JUPITER-80

Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

4 Sep 2011, 01:20
RayS wrote:
I am amazed at how deep this goes..and how easy to understand and edit it actually is. You can edit each of the live sets and then edit each one of the 4 tones that are located inside each one of the live sets. And edit with effects LFO etc each one of those as well. You can get some really different sounds by doing so on each and every live set. So easy to turn on/off any of the different parts. Unlike the Kronos, This is like the IPHONE of Keyboards I tell you.

The iPhone of the Keyboards...that's a good analogy ;-)

Congratulations to RayS and Cello

Give us your opinions about the "beast" ;-)
Make Music and be Happy !!
PauloF

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

6 Sep 2011, 21:20
The Kronos problems could end up being a real boon for Roland and company. If the Korg Kronos' build quality was similar to that of the Jupiter-80 most people would probably hang on to their Kronos and wouldn't give the JP-80 another thought most likely. But apparently Korg bungled the Kronos build quality big time even as evidence started pouring in where in some cases people were saying it was literally a piece of junk. No matter how good the Kronos may sound (and it does sound good) when the build quality is highly suspect and things start to unravel before your very eyes, no amount of "good sounds" could convince people to hang on to what is now considered by some people a highly questionable piece of junk. At least in some people's view anyway. Not all Kronos have been affected in the same way from what I understand. That doesn't excuse Korg from their obligation to keep "quality control" in check though.

This could turn out to be of great benefit to Roland's bottom line if you ask me. Kudos to Roland for continuing to put "build quality" as one of their top priorities, as we've seen with the Fantom G and the Jupiter-80. On the other hand, the tragic Kronos situation bodes very negatively for Korg since it demonstrates to people they have relegated "build quality" to the lower rung of the totem pole apparently; and they'll probably take a massive "hit" to their bottom line as a result.

This is good news for Roland, albeit, extremely bad for Korg's reputation as a professional keyboard company. Once your product quality starts to decline consumers have a tendency to wise up very quickly and will jump ship in droves to other companies that continue to produce "professionally" built, quality produced products. Like Roland obviously. :) Again, kudos to Roland. But shame, shame on Korg for producing what appears to be a mediocre product at best, as far as build quality is concerned anyway. I wouldn't touch a Kronos with a ten foot pole now. At least until Korg sorts this mess out. But I'm really hoping that Roland will eventually come through with a new "full blown" Flagship workstation. Perhaps debuting at the now famous Music Moscow Trade Show on September 15-18? ;) Roland's countdown counter may surprise everyone when it ticks down to September 15th. But then again, maybe not. :(

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

7 Sep 2011, 05:19
keysme,
you are exaggerating it a little bit here.
There are some weak design decisions from Korg regarding some parts (mainly on the dial) but Korg has made a statement and promised to care about. And users will get newly designed parts if they experience problems with their keyboards.
That's what I would call a good customer care and relation. The last time that we discussed some weak built quality on Roland keyboards here, a Roland employee simply stated that other companies have problems too!
It's true that poor built quality can hurt the image of Korg in future, but that is not automatically a special chance for Roland, and especially not for the jp80. Those are different keyboards for different purposes. In the same way, if you are dissatisfied with the built quality of a stage piano from one company, you probably won't instead buy an arranger keyboard from another company just because it seems to be built well. Apples to Oranges.

A good built quality is what we all expect, but it's not enough to give you an advance on the market. You don't buy a keyboard just because it's built like a tank, but because of what you can do with it.
Compare a Korg M3 and Fantom G and probably all would agree that the fantom g is built far better. Try to google "korg m3" and then "roland fantom g" and see the huge difference in found tags in favor of the M3. It's certainly not a scientific proof, but it shows that built quality is not enough to create the most interest.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

7 Sep 2011, 09:22
I firmly believe somewhere behind the scenes Korg is addressing build quality problems. Ultimately there will be a Kronos 2 with larger screen to effectively display the hordes of parameters and physical controls on par with similar instruments from Kurzweil, Yamaha & Roland. You'll never hear from a product mananger "hey we're building a better Kronos" because they must sell Kronos now..inspite of the issues. For the most part players are willing to accept a cheapened hardware device because they all want access to the software inside. To Korg's credit they have released OS upgrades and enhancements and new samples & sounds.

If Roland issued a thousand new sounds for the Jupiter I would have no idea how to integrate those into my existing programming.

Unfortunately Korg forum users, product management & their moderators have no tolerance for a differing opinion or a less-than-satisfied answer and it always degenerates into personal attacks between members. Right now they are slagging a Korg customer with real product issues in a 20 page thread.

