Fantom-S and Fantom-X

To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 09:23
I know, I know, I should enjoy the current workstation offerings, and I do, but since Roland needs lead time to plan out its next flagship workstation offering, now is the time when we can have the most influence on its development, before its specifications are locked into whatever Roland has under development at the moment. So hopefully we can post our ideas here and either Artemio can pass them on or some Roland reps who may lurk here will get the info.

My list, in order of priority for the Fantom-Y/Z/XX or whatever:

1. At *least* 8 simultaneous insert effects, with per-band eq, like on the Motif ES

2. Double the base ROM (to 256 MB), to surpass the Motif ES and Triton Extreme.

3. Allow a different synth engine to be added, similar to the Korg MOSS board, or Yamaha PLG cards. Maybe Roland could allow its VariOS or the V-Synth card(s) to be added to the workstation.

4. interface improvements: track select/mute buttons and undo button like Fantom-Xa; more knobs (at least 8); 8 sliders like on new Roland G-7 (or is it G-70)?

5. At least quadruple the number of available arpeggiations--comparable to the Motif ES, but with four simultaneous apreggiations available at once, and patches and performances store arpeggiation settings

5. All patches and performances over-writable by the user, and several times more performance slots available than currently.

6. More SRX card slots (at least six), and absent a new sound-engine being available (see above) then create more SRX cards.


Anything I left out? ;)

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 09:45
You forgot a cup holder ;-)

Frankly though subjectively, it seems like you'll never have what you want, and I have already told you that. By the time Roland releases a board like that, Korg and Yamaha will get much improved as well, and then you'll want more than this and tell that this hypothetical synth could have been better and here's my wish list for the next workstation, etc.

I have a Fantom-S which is not as "powerful" as X and Xa, but I know that I have a tool that will serve me well for years and years.


Artemio.

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 10:13
I know that "grek" went out of his way to provide this community with a nice sample tool, and I'm using it alot, but its shameful to know that Roland can't even match that of a common consumer, so with that in mind, my main priority wish list item would be for Roland to get their collective "arses" together and create a viable sample import/editing tool that would totally allow us to create/mangle/import samples to and from the X series boards, and to do it elegantly, with proper sample names and such, extremely convenient multisampling procedures, with the ability to store 500 or more Mb's of data, a full-fledged sampling editor should be numero UNO on their list....DUH..!



Jimi Jones
Jimi Jones

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 10:24
I'd like them to bring back the dedicated Bank and Number buttons. I find it very tedious and slow to select banks and patches/performances (without setting favorites) by scrolling and cursoring. That's my biggest gripe in a live setting.

bb
bb

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 11:20
My number one wish is Roland to keep improving their keyboards as they have been doing for so long... I belibe fantom-X/S/Y/A/R/G/H/T/D/B/N/M (name it as you want) will be the sum of new technologies that will appear until it´s development...

Marcondes

Music is Life. So, just create life!
Music is Life. So, just create life!

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 12:24
Ill be modest, and just ask for a full blown secuencer inside the XRII. (sometimes its a burden to carry a computer)

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 13:04
I'm with Artemio on this one and it isn't so much of what you have, its how you use it.

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 13:46
As a gigging musician, my requests are pretty simple.

1. Put the master volume control where you can grab it easily when your eyes are off the keyboard playing and singing. Roland used to do this...like on my XP-60...and Korg and Yamaha still do. It's just stupid on the Fantoms...this little dinky knob buried awkwardly up somewhere on the front panel. And Roland wonders why musicians perfer to gig with Tritons and Motifs...

2. Direct key access to patches. Another stupid STUPID omission.

3. Here's what would get club players excited...a real replacement for the XP-30. No sequencer or sampling...just the the basic sounds of the Fantom X (and maybe SRX-07) in a compact rugged package with their great feeling semi-weighted keyboard for a decent price. The new Fantom is none of these things from the descriptions of it...wall wart power, plastic case, cheap keyboard, and the old Fantom S ROM. Really...with Fantom S 61's selling for $800 on E-Bay, who's going to buy one? I can't believe it... to me it's just stupid stupid STUPID!!!

It just feels like Roland has written off us live players. Many of us who've gigged on Roland keyboards for years are abandoning the brand. I've been waiting for a replacement for my XP-60 from Roland, but it looks like it's going to be a Motif ES. I'll wait through January NAMM...

