FA-06 / FA-07 / FA-08

Why does Roland FA get bad press?

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

14 Feb 2014, 21:03
Yesterday I was surprised to see a Roland FA-06 on display at a local music store here in Nagano-city, JAPAN. Honestly, I thought the build quality and overall look was not good at all. I was kind of excited at first, but when I saw the price at $1,115.00 and the toyish look of it all I didn't have any problem passing up on it. The keys seemed to play ok and the LCD screen was nice. I didn't like the drum pads on it. They seemed very small and a bit stiff. I'm coming from a Fantom X6 size workstation and just felt it was overall much cheaper looking and feeling than my X6. I'll wait a couple of years and grab it at half price. It'll drop in Japan.

I definitely think Yamaha and Korg will be more popular than the Roland where I'm at. Now the AIRA might be a whole other story. That will probably do well, but I just don't see the music store here selling many of the Roland FA-06 which makes me think I'll be seeing a huge price drop very soon in Japan. I definitely think the Integra coupled with another synth like the X or G is a better combo. The staff was excited, but also worried. They have Korg, Yamaha, and a few other synths competing with the FA-06 and they just don't see it selling well. I tend to agree with them. We'll see.

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

15 Feb 2014, 03:45
Ricoche wrote:
Yesterday I was surprised to see a Roland FA-06 on display at a local music store here in Nagano-city, JAPAN. Honestly, I thought the build quality and overall look was not good at all. I was kind of excited at first, but when I saw the price at $1,115.00 and the toyish look of it all I didn't have any problem passing up on it. The keys seemed to play ok and the LCD screen was nice. I didn't like the drum pads on it. They seemed very small and a bit stiff. I'm coming from a Fantom X6 size workstation and just felt it was overall much cheaper looking and feeling than my X6. I'll wait a couple of years and grab it at half price. It'll drop in Japan.

I definitely think Yamaha and Korg will be more popular than the Roland where I'm at. Now the AIRA might be a whole other story. That will probably do well, but I just don't see the music store here selling many of the Roland FA-06 which makes me think I'll be seeing a huge price drop very soon in Japan. I definitely think the Integra coupled with another synth like the X or G is a better combo. The staff was excited, but also worried. They have Korg, Yamaha, and a few other synths competing with the FA-06 and they just don't see it selling well. I tend to agree with them. We'll see.
The FA doesn't have Drum Pads!! those are the Sampler buttons, no velocity or Aftertouch sensitivity on those. The whole purpose are to be used as triggers.
Make Music and be Happy !!
PauloF

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

19 Feb 2014, 22:17
Roland probably gets bad press among amateur wanna-be players. I watch Palladia all the time. Roland & Yamaha are the most widely seen synths/keys there, followed by Nord & Kurz.

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

20 Feb 2014, 09:25
I think the bad press is not just for Roland. it is for yamaha/korg and others as well. People expect the world from them. They in fact try to accommodate as many as features as possible to sell more units. I don't believe in loyalty to any manufactures anymore because each manufacture are including different features. it is really good for consumers. cannot expect one single unit to full fill all your wishes/wants/needs.

secondly, with computer based workstations, world has changed around making music. do we still need full blown workstations without computer? manufactures are struggling to figure this out. This is a special time in history. making music is in transition now. I don't believe any manufactures will create anything like Fantom G nor Motif XF nor Kronos anymore. new format will be different and we are all in the process of defining it as we speak. $1500 price range is the new budget manufactures are thinking for a average workstations. so don't expect too much from those type of workstations, cheap built, etc. I predict in another 3-4 yrs we will see another set of workstations but people with existing workstations will be disappointed as well. because these units are setting new trends.

With the lessons learned from MOXF/FA/Krome, there will be new set of workstations in 3-5 yrs time. question is if you want to wait for that long or move on making music...:) let's go and make some music.

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

14 Mar 2014, 20:55
The only bad press that might be deserved is the limited sampling compared to the Fantoms. I want to like the FA-06 but I rely on sampling so much if I use the Fantom X. Its just too much of a step down...

B

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

25 Nov 2014, 06:18
ref Why does Roland FA get bad press?

I guess you've never publicly admitted to owning a casio then ? :-p


Synth manufacturers like DLSR camera manufacturers are still living in the dark ages.