OTOH most Jupiter owners seem fairly satisfied with their boards. Inspite of the months of negativity leading up the release of the Jupiter, the board Roland shipped has customers playing & creating music. Thank you all.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

7 Sep 2011, 10:32
Yes it is interesting what Roland is going to release Sept 15??? Hmm.. You know after playing the Jupiter a few days now I cant believe how nice and smooth the LED lighted sliders and knobs are also! Just a small added extra on this board...along with how easy using/seeing the touchscreen and making any edits are. Very easy to find any instrument sound almost instantly. I was glued for an hour just playing the sitar on Registration "Mumbai Pyramid" for an hour and couldnt believe how realistic the sitar sound it has.. and the "tone blender" on the registrations really tweak the sound. If you add the Arp along with the Tone BLender it is amazing the rhythm patterns and sounds it creates for you! The S1 and 2 buttons are even preloaded for you.

I would also like to point out how when I first saw all the online demos I thought ther Jupiter was more a live instrument sounds and not too many synth sounds. I was unexpected amazed at how many pads, synth, and drone sounds are in there as I though Korg had the best. The Kronos has more but most I had already heard before... but the Jupiter I was 100% wrong as the sweep sounds and the depth in the pads along with the way Roland did the pan, fade in and out is the best I have heard of any synth! Plus you can easily tweak them or use tone blender or the many different effects to get any different pad you desire.

One thing I do have to say for Korg and Kronos is that after I reported my data knob came off .. I was sent one free of charge within 30 days after they redesigned it. This is really good customer service and hope Roland will do the same if problems arise. Korg does work hard to keep their customers happy which is why I bought the OASYS,M3 and the Kronos. I wish I would have compared them both side by side in a music store somewhere before ordering one. I would have picked the Jupiter hands down.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

7 Sep 2011, 13:06
Comparing a kronos to a j80 is somewhat strange.
At the very least, one is a workstation and the other is not.
1. OK, so lets omit the workstation part and just compare the synth engine(s).
That would be a good start, so the OP may start there if he wishes.
2. Special features. please compare slider/knob/other hardware protrusions.
3. EXTERNAL build?
... Well I auditioned the kronos and j80. The j80 is much better as far as the way I examine things, but very few people know much about the electronics, electrical, board/soldering. cable... basically from an electronics design, how well those two, or those companies rate.
It is even more important that the internal design be compared for obvious reasons.
Anyone here know about these things or have access to service center records over a reasonable period regarding the big three?
It may be possible that in-spite of Roland's outside better build, it may be cheap on the inside. I wouldn't know.
But for sure, regardless of the K's small fonts (only on some screens) that machine will force Roland and Yamaha, even if you think it is junk, to continue to do something better, that is good.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

7 Sep 2011, 14:23
Devnor wrote:
Unfortunately Korg forum users, product management & their moderators have no tolerance for a differing opinion or a less-than-satisfied answer and it always degenerates into personal attacks between members. Right now they are slagging a Korg customer with real product issues in a 20 page thread.
Devnor,
I'll say it again, I'm resolutely against such general statements. Not all users have no tolerance and I can hardly remember that the product management (!!!) behaved in an intolerant way. Please, give us a link to verify your statement. You will find opposing statements on any other forum as well. I have expressed my opinion about some aspects of the JP80 here and got some very unfriendly attacks from some other members. And I never went over to the Korg forum, telling how all people are intolerant here.
I'm reading the Korg forum on a daily basis and I can't remember that either Jerry or Dan (from Korg) ever attacked somebody or told something about other companies in a negative way. Please, feel free to correct me and give us a link.

In the meantime, I'll just quote Dan Krishers (Roland US) post. So, decide for yourself if that is the way to talk about users with different opinions or about other companies:
Wow. I take a time-out to work on some new projects only to come back and see, well lots of I don't know what. (Is there a mod in the house?)
Key wear in the RD-700GX? Really. Display problems in GW-7, when we've been selling the GW-8 for how long? And our sales are very well thank you.
Yamaha is a great company, but it has its own issues as well. (Sorry trolls.) And Korg. (Love those $50 Chinese made synthesizers.)
I'm sure any further comment is needless.
But as a matter of fact, Korg employees post in the forum on a daily basis. They answer a lot of questions and in fact, they explained a lot about the Kronos long before it hit the stores. What about Roland? Have they answered one single question about why something on the jp80 works in this or that way? No, and they never will.
So, let's just stop making general statements about tolerance. One, two or even ten users don't make a crowd.
Neither here, no there.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