Bill Hornibrook

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 15:35
I'll take the "X" series in its present form with a VGA OUT like on the MV8000k and firewire support, thanks.

TRIPLE THREAT PRODUCTIONS

"Don't make excuses, Make it happen"
TRIPLE THREAT PRODUCTIONS

"Don't make excuses, Make it happen"

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 16:15
Artemio,

I've been a loyal Roland purchaser for many years (XP-50, JV-2080, Fantom, Fantom-S). I don't appreciate such condescension from you. All I'm trying to do is to give some positive input into the direction of Roland's flagship workstations, similar to what Yamaha asks it's users to do through polls on the Motifator.com sight. But since Roland hasn't given us a poll, I'm asking you, since you now have some sort of limited affiliation with Roland, to please pass on our requests. I think that this would be (a) polite and (b) good business sense for Roland.

Thank you.

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 16:33
Artemio: "By the time Roland releases a board like that, Korg and Yamaha will get much improved as well"..

So you are saying Roland will always be BEHIND the other two?

--------------------
Remember that there are only 3 MFX + 1 Reverb + 1 Chorus in Fantom-S/X and you have to share them across 16 parts (patches) in a song.

live a musical life
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

5 Nov 2004, 18:18
the main feature that fantom x misses for me is the capability to use external usb devices and to act as an host
that means ,use external hard disk /storage..etc..without any pc intermediation...but

first ..we can share our samples between pc and our machine...ok we need a pc...but it isn't so weird...,for me is a normal abitude

secondly..if i'm not wrong,,,(but i haven't tested yet,,so this can be an useless suggestion) already exist some kind of devices which can avoid the pc and make communicate 2 non host usb....without pc...,maybe...but maybe not

3rd...we can use NOW storage cards,,,half giga/1/2 ??
and advantage ourselves with some good soft such the Grek tool and the chicks tool..the only limit is coming from us

so for my opinion technology is a great invention..but before
i have to know and use widely the machine i have...
i have a Triton too and ..even with her 4 years of life...still amazes me...even if i believe in the great Roland ability to surprise me a lot...such with my new X6 ; ))))


stop and bye
i've loved fantom and tritons then i've found my Oasys..
i swap it for m3m and Fantom G....

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

6 Nov 2004, 01:26
hahahah .... you guys crack me up...

the fantom does more with less than any other keyboard on the market... I do full production from start to finish on this board with great sampling and multisampling ... to me it seems like you try too hard.... artemio is right... the next super synth would not be enough for you because then you would want it to be wireless with internet so you could download samples on the fly from the internet and... lets see why not add 24 realtime control surfaces... so you can adjust everything at once.... oh yea and mabey so the REAL workstation guys dont feel left out lets add a 300 gig Hard drive with no limit on the sampler... so we can have a 7000 sample, multisampled, multi layer, velocity layered, with pitch and formant control vocoder Piano PATCH......

make your freakin wish list... but mark my words... at the point that all your wishes come true.... you my friend will not be unique anymore... because everyone will be able to do the same thing you can.... because its so easy... its just a button touch away on the latest superkeyboard ..... I would rather it be a little dificult to make these boards do what you want.... it keeps the wannabees out of your way.... then of course...it may just be the wannabees complaining about the lack of features anyways..... cause I know im completely satisfied with my board ... and im not a wannabe...

Jesus can make your music better :)

JC THE MC...

JC THE MC...
Fantom X6 2.10,Garage Band,Kliptch Pro media monitors, sennheiser hd 280 pro headphones and a Mac Mini!

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

6 Nov 2004, 02:03
I think everyone has a preference in creation. I myself only use the machine to create an idea then go on to other methods for perfection. Not to say perfection can't be obtained on the fantom. I just leave the perfection to others whose ability I trust more than my own. After all these are only just machines and so far in my life I have never met a machine that can write a composition. It still takes a human's fingers to get that. Just enjoy what you enjoy and leave the rest to a higher power. JMIO.

"Timeless Music Without Limits" ©2004 Pianodick
"Get a man drinkin' or get a man thinkin' he'll wind up looking for angles. Get a man smokin' or get a man chokin' he'll wind up looking for angels!"©2006 All rights reserved

Re: To Roland: Wish list for next Fantom workstation

6 Nov 2004, 02:05
Upps! sorry. Forgot: 8 outs (like the xv5080)
I do 99% live performance

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X