Fantom-S and Fantom-X

FX with SRX-06 Complete Orchestra or Symphony of Voices?

Re: FX with SRX-06 Complete Orchestra or Symphony of Voices?

23 Apr 2004, 01:58
Ron,

That's why I plan on getting an large (512MB or 1GB) ULTRA Compact Flash card for my FX together with SoV, something like this:

http://www.mydigitaldiscount.com/s.nl/c.ACCT139057/category.89/it.A/id.62/.f
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/B0000CD05D/104-9934368-7569533?v=glance
https://www.buymemory.com/memory/ModelModuleDetail.asp?Package=DigitalFilm

If the FX fully supports this transfer rate of 6.8MB/sec it should make SoV very practical on the FX, right?

Has anyone tested the speed of _ultra_ CF like this with his FX? If so please state the specs of the CF card (..x speed) and your findings.

This is one of the reasons why I waited for the FX, faster transfer speeds compared to the SmartMedia cards supported by the FS.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Response from Spectrasonics regarding SoV on FX

27 Apr 2004, 02:42
For those who might be interested in using Symphony of Voices or were hoping for a new vocal SRX card, here is the response I received from Spectrasonics regarding this:

>> 1. Are there any plans to develop a pure vocal SRX card
>> with Roland similar to what SoV has to offer (ie vibratoless
>> Ooohs and Aaahs etc) or at least one that has more samples
>> from SoV than what's on SRX-06 Complete Orchestra

> NO


>> 2. Do you know anything about the still to be released Sample
>> Library converter for the new Roland Fantom-X6 in terms of
>> how well this will work with your SoV library? The converter
>> is supposed to be developed by ChickenSys. Are you in any
>> way involved?



> No. The architecture of the Fantom-X is very different than older Roland
> samplers. We haven't tried it, and USB transfer of SOV could be quite slow
> and impractical.



>> 3. I've been told by someone who has both SoV and the SRX-06
>> card that the SoV samples on the SRX-06 card are more
>> controllable than the raw SoV library (he's probably using
>> it on an XV-5080) [Edit: I was wrong about] Is this correct?

> No...that's absolutely incorrect. The sample library version is far more
> flexible, expressive, playable and controllable.
> The expansion baord version is microscopic by comparison.

[Duh. That's not what I meant]

>> 4. Are there any SoV features that will not work on the
>> Fantom-X, such as Moving Vowels?

> Probably, but we don't know.
> You'd be far better off getting SOV and using it on a software sampler like
> Giga, EXS24, HALion, etc.


>> Thank you in advance for taking the time to answer my questions. I'm
>> having a difficult time deciding between the SRX-06 and SoV. I'm
>> leaning towards SoV because of the overlap between stock Fantom-X
>> sounds and SRX-06 but ofcourse it has to work first and with a good
>> level of control. The SRX-6 card on the other hands offers instant
>> loading of sounds and what I've heard, as limited in scope as it
>> may be, is of excellent quality, just like SoV and I actually need
>> these sounds very quickly.

> I wouldn't recommend getting SOV for the Fantom-X until it has been tested,
> but SRX-06 is really no substitute for SOV either....it's really not even in
> the same league (mono samples, short loops, only a few megabytes of samples,
> no dynamic samples, etc)
>
> Best thing is to get an inexpensive software or compatible hardware sampler
> (used Akai samplers, and Roland S-760s are also very cheap these days) and
> then get the full library....you won't be sorry that you choose the higher
> quality option.


> Hope that helps!

>> Thank you for replying to my questions. I hope you will be testing SoV
>> soon on the Fantom-X because:
>>
>> - The architecture of the Fantom-X is actually virtually identical
>> to that of the XV-5080 which was afaik also compatible with Akai
>> samplers and Roland S700 (through conversion software)
>> - Transfer through USB may not be that quick (I just tested: 35 seconds
>> for a 6MB file), however the Fantom-X has a PC card slot that can
>> also hold Compact Flash cards which have very reasonable transfer
>> speeds. I don't know yet it also support the higher transfer speeds
>> of current 'Ultra Compact Flash II' but if it does it would have a
>> transfer speed of >6MByte per second, as fast as many hard drives.

