FA-06 / FA-07 / FA-08

FA-06 real world reviews!!

FA-06 real world reviews!!

13 Mar 2015, 20:06
The FA-06/08 is just a XP-50/60/80 with simple sampler and some other functions thrown in for good measure it has the integra engine but seems very weak in the sound department. Sure we can make the sounds big and fat with layers and such, but it seems the Roland guys lagged on this model and didnt do all the work as they did in the Fantom-X Series. Dont get me wrong I like this board, but it just needs a lot of programming in my opinion, but then again I remember when I got the X it took a while to get that one into shape as well, but in the X the sounds were fatter and bigger straight from the factory. These tones seem thin and need to be worked on to make some good quality usable layers and splits space sounds are great, but not always usable in most cases, anyway this is a good update for the XP-50 though!! My 2 cents!

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

13 Mar 2015, 23:19
They'll have to pry the FA from my cold dead fingers but they can have my Fantom-X anytime ;)

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

14 Mar 2015, 02:16
I agree. I own both XP50 and FA-06. In spite of number of tones the sound quality is very similar.
Roland seems focusing on middle price range gears. If Roland planning to release a FG the successor at all ?

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

14 Mar 2015, 08:52
We forgot the SNA sounds, SND and the very powerful SNS engine...and the tonewheel clone...and last but not least the SND engine

Having said that, yes, FA is a midrange workstation, not in the same league as kronos...but it is my impression roland doesn't believe anymore in top level WS, because of the strong competition ov DAWs and VSTs

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

14 Mar 2015, 12:13
I owned an XP80 until 2010 and now have an Integra and a MoXF. Knowing the FA sounds based on the Integra, I don't think you can say it is nearly like the XP50/80.
The PCM sounds taken from the XV5080 are indeed close or identical to the XP, but the SN-A sounds have to be much more advanced. Thinking back to the XP80 preset piano, it was so artificial, extremely short-looped, no comparison to the SN-A pianos.
The best part besides SN-A are the SRX/EXP expansions, which again offer more choice and in some cases newer samples (SRX 03,04,10,11,12) than the old SR-JV expansions for the XP50/80.
Unfortunately, I think 2 slots for expansions is not enough. If Roland released an FA which had all of the Integra SN-A sounds and at least 4 slots for EXPs, it would be a big upgrade.

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

14 Mar 2015, 12:24
To make the FA a real flagship these upgrades would be needed:
- a real sampler (timestretch multisampling etc)
- more slots for EXP/User samples
- audio tracks
- mouse interface
- PC editor
- all the integra SNA engines

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

15 Mar 2015, 05:22
By the way I would also like to see 256 polyphony at some point in a WS.

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

15 Mar 2015, 08:51
The FA series are pretty weak as workstations. I have not purchased one because of their lack of serious workstation features. The Fantom G had a really nice platform going which was a real jump from the previous models. With a Sequencer with what up to 128 tracks of MIDI, 24 tracks of audio, independent effects per channel what was not to love? I got the Fantom X6 which is good but it needs more tracks for MIDI and Audio. but the Fantom G was discontinued before I could get it. Now the FA series is out and they really are a step backwards in workstations. Frustrating.

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

15 Mar 2015, 10:35
Again, FA is not the fantom follow up (look at the price), it is more a sort of Juno evolution...it is playing in the krome/moxf arena, and if you look at it this way it is far from disappointing imho

Then if Roland has any plan for a true fantom g follow up...I don't know, but I think they haven't

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

15 Mar 2015, 11:02
synthtron, get a second hand Fantom G as I did; it is reslly good and together with the Integra 7 no need for an FA-06/08.
Cyrano is right the FA is not a Fantom G replacement and won't be. It is a Krome equivalent at best and I suppose better in some respect but far inferior to a Kronos or Motif.

I have been disappointed by Roland but as Cyrano says (in another thread) they do not listen to customers experience but profit.

in a way I hope the future will tell Roland they have made a mistake but if they sell lots of keyboard like jd-xi/xa i am not sure they will go back to a full ws.

the bit I do not understand is why they have not kept the Fantom G alive with improvements; cost cutting maybe.

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

15 Mar 2015, 11:42
It is a simple financial calculation:

Profit=(sales volume*unit price)-((fixed costs)+(produced volume*unit costs)+(sales costs))

Fixed costs are the research costs and the other overhead costs not directly related to the goods production while sales costs are the costs incurred for the marketing and sale operations (szles force, promotion, advertising etcetera

This calculation should be done for each product projecting the results over let's say 10 years and calculating the NPV (the profit discounted by a certain discount rate: 100 $ today are a different thing than 100 $ in 5 years time)

The products or projects with the best NPV will be produced and sold... The others, not

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

15 Mar 2015, 12:07
leone123 wrote:
synthtron, get a second hand Fantom G as I did;
I actually ended up getting a used Roland MV-8000 recently to sequence on now (Computer DAWs frustrate me) and I have retired my Fantom X6 and MMT-8 sequencers as a result.

I actually prefer synthesizers over workstations and would like to see Roland continue to innovate and push their synthesizer brands. The idea of the JD crossover Synthesizers are great!

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

15 Mar 2015, 13:19
Synthtron wrote:
leone123 wrote:
synthtron, get a second hand Fantom G as I did;
I actually ended up getting a used Roland MV-8000 recently to sequence on now (Computer DAWs frustrate me) and I have retired my Fantom X6 and MMT-8 sequencers as a result.

I actually prefer synthesizers over workstations and would like to see Roland continue to innovate and push their synthesizer brands. The idea of the JD crossover Synthesizers are great!
well that is in a way what I did with buying the fantom g so that I have 128 midi tracks and 24 audio tracks without a pc or mac.
maybe it is me but I do not get the JD crossover synth! one analogue voice? I have various synths from Roland but the main reason is for polyfony reasons.
If I could have the same power engine of the 8 synths I have inside a single ws that would be my ultimate dream... I also think the arpeggiator functions in Roland synths is very weak as I cannot have a different instance of arpeggiator for each parts. This is not great cor live.

I read that the pc3k series of Kurzweil can have an arpeggiator instance for each part playing independently.. I wonder how Kurzweil are.... not many here in the UK... at least advertised!

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

15 Mar 2015, 16:33
The JD-Xa is a single analog voice while JD-XA is said to have 4 voices.

The JD-Xi may not be for me but the JD-XA is in the direction I am interested. Would be nice if it was 6 voice polyphony on the analog engine but it is a start.

Re: FA-06 real world reviews!!

15 Mar 2015, 16:35
Synthtron wrote:
The JD-Xa is a single analog voice while JD-XA is said to have 4 voices.

The JD-Xi may not be for me but the JD-XA is in the direction I am interested. Would be nice if it was 6 voice polyphony on the analog engine but it is a start.
Maybe you could be interested in the new prophet 6

← Back to FA-06 / FA-07 / FA-08