The products weak, dated, flawed and generally not fit for purpose

Lack of vision at corporate AND product design level

Fender solved most key guitar design problems with the stratocaster back in the 50's ...the rest is history




Consider this

The chip that drives your computer monitor costs about 5 bucks tops, heck you can buy an entire motherboard for 50 bucks....YET you still cant plug a computer monitor into the back of a typical synth...and u can pick up a second hand computer monitor for a crate of beer

THATS how retarded snyth manufacturers are

Hardly any synthesizers allow you to record and play back a single track of audio in wav format with the same ease of a 1970's radio shack tape recorder. Here again the chip to do that cost 5 bucks or less.

THATS how retarded synth manufacturers are

Q which synth comes with a built in video tutorial ? some have colour screens all make sound ! last time i looked you can fit 10 hours of video on a 5 buck SD card or USB stick and thats at retail prices.

THATS how retarded synth manufacturers are

Most crapsui mobile phones of a decade ago have bigger screens than most synths of today. Last time i looked everyone's TV screen and Computer Monitor has got significantly bigger year on year. Synth screens aren't even close to being as big as they need to be.

THATS how retarded synth manufacturers are

For the last 50 years computer power has doubled evey 18 months, so has the internal complexity, the potential options giving that extra grunt has gone exponential yet the physical interface and end user design has effectively stagnated.

THATS how retarded synth manufacturers are

I can write out a massive list of blindingly obvious flaws yet to be addressed. Roland and others deserve ALL the flak they get and then some!

SHEER + UTTER + CONTEMPT

If any exec from Roland, Korg, Casio, Yamaha whatever is reading this...im for hire !

Typical end user reviewing your products
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bLZky9aMQTg

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

5 Dec 2014, 05:01
Until you can get a "Kronos like" instrument for $1500 or a "Kronos killer" at the top end, the dis-satisfaction for new models with existing owners will continue imho. The FA series is a value play on the current (arguably rigged) mid-market segment nothing more nothing less, pretty good value for new owners less so for existing owners looking for innovation.

Krome, MOXF, FA or 2nd hand market for last gen take your pick or pass.

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

5 Dec 2014, 16:56
Unfinished products updates takes years and sometime
You don't get up dates at all the one reason roland gets bad
Press I loved my mv8800 I sold it because you could no stream samples
You always had to load projects to use samples
But that's why I think roland get bad press

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

5 Dec 2014, 19:04
I haven't seen any (official) bad press on the FA06, not to the extent of labelling it a poor product anyway.

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

6 Dec 2014, 14:03
To be a 2014 board, with cheaper technology versus 2005 when I got a fantom X8 for 2400 new. The 1799 price point seems like it could have actually had a few more features. Now regret the sale of my X8 last spring


I miss
patch, mixer, and live buttons.
All of the "shift" clicking to find things buried is also a nuisance. More so that what the fantom required.
assigning musical pattern to keys or the pads (with velocity control) with about 4 button clicks.
velocity pads are missed in general.
kind of miss the dedicated piano button and being able to adjust the piano lid.
A sequence that saved the instruments without you having to create a "live set" for it.

I've had a FA08 for a few days and it is not earning its keep here so far. I don't plan to do DAW work and the lack of what would be largely software driven features, not hardware, is rather annoying as soft items dont really add to cost like hardware.

Re: Why does Roland FA get bad press?

2 Jan 2015, 12:44
ref Press the keys and buttons, stuff the press.

The FA series is designed for techno hipsters and fan boys , look at the glossy's , facia screen etc etc

That said the technology and feature bloat has advanced to such a state that the clusterflock of weak features you get on the FA means that most humans will find something useful....as ever utility = manual wading

Human beings like shiny toys to play with, musicians and other productive people NEED WYSIWYG work tools.


Reason for Bad press ?

Hipsters suffer from feature anxiety, productive types want ease of use. Human beings need about 50k's worth of synths before they are satisfied that their creative needs are being met......expect bad press until mankind has figured out how to cram 50k's worth utility into a box costing 5k or 500 beer tolkens

The FA looks like the kind of synth i would design as a $500 entry level device, but the UI and half baked feature set makes me want to drive a Segway of a cliff

← Back to FA-06 / FA-07 / FA-08