> You'll need to contact Roland regarding further testing of SOV. We don't
> have a Fantom-X accessible to our staff, nor do we plan to purchase a
> Fantom-X.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: FX with SRX-06 Complete Orchestra or Symphony of Voices?

27 Apr 2004, 03:52
Boy those guys really seem to have a fondness for our beloved Fantom-X :-)

ChickenSys does like our Fantom :)

28 Apr 2004, 09:28
Here's the response I got from ChickenSys.

>> According to Roland a sample library converter
>> will be made available in the near future to
>> all Roland Fantom-S/X users to convert existing
>> sample libraries to Fantom-X format. Supposedly
>> this will convert from Roland and Akai formats
>> and supposedly it is being developed by you
>> (ChickenSys). Is any of this correct and if
>> so when can we expect this and exactly what
>> can we expect from it?

> Question 1: That's entirely up to Roland - I hope
> soon. Some of it is up to me, getting it completely
> done, but the release is up to them.

> Also can you tell me if SoV will translate correctly
> (and to what extent in terms of functionality) to
> the Fantom-X?

> Question 2: Is the Roland format what you have?
> OK, then, I'll put it in testing rotation tomorrow
> and give you the exact answer.

>> I contacted Spectrasonics and they were not
>> able to tell me anything. In fact they suggested
>> I get an old Roland or AKAI sampler or a software
>> sampler to use their library. I just got my brand
>> spanking new FX and I have enough gear to haul
>> around already so adding a hardware of software
>> sampler is not an attractive option. I want to use
>> SoV in a live setting, not just in the studio. I
>> would think the Fantom-X with it's up to 1GB PC
>> card interface and 512MB of sample memory and
>> virtual identical architecture to the XV-5080
>> should be a viable and practical platform for SoV,
>> right?


> Question 3: Your observations are correct. The
> Fantom is hot, extremely powerful workstation and
> easy to use. I love mine. One correction: The
> Fantom does not have the identical structure as
> the XV, it's a derivative. The XV is identical to
> the S-7x series. The Fantom is better in some ways
> (memory, stereo samples, a couple other keen things),
> but worse in a couple others (more restrictive
> structure - it is possible to have a S-7x or XV Patch
> not be able to fit in a Fantom Patch).

> The Fantom has sampling much tied into the structure,
> whereas the XV it was not really integrated at all.
> And of course the SmartMedia/CompactFlash thing is
> great for handiness.

> I'll post back on a SoV report for you.

I'll keep you guys and gals posted.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: FX with SRX-06 Complete Orchestra or Symphony of Voices?

28 Apr 2004, 18:51
This seems kind of silly to me. If you're going to spend the money on SOV, buying something like Kontakt, which is a much better sampler than any hardware device, makes a lot more sense. If you want to go the hardware route, buy an E-mu Ultra sampler with an internal hard drive and the Akai/Emu version of SOV. It seems pretty obvious that the Fantom was not designed for the purpose of reading sample libraries. It uses a sampling architecture that's quite a bit different than any other product. The XV-5080 architecture is basically the same as the S-760 and as such not at all compatible with the Fantom X.

Re: FX with SRX-06 Complete Orchestra or Symphony of Voices?

29 Apr 2004, 08:13
> This seems kind of silly to me.

I appreciate your input, but personally I think it's kind of silly to buy another box just to run one sample library that I happen to like while possibly my Fantom-X could do the exact same thing. One more box also means:

- One more device to haul around
- One more power cable. Maybe even a wall-wart.
- One more MIDI cable
- Two more audio cables
- Extra mixer input

Or: Five more elements that can fail.

> It seems pretty obvious that the Fantom was not
> designed for the purpose of reading sample libraries.

If that is the case then why has Roland from the moment they anounced the Fantom-X advertised it as being able to use Akai/Roland sample libraries? And a software solution such as Roland has promised is fine with me, I only need to do the conversion once. If this work I don't need a better sampler.

I realize that some sample libraries that use specific features available on one sampler may not translate equally well to other sampler architectures. But hey, the sole reason of existence for the ChickenSys Translator software is to provide conversion between different sample formats and they go to great lengths to preserve as much of the usabilty of the library as possible on the destination platform.

