Fantom-G

Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

29 Sep 2011, 13:09
Hello:

I'm preparing to buy a new workstation.
However, the term workstation for my purposes must provide a sensible approach to the design and implementation of the seq functions.
I've downloaded both the Kronos and fantom manuals- everything including roland's new mini topic specific PDFs which are well written.
For years, I've used the following as a non-computer approach to synth composition:
Ensoniq sd-1 32 voice, as the seq application, midi'ed to roland jv-1080, then switched to 2080, then finally to the xv-5080.
Therefore, I'm familiar with the rolands and was somewhat surprised to see that the G is still very similar to the voice structure/programming/editing, etc., of all my rolands... this is actually very good news.
Even though the kronos is, as a synthesizer strictly, more varied/powerful, the sequencer is just lame and convoluted compared to the G.
Of course, all of my analysis of the matter is based upon manuals, so in reality, the kronos may not be as bad as it appears from the manuals. Likewise, the G may have disappointments as well.
It will be somewhat impracticable to go to guitar center and attempt to artistically run these sequencers through their paces.
Since I found the previous roland's satisfactory when relied upon as basic/solid modules when under the control of the sd-1 sequencer, using roland as the seq and synth may be a different story.
As far as I could tell when comparing the G and K sequencer functions to the sd-1, here is what I was looking for in basic seq functions which seemed to be missing or convoluted in the k compared to the ensoniq and to some degree equal or better than either the sd-1 or K on the fantom:
Very basic for me...
Record a midi track, decide that the normal performance controllers: mod wheel, pitch wheel, pressure and velocity need to be edited. OK, so on the ensoniq, I choose any one of those and have the following basic and logical functions without using an event list editor:
Scale by xx, plus or minus (multiply by) the entire track, by in/out locations and or by keyboard range, as well simple stuff like delete by the same as above. When edit is executed, then compare this with old or last version. Surely these would be very basic and useful tools... not on the K, but the G appears to include at minimum the above, but I say appears because there were areas that lacked clarity in those manual topics.
There is more I'd like to express, but I need to view the responses here before I add any more please.

BTW, it is possible that roland will come to market soon with a new flagship unit which might change everything, then there is the motif stuff, which have a very nice sound set, but even more convoluted seq and voice architecture, from my perspective or methods of workflow.
The G is more simple/logical in dealing with synthesis engine editing (more classic) and especially this one very big deal (If it is still like xv5080) you can edit at the synth level from multi-mode, but that was a module... what happens when you are PLAYING back the seq and want to edit real-time those programs, can this still be done?

One other matter please... I see here at this forum that due to memory constraints, the use of USB sticks are not working well unless using rolands. Kronos is way ahead here and most important, korg factory personnel are very present. Is roland equally present and ready to address issues?
After-all, support is a big deal.

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

29 Sep 2011, 21:35
After thoroughly reading the Kurzweil's sequencer functions- especially editable functions- the PC3K is my first choice.
Best wishes to all.

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

30 Sep 2011, 09:07
not sure wat kind of music you do, but unless you MUST have an all-in-one unit i highly recommend you get a RD700NX (or any controller of your choice with pitchbend/modulation) + DAW of your choice. you will net so much more for less and unlimited expandability.

kronos is great and all but as i mentioned, it's a glorified workstation of yesterday.

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

2 Oct 2011, 23:35
I have Sonar producer edition 8.3 loaded on a custom audio PC/win7 ultimate x64,i7,6 gig ram, MOTU 828mk3.
I do not like it.
I must find a reasonable workstation whose seq functions in a musically useful manner.
In my original post, which explained some basic edit functions apart from event list editing, can you comment as to whether the G can provide this please?
Would you like to buy my DAW?

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

3 Oct 2011, 07:57
I must find a reasonable workstation whose seq functions in a musically useful manner
Its called a fantom G ;)

But seriously..
Im comfortable with the G either with or without a DAW.
knowing it as i do.. i can safely say i wont be looking for a replacement for a long time..
have said that,
building around it and the future is DAW and soft synths.

Best way to view the G is like a laptop (fantom G) and a docking station (DAW)

The G being the laptop for doing what you need when you dont have access the the power of the DAW/docking station.

But them together and MAGIC!

Now there are some downsides to the G which you have to aware of and plan accordingly
the filesystem is one and not being able to move multisamples from project to project..

