Fantom-S and Fantom-X

SXR-2 Concert Piano OR SRX-11 Complete Piano Exp. Boards?

SXR-2 Concert Piano OR SRX-11 Complete Piano Exp. Boards?

9 Nov 2010, 15:33
Hello,
I'm considering buying either the SRX-2 Concert Piano or SRX-11 Complete Piano expansion boards for my Famtom X.

I know it's subjective and somewhat a matter of personal preference, but which of these 2 boards do other users consider to have the best samples?

How much better are the piano samples in these expansion boards compared to the factory accoustic piano samples in the Fantom X?

Thanks in advance for your advice!

Re: SXR-2 Concert Piano OR SRX-11 Complete Piano Exp. Boards

9 Nov 2010, 17:20
They both are not much better than the stock one which in the X really cuts throught the mix - especially the SRX-02 I would stay away from.

Re: SXR-2 Concert Piano OR SRX-11 Complete Piano Exp. Boards

9 Nov 2010, 19:58
I had the Concert Piano expansion board, and it was okay. I sold it and purchased the Complete Piano exp. and it was amazing. As midi said, there both better than the original piano sounds, but personally it all comes down to tweaking and having a pedal. When I first got the fantom I did not have a pedal and all piano sounds sounded "cheap" WHen I purchased a pedal and tampered with the patch, the piano quality rose significantly. Hope this helps
E.A.

Re: SXR-2 Concert Piano OR SRX-11 Complete Piano Exp. Boards

9 Nov 2010, 23:18
Thank you both for the input. I've found that the "ultimate grand" patch on my X8 have a couple of notes that give a slight "rattle twang" type of artifact sound. I mainly notice this on the C & C# one octave above middle C. I've checked it on different monitor speakers, so I'm pretty certain it's in the sample set in that octave. I now mainly use the "So True" patch which I tweaked with a little bit more reverb. The "so true" patch along with several others use a different set of samples that don't contain that unwanted "rattle" I mentioned.

I use a Roland sustain pedal and it works great. I'll probably give the "Complete Piano" SRX-11 a try. Sounds like they did a good job with the multi sampling on that one.
Thanks again !

Re: SXR-2 Concert Piano OR SRX-11 Complete Piano Exp. Boards

9 Nov 2010, 23:48
Oregonfantom, I hear some of the same artifact sounds that you said you hear on the Ultimate Grand patch on my X8 and X6 as well. I found it interesting that I heard similar problems on my SRX11 and on the RD pianos I have tried so I suspect that the same samples are used although tweaked differently.

Re: SXR-2 Concert Piano OR SRX-11 Complete Piano Exp. Boards

10 Nov 2010, 17:29
I've used ultimate grand + to great effect (thanks to whoever programmed that). Just bought a SRX 11 and I'm not that blown away to be honest.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X