents bought for me in middle school. I used an Alexis mmt8 for sequencing and let me tell you, it was a chore to get things written with that setup but I managed. I’ve owned a jv80, xp80, a fantom x8 and currently have a g8 that has been my go to for almost 11 years.
I’ve thought many times before a week ago when I heard Roland released a new a Fantom successor of going the Kronos route. I’m sure the Kronos has a lot of potential when you get into the guts and make it your own.
I’ve been able to get some absolutely amazing sounds from my G8. Its been a great workstation even though it shows its age.
My initial thoughts and review...
I watched the demos from Scott Tibbs and others. The sounds on the new Fantom in their demos sound awesome.
In person, the Fantom sounds plain and flat, a lot like the xp series. The user interface is Roland but different. I can see some possibilities for real time control of sounds and for live performance musicians, it seems like a great platform. But for my uses, and as a true successor to my G, its not...yet. I think they rushed it out before it was ready.
Pros seem to be they fixed the Fantom G weakness with way more synth tones. The pianos seem good but it seems like instead of taking the best of the Fantom series waves, adding new wavs and things like vpiano, they left out a lot of what made the previous Fantoms a step above the Xv/jv synths. It sounds more like a super xv than a Fantom.
I dug into the samples and was disappointed they would leave out the best of the sn and previous Fantom synths for a complete xv waverom set.
The patches themselves suggest they rushed the product to market. The waverom recycled more of the mediocre than the best.
I remember trying the Fantom x and G in the store and found it to be instantly inspiring. Even though the patches needed a little work, there was a lot of good sounds that worked together. That’s what the new Fantom lacks. It’s a synth first, performance keyboard second and Swiss army workstation a distant 3rd
The 7 inch screen is also a disappointment. They should have gone bigger and had an iPad style screen with gorilla glass. A resolution of at least 1920x1080. Mouse support and external monitor support would have been a great idea. I know they can’t or won’t fix the screen but they could have given it a premium screen for the price.
Dropping the larger transport buttons for 90’s style mini transport buttons. The Fantom is supposed to be daw friendly, but puts teeny transport buttons, and not have things like fwd, rev, pause, etc buttons...seriously?
I know the pha50 based 8 is top of the line, but I think the G series had better balanced weighted action. The new keys are too stiff imho.
Another oddity is why the 6 and 7 cases don’t mount flush with the keys. There is a .25 inch gap where you see the keys dip. It’s like they threw another keyboard in the Fantom, one that wasn’t designed for it.
I’m also disappointed in the sequencer dropping song mode opting for pattern mode where you piece together patterns to form a song. 80’s synth sounds and 80’s style sequencing. They should have kept the previous sequencer from the g or at least had a song mode like the G that resembled a true daw.
I would gladly pay extra to have the waveforms from the D series, Fantom and full integra available in one unit, and a song mode that wasn’t so clugy.
One of the previous Fantoms great features was if you wanted a synth pad, you could select the type and scroll through all pads, etc. While the feature is partially there, you have to select a bank and then browse by instrument. That’s not very intuitive. It’s a pain to go through each bank and browse by tag.
Even with all the negatives, I see its potential. But I think if I buy one, it will be a 7 and not an 8. My G8 plays better than the pha based Fantom. There is a steep learning curve to this instrument, more so than previous Fantoms.
If Roland demonstrates true support for the new Fantom and addresses its shortcomings in the sequencer, sampler and rom depts, I’ll buy one. I’d love to sell my G8 and have one board but I can’t see how I can get rid of my G when the new phantom is so weak in areas it shouldn’t be, sonically and functionally.
If I do, I’ll probably have to switch to using pro tools as my full time recorder and not use the sequencer at all. Pattern sequencing might be good for some styles of music but not for a lot of styles, including mine.
I’ve thought many times before a week ago when I heard Roland released a new a Fantom successor of going the Kronos route. I’m sure the Kronos has a lot of potential when you get into the guts and make it your own.
I’ve been able to get some absolutely amazing sounds from my G8. Its been a great workstation even though it shows its age.
My initial thoughts and review...
I watched the demos from Scott Tibbs and others. The sounds on the new Fantom in their demos sound awesome.
In person, the Fantom sounds plain and flat, a lot like the xp series. The user interface is Roland but different. I can see some possibilities for real time control of sounds and for live performance musicians, it seems like a great platform. But for my uses, and as a true successor to my G, its not...yet. I think they rushed it out before it was ready.
Pros seem to be they fixed the Fantom G weakness with way more synth tones. The pianos seem good but it seems like instead of taking the best of the Fantom series waves, adding new wavs and things like vpiano, they left out a lot of what made the previous Fantoms a step above the Xv/jv synths. It sounds more like a super xv than a Fantom.
I dug into the samples and was disappointed they would leave out the best of the sn and previous Fantom synths for a complete xv waverom set.
The patches themselves suggest they rushed the product to market. The waverom recycled more of the mediocre than the best.
I remember trying the Fantom x and G in the store and found it to be instantly inspiring. Even though the patches needed a little work, there was a lot of good sounds that worked together. That’s what the new Fantom lacks. It’s a synth first, performance keyboard second and Swiss army workstation a distant 3rd
The 7 inch screen is also a disappointment. They should have gone bigger and had an iPad style screen with gorilla glass. A resolution of at least 1920x1080. Mouse support and external monitor support would have been a great idea. I know they can’t or won’t fix the screen but they could have given it a premium screen for the price.
Dropping the larger transport buttons for 90’s style mini transport buttons. The Fantom is supposed to be daw friendly, but puts teeny transport buttons, and not have things like fwd, rev, pause, etc buttons...seriously?
I know the pha50 based 8 is top of the line, but I think the G series had better balanced weighted action. The new keys are too stiff imho.
Another oddity is why the 6 and 7 cases don’t mount flush with the keys. There is a .25 inch gap where you see the keys dip. It’s like they threw another keyboard in the Fantom, one that wasn’t designed for it.
I’m also disappointed in the sequencer dropping song mode opting for pattern mode where you piece together patterns to form a song. 80’s synth sounds and 80’s style sequencing. They should have kept the previous sequencer from the g or at least had a song mode like the G that resembled a true daw.
I would gladly pay extra to have the waveforms from the D series, Fantom and full integra available in one unit, and a song mode that wasn’t so clugy.
One of the previous Fantoms great features was if you wanted a synth pad, you could select the type and scroll through all pads, etc. While the feature is partially there, you have to select a bank and then browse by instrument. That’s not very intuitive. It’s a pain to go through each bank and browse by tag.
Even with all the negatives, I see its potential. But I think if I buy one, it will be a 7 and not an 8. My G8 plays better than the pha based Fantom. There is a steep learning curve to this instrument, more so than previous Fantoms.
If Roland demonstrates true support for the new Fantom and addresses its shortcomings in the sequencer, sampler and rom depts, I’ll buy one. I’d love to sell my G8 and have one board but I can’t see how I can get rid of my G when the new phantom is so weak in areas it shouldn’t be, sonically and functionally.
If I do, I’ll probably have to switch to using pro tools as my full time recorder and not use the sequencer at all. Pattern sequencing might be good for some styles of music but not for a lot of styles, including mine.