But if your real task is just making music...
it will all work out.



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

5 Oct 2011, 12:09
Considering Fantom G over Kronos?
you've got to be kidding - there is no comparison whatsoever...
not even same league.

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

5 Oct 2011, 17:08
philmagnotta wrote:
Would you like to buy my DAW?
Actually, I might like to buy your DAW. Although, I'm not interested in the MOTU, you'd probably be better keeping that if you bought it retail. I'm curious if you're running it via Firewire or USB.

PS. I don't think it's crazy you're considering the Fantom over a Kronos. It didn't impress me as a workstation at all.

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

15 Oct 2011, 13:37
phil,
It is a matter of personal preference in my opinion.All of these keyboards are powerful but the Roland Fantom G does all that you ask for and even more.The only thing in my opinion that Kronos is good for is the synthesis technique and maybe live performances.But from what I 've read in your post it seems you are more of a home studio kind of guy for which Roland is perfect.Kurzweil is powerful but overall wise I would suggest you get the Fantom G.Trust me , you will not be disappointed.But remember to upgrade your Fantom G once you get it and I guarantee you won't need or want to touch a PC DAW anymore!

Good luck with whatever decision you take,

roland lover!

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

17 Oct 2011, 08:16
You are seriously kidding right?

The Fantom G cannot compare in any way shape or form to the ease, functionality, performance or capability to even the cheapest of daw

rolandlover wrote:
phil,
.Kurzweil is powerful but overall wise I would suggest you get the Fantom G.Trust me , you will not be disappointed.But remember to upgrade your Fantom G once you get it and I guarantee you won't need or want to touch a PC DAW anymore!

Good luck with whatever decision you take,

roland lover!

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

17 Oct 2011, 09:14
True..
However I have and can manage to do a completely finished and mastered track on the G just like any DAW.
Okay its not as quick or flexible but can be done.



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

17 Oct 2011, 23:20
Have the Kronos and the Fantom g, I can't decide which should be over the other, on my two tiered stand


The are both excellent workstations, directly comparable

It depends on your needs and wants

I use the Fantom g for song arrangement, I enjoy the sequencer

I use the Kronos for karma and the various sound engines

Don't be fooled by those who dis one or the other, they both sound excellent, the approach to your music and your workflow should be your deciding factor
Fantom G & X7, Motif XS6, M3, V-synth, JP8000, M1, Wavestation, Radias, Nord Lead 2X, Karma, Snow, electribes and other groove boxes.

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

18 Oct 2011, 05:25
workflow should be your deciding factor
True

For me the X/G has been there.
The G is great as both a workstation DAW and controller.
However my analogy of now workstation v PC Daw is a kin to my comparison of game system v computer.

Years ago i could never understand why buy and game console when a computer can do it and more..
computers have advanced so much now that the same comparison can now be made with
workstation v Computer..

Im currently using my G with a pc DAW, Omnisphere and tone2 Gladiator.
The possibilities with these are endless beyond belief.
Moving forward.. PC DAW and softsynth are the future of production when it comes to workflow.

I no longer see a workstation filling this gap as its no longer cost effective and you end up getting minor advances for your money compared to the pc Daw solution.

example..
Jp80 is 3500k
you get more with Omnisphere for under $500 and knocks the socks off anything you get from the jp80.

The only place for a workstation is live work and even that is starting to fade too..
But regardless of all of this.. the G still does fit nicely in there with the PC DAW.



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

20 Oct 2011, 11:41
Atlas5 wrote:
I use the Fantom g for song arrangement, I enjoy the sequencer
Good point. The Fantom G's sequencer is great for quickly arranging songs, and, in terms of midi editing, is almost the same as the Fantom X.

Just a few features missing, but these can be very easily worked around.
Since "Time Fit" and "Exchange" are no longer a problem, Extract can be very easy reproduced using Duplicate -> Copy channel X at the end of the phrase -> Delete multitimbral part.

In terms of merging phrases, assigning them to the dynamic pads makes it very easy to merge not just two, but more phrases, totally or partially.

The sequencer of the Fantom G is definitely not an excuse for anyone blaming this keyboard.

Re: Considering Fantom G over Kronos?

20 Oct 2011, 12:28
never mind.
Can You Touch The Apex

← Back to Fantom-G