techie wrote:
So my current solution for a Studio Set with piano is to reduce volume for synth and drums parts in Studio Set view and raising for piano. E.g. piano is set to 127, synth lead to 70 and drums to 72. Not very convenient but at least i can hear piano at the same level of details then.
Maybe somebody can give more advanced explanation to this problem. Synth patches use same velocity curve, since it's a global value. Why the sound much more detailed and louder?
Actually, this has been the solution to the problem forever! I've never owned a synth over the years you didn't have to do this to.
Couple of reasons:
1. Some manufacturers don't even bother to attempt to balance sounds out!
2. With synthesized sounds, a Filter not only removes frequencies but also decreases the overall volume. So there's no real way to predict the end user's Filter setting on any sound, and thus no way to predict how loud the end result will be. So, rather than limit you, they make sure it's plenty loud on the top end, and let you pull it down to whatever you need (and it's always better to cut than boost).
3. All sounds have different envelopes, but those with "sustain" charachteristics - those that continue to make sound at the same volume as long as the key is held - such as Organ, Strings, Synths, etc. will "feel" or "seem" louder overall - so a Piano sound might hit 127 and fade to 20, but an Organ sound may hit only 80 but remain at 80. It's going to make the Organ "seem" louder even though the piano actually is louder - it's just that the piano's full volume happens for only a percentage of the sounding time, mostly right at the beginning.
This has to do with "perception" but again, the manufacturers build in ways for us to reduce the volume of things that are perceived louder so we can balance things as necessary.
4. Drums and other percussive instruments, including really any short but quick attack sound like Piano, Guitar, or even String Pizz and Harp, etc. have fast transient peaks. These happen really quickly but we don't really perceive them as super loud - they simply go by so fast our brains can't track them (this is kind of how compression for mp3s work).
In digital audio, they have to keep these peaks below 0 dbfs so they don't clip. However, it's not uncommon to put a limiter on drums helping to bring up the overall perceived level (which could be done to Piano and other instruments as well, and in the recording studio, commonly is).
5. Finally, even though the velocity curve is the same, how an instrument responds to the velocity curve varies too. Simply put, a synth oscillator may be "on" when it sees any number above 0, and "off" at 0. But there might be no difference at all between 1 and 127. It's a "non-velocity sensitive patch".
Harpsichord *should* react this way if it's being authentic becuase in the real world, there are no dynamics on a harpsichord - as soon as the quill plucks the string, you get 100% of the instrument's volume, period. It's either not playing a note, or it plays it at 100%, Every note played is played at full volume.
So, if a Harpsichord patch was velocity sensitive for some reason, one might want to play it with a keyboard set to a "fixed" setting on one with a velocity curve that reaches full volume really quickly and easily, so that it emulates the real thing.
So manufacturers give us control over both the overall volume of each patch as well as the velocity curve on the instrument, and in some cases you can even adjust how a patch responds to velocity information so we can have a big enough range to make all the adjustments we can.
You can, on some patches for example, use a lower velocity (like some guitar patches will play a muted guitar sound at velocities below 64) to create a "less intense" sounding sound, but use the volume to raise it to the level of everything else.
All this helps to compensate for our brain's inability to perceive all sounds the same as well as the technical limitations of digital audio and synthesis techniques, etc, as well as simply the logistics that some people might want a quiet instrument loud, a loud instrument quiet, an instrument that normally has dynamic range to have none, and other artistic purposes.
So I wouldn't ever call these things a "flaw" per se (though I will gripe about certain elements!) but just something else you need to learn to get the most out of these types of instruments.