7 Sep 2011, 16:04
You are correct. In my frustration over my own situation with Kronos I lumped Korg product management into that group. My bad. They seem like a good group and have been 110% professional. Some of their decisions are puzzling to me but that seems to apply to every musical instrument manufacturer.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

7 Sep 2011, 18:23
mojkarma wrote:
I'm sure any further comment is needless.
But as a matter of fact, Korg employees post in the forum on a daily basis. They answer a lot of questions and in fact, they explained a lot about the Kronos long before it hit the stores. What about Roland? Have they answered one single question about why something on the jp80 works in this or that way? No, and they never will.
So, let's just stop making general statements about tolerance. One, two or even ten users don't make a crowd.
Neither here, no there.
Actually, you are incorrect. Roland has had workshops dedicated to the Jupiter 80. They have had gone out and talked about how this synth works. If you haven't seen it already, type "Jupiter 80 workshop" in youtube.

Roland also posted about 25 videos for the Jupiter 80. You can view those too.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

7 Sep 2011, 19:26
gfan80 wrote:
Actually, you are incorrect. Roland has had workshops dedicated to the Jupiter 80. They have had gone out and talked about how this synth works. If you haven't seen it already, type "Jupiter 80 workshop" in youtube.

Roland also posted about 25 videos for the Jupiter 80. You can view those too.
Please, read again what I wrote, since you quoted that part.
Korg answered to user questions about the Kronos even BEFORE the keyboard was released.
You may call those youtube clips a workshop. In reality, it's a little more detailed product demonstration. Maybe Jimmy even answered some questions, but you don't hear them in the clip. And you need to know german.
I'd prefer to have Roland stuff here, sharing some information, helping out with some concerns, problems and so on. Nothing wrong with posting youtube clips, but it doesn't make it up for a direct communication with customers in the same way as all others do.

Oh, there is also a very interesting part in this "workshop" clip:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hQouqti76s4&feature=relmfu

At 10:20 Jimmy explains how the JP80 wonderfully cuts thru the mix when you play live. And to prove it further he says:
You all know the problem that happens with a keyboard, and with the Fantom G too (!), you prepare at home your setup, all your sounds, then you come onto the stage, start playing and your bandmates look at you and ask, what is that supposed to be?

Maybe Jimmy doesn't know that the Fantom G is still an actual product. He basically says that - unlike the JP80 - the Fantom G doesn't cut thru the mix. Being myself a FG owner, it makes me really feel good to be in Rolands hands, when their presenters have such a good opinion about a product that is still being sold.
Dan Krisher calls us a troll and Jimmy Kresic tells us that the FG doesn't cut thru.
:)

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

7 Sep 2011, 19:37
mojkarma wrote:
gfan80 wrote:
Actually, you are incorrect. Roland has had workshops dedicated to the Jupiter 80. They have had gone out and talked about how this synth works. If you haven't seen it already, type "Jupiter 80 workshop" in youtube.

Roland also posted about 25 videos for the Jupiter 80. You can view those too.
Please, read again what I wrote, since you quoted that part.
Korg answered to user questions about the Kronos even BEFORE the keyboard was released.
You may call those youtube clips a workshop. In reality, it's a little more detailed product demonstration. Maybe Jimmy even answered some questions, but you don't hear them in the clip. And you need to know german.
I'd prefer to have Roland stuff here, sharing some information, helping out with some concerns, problems and so on. Nothing wrong with posting youtube clips, but it doesn't make it up for a direct communication with customers in the same way as all others do.

Oh, there is also a very interesting part in this "workshop" clip:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hQouqti76s4&feature=relmfu

At 10:20 Jimmy explains how the JP80 wonderfully cuts thru the mix when you play live. And to prove it further he says:
You all know the problem that happens with a keyboard, and with the Fantom G too (!), you prepare at home your setup, all your sounds, then you come onto the stage, start playing and your bandmates look at you and ask, what is that supposed to be?

Maybe Jimmy doesn't know that the Fantom G is still an actual product. He basically says that - unlike the JP80 - the Fantom G doesn't cut thru the mix. Being myself a FG owner, it makes me really feel good to be in Rolands hands, when their presenters have such a good opinion about a product that is still being sold.
Dan Krisher calls us a troll and Jimmy Kresic tells us that the FG doesn't cut thru.
:)
You said that Roland didn't answer a single question about their product and they have. They have held actual workshops with people there - and not just in Germany.

