JUPITER-50

Faulty Generic Midi Driver?

Faulty Generic Midi Driver?

27 May 2014, 18:50
Dear all,

my JP50 is showing a strange behavior, and I would like to ask you to experiment this (just to check whether it is just my unit):

1. Choose the Generic-Midi Driver (from Menu-System-Setup-MISC-USB Driver Section)
2. Select an empty registration, and choose live set "1932 Tight Horns"
3. Now connect the JP50 to your PC/MAC (via USB), and start playing chords repeatedly and reasonably fast (for my test I was playing a Gm chord with at least four notes, just to give you an idea).

What do you hear? I hear severe drops and lags of notes.

I do not have installed on my MAC the specific Roland driver: this clearly might make a difference, but I need to use the Generic Driver, since I control the JP50 from an Android tablet. I tried also with an iPad (both MidiMonitor app, and the JP50 app), experimenting the same kind of issue.

A final note: the issue is not with all sounds (mostly with SN brasses, I do not know why). Also, if I use an external MIDI-USB interface (connected to the standard midi in and out of the JP50) I experience no problem.

Thanks to whoever wants to try the above experiment.

Regards,

G.

p.s. I asked to a friend of mine to test this on its JP80: no problem there.

Re: Faulty Generic Midi Driver?

29 May 2014, 08:22
gius_prenc wrote:
Dear all,

my JP50 is showing a strange behavior, and I would like to ask you to experiment this (just to check whether it is just my unit):

1. Choose the Generic-Midi Driver (from Menu-System-Setup-MISC-USB Driver Section)
2. Select an empty registration, and choose live set "1932 Tight Horns"
3. Now connect the JP50 to your PC/MAC (via USB), and start playing chords repeatedly and reasonably fast (for my test I was playing a Gm chord with at least four notes, just to give you an idea).

What do you hear? I hear severe drops and lags of notes.

I do not have installed on my MAC the specific Roland driver: this clearly might make a difference, but I need to use the Generic Driver, since I control the JP50 from an Android tablet. I tried also with an iPad (both MidiMonitor app, and the JP50 app), experimenting the same kind of issue.

A final note: the issue is not with all sounds (mostly with SN brasses, I do not know why). Also, if I use an external MIDI-USB interface (connected to the standard midi in and out of the JP50) I experience no problem.

Thanks to whoever wants to try the above experiment.

Regards,

G.

p.s. I asked to a friend of mine to test this on its JP80: no problem there.
You mean that this strange behavior only occurs when the JP-50 is connected to the computer via USB, and it doesn't when it's not?
Make Music and be Happy !!
PauloF

Re: Faulty Generic Midi Driver?

29 May 2014, 18:37
Hi;

yes, exactly: when connected to the computer, or to my Android tablet (running an app that I wrote to control the JP50), or to the iPad (while running the JP50 app).

Very strange: anyway, at least when connected to the Android tablet, if I select the "Vendor" midi mode , there is no problem. Unfortunately, the Vendor midi mode does not work for the iPad.

Regards,

G.

Re: Faulty Generic Midi Driver?

30 May 2014, 00:50
G.

Beginning with Windows XP Service Pack 2, MAC OS X 10.6.4, and the original iOS for the iPad, these operating systems came with "GENERIC" (read that as: "BASIC") MIDI drivers built-in and no longer required the installation of separate third party drivers. The intent was to provide "BASIC" MIDI connectivity for those who were new-to/unfamiliar-with MIDI technology and/or computing. For Windows, any devices that work with its built-in drivers are said to be "FULLY CLASS COMPLIANT". For MAC OS, such devices are said to be "CORE MIDI COMPLIANT". These built-in drivers support "BASIC" MIDI messages such as NOTE-ON, NOTE-OFF, VELOCITY, BANK SELECT, PROGRAM CHANGE, CONTINUOUS CONTROLLER, etc. but higher level messages, such as SYSTEM EXCLUSIVE (SYSEX) and BULK DATA DUMP are either limited or not supported at all. For Windows and MAC OS, you can still install full featured third party drivers for full support, and the keyboard will work with either, providing how you configure its MIDI set up. IN any case, these "DRIVERS" we are discussing are always located on the computing device - NOT on the keyboard. When you switch the keyboard MIDI setup between "GENERIC" or "VENDOR" you are just telling it what type of driver to go looking for on the computing device. Android devices are neither "FULLY CLASS' or "CORE MIDI" compliant, and therefore will not work with the "GENERIC" (CLASS COMPLIANT) setting on the keyboard. Likewise, since the iPad provides no means for installing third party drivers, it will only work with "COMPLIANT" devices with their MIDI configurations set to "GENERIC".

In regard to your original question (post): If you are experiencing strange keyboard sounds or behavior only when you have a MIDI connection established, you most likely have a MIDI feedback loop going. You need to configure your DAW software NOT to echo back to the keyboard what it receives from the keyboard - that is, turn off MIDI THRU or ECHO in your DAW software and MIDI THRU on the keyboard. Since USB MIDI is, by nature, bi-directional, inadvertent, unexpected MIDI feedback loops are a common occurrence. The same can happen with the old 5-pin-DIN MIDI connections when both connections (cables) are used.

Hope this helps.

Regards,

Ted

Re: Faulty Generic Midi Driver?

30 May 2014, 20:00
gius_prenc wrote:
Hi;

yes, exactly: when connected to the computer, or to my Android tablet (running an app that I wrote to control the JP50), or to the iPad (while running the JP50 app).

Very strange: anyway, at least when connected to the Android tablet, if I select the "Vendor" midi mode , there is no problem. Unfortunately, the Vendor midi mode does not work for the iPad.

Regards,

G.
I also suspect a MIDI loop. Please read tnicoson's post and check if it's the case here
Make Music and be Happy !!
PauloF

Re: Faulty Generic Midi Driver?

31 May 2014, 10:00
Hi;

thanks for your answers.

The point is that I do not run any software or Daw after connecting the USB to my MAC: I just plug the JP50 to the computer. As I said, the problem also occurs when I connect th JP50 to the iPad and run the JP50 app.

So, there should be no midi loop involved.

I am asking just because I developed an Android app (currently on the Google Play Store -- MIDI Commander) to control midi devices, and I am having these issues only with the JP50 when the generic midi driver is selected (I tried it with several other keyboards, of course).

At the beginning I thought it was an issue with the midi communication with my app; but then, I found out that the same problem occurs with the computer (again, just connecting the cable), and with iPad with the specific JP50 app.

Anyway, I will try to prepare a video, to show you the problem.

Regards,

G.

← Back to JUPITER-50