Fantom-S and Fantom-X

UPS or Power Surge ?

UPS or Power Surge ?

12 Apr 2010, 06:54
I have a big problem... I am staying at my wife's parents now, and thy don;t have any power let with grounding.
It there a way to protect my hardware without having grounding?
some people say that an UPS should work , other say Power Surge , other say that non of them work without having grounding...
Do not ever be ashamed of what you are, what you feel, and what you think. The truth hurts, but it is necessary.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

12 Apr 2010, 15:06
Just had a discussion like this in the Breakin news thread lol..... all the same a UPS is better than nothing in your situation.....heres a more detailed reply on the subject from someone I have worked with,

"Having looked at the innards of a few UPSes, and the schematics for a few more, and done the "yank the plug out of the socket" test with many more, they all seem to work fine, as UPSes, without a ground. You might get a "site wiring fault" indication, but the inverter still kicks in and supplies backup power when it should.

The surge protection function becomes less useful in the absence of a ground, though. It should still stop rapid spikes (which are blocked by inductors in series with the line and neutral conductors, no ground connection there) and surges between line and neutral (a MOV is connected between L and N with no ground there either).

What would worry me is the MOVs between line and ground, and between neutral and ground, to protect against common mode surges and surges on the neutral. Not only do these NOT function without a ground connection, but I can't see what stops them from coupling dangerous voltages onto the ungrounded "ground" conductor in the event of that type of surge.

I would be concerned about touching any metal parts of protected equipment which could become momentarily electrified when connected to this type of surge protector when a surge occurs, and the ground isn't really grounded."

TL;DR...... Yes it will still help but will not be as effective and will likely shorten the life of your UPS (also introduces a possible shock hazard.)

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

12 Apr 2010, 23:49
And how is possible to make your own grounding (if the building doesn't have?
is there a way to make some car battery or something to take the grounding purpose?
Do not ever be ashamed of what you are, what you feel, and what you think. The truth hurts, but it is necessary.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

13 Apr 2010, 00:49
ummmmm in short no. Not sure where that idea came from but you are talking about two different types of current.... AC and DC .....and even tho the grounding concept is the same, you will risk blowing that battery sky high.
There are only two answers to your question and all of them require an electrician (unless you are a really good handy man and dont mind getting dirty).

1. (and probably the cheapest way) Have the one outlet you are going to use grounded to a cold water pipe or grounding rod.

2. Have the entire house rewired for ground...which means dropping new power lines all through the house in question and replacement of all outlets to modern plugs.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

13 Apr 2010, 02:38
Ground is just the common term, it's really a direct connection to Earth.

In your case, a two wire situation, the neutral/ground likely connects to an earth ground at the main.

Still, it's a dangerous situation for you and your equipment because there isn't a dedicated path for overloads, faults, or surges where the voltage can travel safely away(instead of through). Even if you have no problem, there could be static build-up which may make it into your signal path. It might even cause noise in the circuit since you'll likely be connected to the house appliances too.

I have to agree with lordelix, you should at least contact an electrician to make sure you do this safely. I have no idea what your country's electrical codes are; so it's quite difficult to offer a specific suggestion.

Good luck.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

13 Apr 2010, 03:29
In Romania we have 220-230V at 50Hz.
The building is very old, made in the 70's and it's not my house to do all I want (I am staying at my wife's parents), and to change a 4 rooms apartment is something not cheap at all.
So, I ask again, the UPS can take those power surge?
I ask an electronic engineer and he said that without grounding, the ups is worthless.
Many thanks for the answears...
Do not ever be ashamed of what you are, what you feel, and what you think. The truth hurts, but it is necessary.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

13 Apr 2010, 04:49
Basically, there is no guarantee without a seperate earth ground.

Since there would be no path of least resistance(an easy way to look at the 3rd wire), the whole circuit could be lit up with the extra current on it's way to the main. Do you think a UPS could withstand a lightning strike? Would the mechanical parts fry to the point of disconnect before shorting your equipment?

It's just dangerous and unpredictable. You can cross your fingers, but you don't know when the cat is going to chew through a wire or the neighbor decides to drill a hole in the wall. These are serious voltages we are talking about.

I'd say the engineer is correct; UPS will only waste your money.

I hear ya on the expense part, but maybe there are alternatives. Studios often have their racks/equipment on a dedicated ground. Maybe you can wire just one room and drop a ground to the sewer, but again, this is something to consider with someone who knows local building code. Of course, if they are renting there may be nothing you can do at all.

The only other option is to use a ground lift on the plug and take the risk. It is a risk, but hey, you won't have to worry about ground loops. :\

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

13 Apr 2010, 05:37
I have some troubles now with my fantom-xr module, and I am thinking that maybe this ground issue was the cause...
I am trying to avoid future problems...
Do not ever be ashamed of what you are, what you feel, and what you think. The truth hurts, but it is necessary.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

13 Apr 2010, 15:53
This is nearing my limited understanding of electricity, but could you explain the problem you are already having with the XR? There is possiblity of static build up in your system. Having a ground lifted should eliminate noise from a ground loop tho.

The earth ground is more about protecting your equipments and safety, in the event of a fault.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

13 Apr 2010, 23:07
ahh Romania.....beautiful country. My band was there in 2008 for the Rockin Transylvania festival. I didn't really like Bucharest too much but once we got away from the city it was absolutely breath taking.
Well as I said before its not a total waste as you will be afforded some protection from it. It will not protect your equipment completely as it should since there is no ground....and any warranty or guarantee the backup/surge suppressor manufacturer has made will be voided. Some protection is better than none. In the end the only real way to solve this issue is for you to ground the outlet you intend to use for your equipment or rewire the house for ground. Its the only way to be sure.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

14 Apr 2010, 00:11
well..
my fantom-xr is having some strange issues.After installing the 64bit driver, for Windows XP, I have restarted the PC and the fantom-xr menu was showing in mirror.
I quit using Windows 7, but now even if there are nothing connected to the fantom., after loading the OS, after 20-30 minutes, it's menu screen freeze on page (buttons still works, if I touch them they lights up and save, or doing the purpose of, but after other 10-20 minutes, the fantom-xr freeze completly...
So at this moment, I really don;t know if it is the 64driver that mess up the OS (I did make a OS reinstalll, a factory reset, use it without card, ram, just as it comes from factory), or, is something hardware.
So I am asking my self if is not something because of the not having grounded.
Do not ever be ashamed of what you are, what you feel, and what you think. The truth hurts, but it is necessary.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

14 Apr 2010, 01:15
and all that started only after you were in new apartment?

I'm really not sure how the lack of ground would mess up your XR like that, but pretty certain it had nothing to do with the 64-bit driver as that is on the computer side of things.

There is a remote possibility the electrical power has something to do with it. Computers, I would suppose some digital hardware too, do prefer to have clean square waves(electrical). Is there a way to test it in another location?

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

14 Apr 2010, 02:29
Yes, I did test it on 4 different locations, but the freezing keeps happend
Do not ever be ashamed of what you are, what you feel, and what you think. The truth hurts, but it is necessary.

Re: UPS or Power Surge ?

15 Apr 2010, 12:41
Unfortunate, but that sounds more like the XR has a problem. Maybe a repost on the symptoms to see what other people think, or see if you can get it serviced.

Maybe electric damage is already done or maybe it got bumped in moving.

Good luck.

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X