According to ChickenSys the SoV library is only lightly programmed so I would expect it to work very well on a Fantom-X and besides they are testing it right now. Sure, if they test it and find that it does not translate and they cannot somehow improve the translation I may have to either forget about SoV or bite the bullet and get more gear but I will only do that if it's neccessary.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: FX with SRX-06 Complete Orchestra or Symphony of Voices?

29 Apr 2004, 11:30
I am confident that the SOV library "can" successfully be converted in a useful manner into Fantom-X format. In fact, if you have the time and patience to do it, you can do it yourself right now. Of course, that is not as practical, but it illustrates the point.

There is nothing so complex about SOV. Most of the multisamples are not all that complex as far as layers and overwhelming splits or performance articulations. Sure, some are more complex, but the lions share of it you could utilize by dragging the individual samples over, and creating the splits to make your own multi sample. This is not to knock down the original SOV library at all. It is awesome in it's scope. But the scope I refer to is the size, diversity, and depth of the library...not the complexity of the individual patch structure.

When a company like Spectrasonics or Chycken Systems talks about converting a library such as SOV, they have to consider every performance element that made up the original programming. They cannot represent that they are successfully offering a converted format of a Professional Library, without providing a virtual clone of the original. There may be some elements or performance articulations that do not transfer into the slightly odd Fantom format correctly....but the lions share of the conversion in this case, with this library, is merely duplicating the splits and layers. These are mostly "static pad" patches...not frought with performance controls such as real time crossfades or key switching. Those type of articulations are much more difficult to program, and to convert. But if your interest is in hearing and sequencing the fundamental patches in the SOV library...which by their nature are mostly static pads...then you can certainly achieve this on the Fantom series.

However, if you want every single nuance of the original programming, then you would be better off using a software sampler that is supported.

I have this same basic problem with the Voices of the Apocalypse library. It is a Gigasampler library, and not directly compatible with EXS24 (my main sampler) or other samplers. Unlike SOV, VOTA has extreme "real time performance" based programming...because it is intended to be used in Gigasampler to build and "sing" actual words. So the keyswitiching, real time crossfading, and amount of layers is very high volume and complex. You cannot get these functions in other samplers without major tweaking, if at all. BUT, if you simply want to use the "sounds" of the VOTA library, as pads and vocal samples, you can easily duplicate the multisamples (that is....position the samples in the appropriate key ranges) and have the VOTA sound as a static pad. I have done this in EXS24 and use it all the time (I also have Gigasampler for when I want to use the word building functions, but it's PC only, and I like working on my Mac most of the time).

So bottom line is...If you want to use the SOV library sounds for your original compositions, then get it. You will be able to create your own useful multisamples in the Fantom X without much trouble from the huge and diverse library of vocal samples that you will be getting. You should have much fun, and create tons of new useful Fantom patches...even by just importing one of the thousands of samples in the library. Then you can incorporate it into the power of the FX sample/synth engine, and create great patches to use. It sounds like fun to me, and I have done some of this already. You need to think of the Fantom X as a sampling synthesiser...not just a sample player. Pull in great original sample material, and use it as building blocks for your own patches. If you want to make and use awesome vocal choir patches on the Fantom X, you could ask for no better collection of choir material to work with than SOV. It is the raw waveform material that you will build on.

However, if you want the ease of just loading up the default programming from Spectrasonics, then either wait until the Roland conversion software is out (and even then, it sounds as if there may be some deficiencies over the straight Akai format), or get Kontact, or Mach 5 or something like that.

By the way...my earlier indication that the SOV samples on the SRX06 were more "controllable" than the original library is true. This is merely because of the integration into the patch architecture of the Fantom, and the real time control of things like LFO's, step effects, envelopes, and performance controllers such as the Dbeam, arppeggio, etc. Not to also forget the immediacy of loading patches directly on board the Fantom. This is not to say that the SRX/SOV patches are as comprehensive or sonically brilliant as the original library. Clearly the original is "better" in all respects. But the "playability" of the SRX patches is a notch up.

Thanks,

Ron

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X