You obviously didn't listen to a single sentence I wrote in my response to you - so the point of even trying to respond to your nonsensical drivel doesn't warrant a further reply from me.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

8 Sep 2011, 00:48
This is good news for Roland, albeit, extremely bad for Korg's reputation as a professional keyboard company.


Korg is small compared with Roland. I believe Roland's Boss division alone outsells Korg. Korg seems to have an identity crisis. They make cheap, toy-like instruments as well as a pro keyboard like the Kronos. The OASYS understandably didn't sell in a large quantity. The SV-1 didn't sell. So, Korg had to lower the production cost of the Kronos and it clearly shows. To me, a $3k synth shouldn't feel like a $300 keyboard sold at Best Buy. A company simply cannot build its flagship product like that. It's very funny some Korg forum members fanatically defend the Kronos's build quality. Let's see how Korg does for the Kronos EX.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

8 Sep 2011, 02:05
Chrisk-K wrote:
This is good news for Roland, albeit, extremely bad for Korg's reputation as a professional keyboard company.
Korg is small compared with Roland. I believe Roland's Boss division alone outsells Korg. Korg seems to have an identity crisis. They make cheap, toy-like instruments as well as a pro keyboard like the Kronos. The OASYS understandably didn't sell in a large quantity. The SV-1 didn't sell. So, Korg had to lower the production cost of the Kronos and it clearly shows. To me, a $3k synth shouldn't feel like a $300 keyboard sold at Best Buy. A company simply cannot build its flagship product like that. It's very funny some Korg forum members fanatically defend the Kronos's build quality. Let's see how Korg does for the Kronos EX.
I have this one problem with Korg. Although I do own an X50, getting parts directly from Korg is next to impossible.

In effort to get the parts, you have to go either through one of their certified vendors or get it serviced by someone authorized by Korg. Also, the keys are apparently cheaply built. There are no weights on the bottom of the X50's keys. If one key needs to be replaced, you have to replace four or five of them as they are bundled together.

I think the X50 will be the last Korg product I'll own until they finally decide to support the customer with the ability to order parts.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

8 Sep 2011, 10:43
gfan80 wrote:
I have this one problem with Korg. Although I do own an X50, getting parts directly from Korg is next to impossible.
In effort to get the parts, you have to go either through one of their certified vendors or get it serviced by someone authorized by Korg.
Try this:
write an email directly to Yamaha, Roland, Kurzweil and report that you need a replacement for a broken key (Just pretend that you own a keyboard from them).
Then come back and give us a report.
In the meantime while waiting for an answer, read this:
http://www.rolandus.com/support/?tab=service_repair
Also, it helps reading manuals.
For the balance, let's see what the JP80 manual says on the 4th page:
Do not attempt to repair the unit, or replace parts within it (except when this manual provides specific instructions directing you to do so). Refer all servicing to your retailer, the nearest Roland Service Center, or an authorized Roland distributor, as listed on the “Information” page.
To catch your attention Roland even wrote a big WARNING above that text.
gfan80 wrote:
Also, the keys are apparently cheaply built. There are no weights on the bottom of the X50's keys. If one key needs to be replaced, you have to replace four or five of them as they are bundled together.
They haven't put weights on a $699 keyboard and it feels cheap? What a shame!
Try a Yamaha MM6 and compare. Or a Roland Juno-Di.
Let me quote from the Juno-Di review from Musicradar.com:
For a start, the keybed is too stiffly sprung for really sensitive playing. Then there are the dials, which have some sideward play, and the fairly cheap plastic used for the case/underside.

We don't want to be too harsh, however, as this is a budget instrument
gfan80 wrote:
I think the X50 will be the last Korg product I'll own until they finally decide to support the customer with the ability to order parts.
You are not allowed to repair anything on any product until the product manual explicitly states that you can do so. Try to order a motherboard for your computer or your tv or your car directly from the manufacturers head office. I'm wondering that there are people who don't understand how service business works.

Re: Sold Kronos for a Jupiter 80.. and glad I did!!

8 Sep 2011, 11:18
I went into Scott Tibbs workshop 2 months ago with very little intention of buying a Jupiter. YouTube videos weren't impressing me and I had a bad Fantom G experience. He answered every question I had after going through his great demo. I thought it was very useful and certainly provided me with information I could not get elsewhere. I ended up walking out with a Jupiter and have been very happy with the purchase.

I never sold my Kronos and Korg has been very helpful in resolving issues. That being said, I find myself enjoying the Jupiter far more than my Kronos.

← Back to JUPITER-80