Considering Fantom G over Kronos?
29 Sep 2011, 13:09Hello:
I'm preparing to buy a new workstation.
However, the term workstation for my purposes must provide a sensible approach to the design and implementation of the seq functions.
I've downloaded both the Kronos and fantom manuals- everything including roland's new mini topic specific PDFs which are well written.
For years, I've used the following as a non-computer approach to synth composition:
Ensoniq sd-1 32 voice, as the seq application, midi'ed to roland jv-1080, then switched to 2080, then finally to the xv-5080.
Therefore, I'm familiar with the rolands and was somewhat surprised to see that the G is still very similar to the voice structure/programming/editing, etc., of all my rolands... this is actually very good news.
Even though the kronos is, as a synthesizer strictly, more varied/powerful, the sequencer is just lame and convoluted compared to the G.
Of course, all of my analysis of the matter is based upon manuals, so in reality, the kronos may not be as bad as it appears from the manuals. Likewise, the G may have disappointments as well.
It will be somewhat impracticable to go to guitar center and attempt to artistically run these sequencers through their paces.
Since I found the previous roland's satisfactory when relied upon as basic/solid modules when under the control of the sd-1 sequencer, using roland as the seq and synth may be a different story.
As far as I could tell when comparing the G and K sequencer functions to the sd-1, here is what I was looking for in basic seq functions which seemed to be missing or convoluted in the k compared to the ensoniq and to some degree equal or better than either the sd-1 or K on the fantom:
Very basic for me...
Record a midi track, decide that the normal performance controllers: mod wheel, pitch wheel, pressure and velocity need to be edited. OK, so on the ensoniq, I choose any one of those and have the following basic and logical functions without using an event list editor:
Scale by xx, plus or minus (multiply by) the entire track, by in/out locations and or by keyboard range, as well simple stuff like delete by the same as above. When edit is executed, then compare this with old or last version. Surely these would be very basic and useful tools... not on the K, but the G appears to include at minimum the above, but I say appears because there were areas that lacked clarity in those manual topics.
There is more I'd like to express, but I need to view the responses here before I add any more please.
BTW, it is possible that roland will come to market soon with a new flagship unit which might change everything, then there is the motif stuff, which have a very nice sound set, but even more convoluted seq and voice architecture, from my perspective or methods of workflow.
The G is more simple/logical in dealing with synthesis engine editing (more classic) and especially this one very big deal (If it is still like xv5080) you can edit at the synth level from multi-mode, but that was a module... what happens when you are PLAYING back the seq and want to edit real-time those programs, can this still be done?
One other matter please... I see here at this forum that due to memory constraints, the use of USB sticks are not working well unless using rolands. Kronos is way ahead here and most important, korg factory personnel are very present. Is roland equally present and ready to address issues?
After-all, support is a big deal.
I'm preparing to buy a new workstation.
However, the term workstation for my purposes must provide a sensible approach to the design and implementation of the seq functions.
I've downloaded both the Kronos and fantom manuals- everything including roland's new mini topic specific PDFs which are well written.
For years, I've used the following as a non-computer approach to synth composition:
Ensoniq sd-1 32 voice, as the seq application, midi'ed to roland jv-1080, then switched to 2080, then finally to the xv-5080.
Therefore, I'm familiar with the rolands and was somewhat surprised to see that the G is still very similar to the voice structure/programming/editing, etc., of all my rolands... this is actually very good news.
Even though the kronos is, as a synthesizer strictly, more varied/powerful, the sequencer is just lame and convoluted compared to the G.
Of course, all of my analysis of the matter is based upon manuals, so in reality, the kronos may not be as bad as it appears from the manuals. Likewise, the G may have disappointments as well.
It will be somewhat impracticable to go to guitar center and attempt to artistically run these sequencers through their paces.
Since I found the previous roland's satisfactory when relied upon as basic/solid modules when under the control of the sd-1 sequencer, using roland as the seq and synth may be a different story.
As far as I could tell when comparing the G and K sequencer functions to the sd-1, here is what I was looking for in basic seq functions which seemed to be missing or convoluted in the k compared to the ensoniq and to some degree equal or better than either the sd-1 or K on the fantom:
Very basic for me...
Record a midi track, decide that the normal performance controllers: mod wheel, pitch wheel, pressure and velocity need to be edited. OK, so on the ensoniq, I choose any one of those and have the following basic and logical functions without using an event list editor:
Scale by xx, plus or minus (multiply by) the entire track, by in/out locations and or by keyboard range, as well simple stuff like delete by the same as above. When edit is executed, then compare this with old or last version. Surely these would be very basic and useful tools... not on the K, but the G appears to include at minimum the above, but I say appears because there were areas that lacked clarity in those manual topics.
There is more I'd like to express, but I need to view the responses here before I add any more please.
BTW, it is possible that roland will come to market soon with a new flagship unit which might change everything, then there is the motif stuff, which have a very nice sound set, but even more convoluted seq and voice architecture, from my perspective or methods of workflow.
The G is more simple/logical in dealing with synthesis engine editing (more classic) and especially this one very big deal (If it is still like xv5080) you can edit at the synth level from multi-mode, but that was a module... what happens when you are PLAYING back the seq and want to edit real-time those programs, can this still be done?
One other matter please... I see here at this forum that due to memory constraints, the use of USB sticks are not working well unless using rolands. Kronos is way ahead here and most important, korg factory personnel are very present. Is roland equally present and ready to address issues?
After-all, support is a big deal.