Fantom-S and Fantom-X

USB connection causes noise in audio

USB connection causes noise in audio

22 Mar 2010, 00:25
I recently got a Fantom X8, and I noticed something tonight while monitoring under headphones that seems strange to me. When the Fantom is connected to my Mac (G5 PPC) via USB, the Fantom's audio outputs are quite noisy. The second I disconnect the USB cable, the noise disappears. Upon a little further investigation, I found that this could be some strange grounding problem with the USB bus or something, because just touching the metal shell of the USB connector to the USB plug on the keyboard causes the noise (before I even plug it in).

Anyone else seen this happen before? I've tried several USB cables, and they all seem to do the same thing.

Thanks,
Russ

Re: USB connection causes noise in audio

23 Mar 2010, 18:59
That, my friend, is the result of a ground loop. Ideally, all ground is at 0 Volts, but many things make a set-up deviate from ideal. Your headphones work off of the difference in voltage between the signal wire and ground. If ground is exactly 0 Volts, all is fine. Even if the ground of the Fantom is moving around, that is still fine because the Fantom generates its signal with respect to its own ground. When you connect up the USB cable, you create a path between your computer ground and the Fantom ground. But there is already a ground connection between your computer and the Fantom. That path is out the power cord of the computer, through your studio electrical wiring and on through the power cord of the Fantom. Combine this with the new path created by the USB cable and you now have the loop, the "ground loop."

Loops are only bad if they have too much resistance in them. That causes current in the loop to change the voltage at different places in the loop, a bad thing. So one thing you can try is to shorten the loop by plugging both computer and Fantom into the same power strip. Some times that is all it takes to quiet everything down. If the noise is still there, you can break the loop by using a three to two prong adapter on one of the power cords to isolate the safety ground. This is not preferred, of course, because now there is no safety ground should the isolation break down between the hot wire and the case of your equipment.

Just happens that I replaced my PowerBook with a new iMac this past weekend and when everything was hooked up, yes just the kind of noise you describe. I've gotten a big improvement by isolating the power cords on my powered monitors, but still have not gotten rid of all the noise. Just a note, unless you have more gear connected together than indicated in your post, getting the Fantom and computer powered off the same power strip should solve your problem.

Let us know what you find.
-Rodan

Re: USB connection causes noise in audio

23 Mar 2010, 21:45
Rodan,

Thanks for your awesome description. The Mac and the Fantom are not on the same power strip. There is a lot of gear in this studio, so it won't be possible to get everything together on the same power strip, or likely even the same electrical circuit. However, I can definitely try to get the Fantom and the Mac on the same power strip because they're relatively close together.

I will give that a shot right away, and let you know if it helps! I greatly appreciate your suggestion, it makes a lot of sense. I knew it had to be some sort of grounding problem, but I was unsure how to proceed.

Thanks a bunch!
Russ

Re: USB connection causes noise in audio

24 Mar 2010, 20:19
He is right, though.
Try connecting the Fantom with MIDI only and see if the same problem occurs. If it does not, then you clearly have a grounding problem in your studio.

MIDI is ground-lifted (not sure if this is the correct term as my mother tongue is not english). USB is not.

EDIT: I just realized the stupidness of my comment: The damned thing will ground itself through midi too, of course, if the wiring is truly bad and the fuse is not quick enough. That's where the Fault current protection kicks in. :)
____________________________________
There is no such thing as a stupid question.

Re: USB connection causes noise in audio

28 Mar 2010, 15:24
Well, I figured out how to get around the noise problem. Plugging the Fantom into the same power strip (it's actually a big UPS) as the Mac actually made the noise worse. It turns out that the noise may have actually been partially caused by the crappy USB hub that I was using. I should have known. I changed the USB cable routing to go to a much better self-powered USB Hub, and the noise completely disappeared. Yay.

Fantom is quiet... I'm happy now. I'm sure I still have grounding issues in this basement, but for the most part things sound ok. I just have to be somewhat careful, apparently.

Thanks!
Russ

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X