Fantom-G

is G successor coming out any time soon?

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

20 Sep 2009, 16:42
The Fantom G has at least two more years before we see its successor in my opinion. Since you already have a fine keyboard instrument in the Motif XS you may want to indeed hold on to it and wait for the Fantom G replacement to come out in two to three years. Especially if are mainly thinking of upgrading to the Fantom G only because of its larger and higher resolution LCD screen. ;) Having owned a Motif XS myself I can tell you firsthand that the Fantom G (which I own - G7) also has a much easier OS navigation and improved work flow operation on it than the XS does. Sounds are subjective of course, but they are pretty much evenly matched I'd say with the XS having a much richer and comprehensive Arpeggio feature function than the FG has. If you use Arpeggio's a lot it would be hard to beat the XS for that purpose in my opinion. The Fantom G Arpeggio function(s), OTOH, are archaic in comparison in my humble opinion. But if Roland really wanted too they could "vastly" improve the current FG Arpeggio function by way of an OS update. They need to get their Software Engineers involved in "producing" some "new" Arpeggio functioning technologies to compete with the likes of Yammie and Korg. If they don't, Yammie and Korg will continue to "smoke" Roland in that area in my opinion. Pump some R&D into it and hire the right people and Roland could theoretically have something on the table by the launch of OS 2.0, 3.0, etc. But is that something of a high priority in their minds? If it was, we most likely would have already seen similar technology that Yammie and Korg have on their workstations on current and even past Roland workstations like the Fantom X. Since we don't, apparently it is not a high priority with Roland, needless to say. But as the saying goes: "you snooze, you lose", which certainly applies in this case and portends to Roland's lackadaisical attitude in this area in my humble opinion. >> If indeed Roland is busily working on improving their own Arpeggio technology (with hopefully a breakthrough soon to be forthcoming) then I sincerely apologize for dissing them. If, OTOH, they are shooting marbles with each other in the work area playground at Roland Japan then obviously they couldn't care less about improving upon the archaic Arpeggio functionality on their keyboards and have already raised the white flag apparently. Their loss, Yammie and Korg's gain though, sad to say...

One of the areas that the Fantom G rules over the Motif XS is expandability. The Motif XS can NOT be further expanded by way of their previous PLG card technology. The Fantom G has ARX card support that are basically DSP synths in themselves, having their own DSP processor(s) and own on-board polyphony, etc. But in my humble opinion, Roland is wasting a grand opportunity to turn ARX into something more than what they currently have developed it into. A measly "50" sample patches for roughly $500.00 for the ARX-03 Brass card, for example, is not my idea of a 'reasonable' "price vs. performance" quotient or ratio. Given the former "SRX"-10 Brass card had, at least, somewhat of a more respectable "100" patches, but at under 1/2 the cost of an ARX card = is it any wonder?? why many, many, many, of your current Fantom G owners don't take too kindly to forking over their hard earned "cash" for these current ARX cards, if at all? As the old adage goes: "WHERE'S THE BEEF"??? certainly applies when it comes to Roland's sporadic attempt to get ARX off the ground and into the hearts and minds of Roland customers in my opinion. If indeed the "status quo" prevails at Roland headquarters in Hamamatsu Japan regarding ARX marketing and implementation, then I really doubt whether ARX will be carried over much further on any future Roland keyboards. I hope I'm wrong about that though, and that Roland Japan will finally get a "vision" (more like a "revelation") on what is both acceptable to Roland's bottom line and in the "best" interest of their customers regarding ARX. As an example, on the next ARX card please give Users at least 200 sample patches to play around with and reduce the price of ARX cards by around $100. Oh yeah, and make the samples you put into them actually worth the price you have to pay for them too. :) Example: ARX-01 Drums, and ARX-02 EP didn't sound much different (or better) than what is currently already in the Fantom G preset wav rom if you ask me. ARX-03 Brass has some very nice Brass section and other Brass sounds on it, granted, but when you only gave it "50" sample patches and people had to fork over roughly 5 C notes to get it, can you understand why people would be a little hesitant to do so, especially in these dire global economic times?? For example, I myself would have definitely gotten an ARX-03 Brass card if you would have given it at least "100" sample patches to go along with it?? ;) But only "fifty" patches for basically $500 bucks is simply stretching it too thin in my opinion! Again, "WHERE'S THE BEEF" in this scenario?? The SUBSTANCE!! The VALUE!! The PRICE/PERFORMANCE RATIO!! Hmmmm??? :)

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

20 Sep 2009, 18:57
@keysme - I also find the price points for expansion prohibitively expensive. For $500 I could rather buy omnisphere and a virtual cacophony of creative possibilities. To which point, I have to think such competition will eventually wear on Roland's bottom line. Then of course, you need upgraded CPU for that. I guess that's the price you pay for sound nowadays. :\

I can't comment much on arpeggios, I dream of Motif in this regard and use combination of sequencing and minimum arps in Juno for now.

Still, I look forward to the Jupiter workstation :D

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

21 Sep 2009, 01:31
I completely agree with "keysme" about ARX...

dbijoux - I also look forward to the Jupiter 8 & ORGAN modeling ARX.

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

21 Sep 2009, 04:09
I have no problem with the ARX, as long as Roland keeps refurbishing them and selling them as such to major music chains. I just bought both the ARX-02 for $209.

I understand the frustration over the original pricing, as these boards probably only cost Roland $150 max, each, to make... if not less. I understand that the research going in to the boards may be in addition to manufacturing costs, but $450 for each expansion board on top of the $2000-$3500 that people already paid for the keyboard is sort of a misstep in getting the word out on how great they really are.

In a way, they are sort of guiding users to believe that they saved the best sounds for the expansion boards themselves and not the original keyboard. Not to say that the sounds arent great, because a lot of them are. I guess it would be one thing to have a ARX board with a multitude of different sounds(not just one instrument), in order to justify the price tag. Truthfully though, to buy two expansion boards at full price is either the whole way or half way to buying another keyboard that may have the better sounding instruments that you are looking for.

So the question comes for Roland... Is it worth alienating the userbase you already have in order to generate more profit? Or is it more profitable to comfort the same users with cheaper expansions to generate more sales in the future?

I love this keyboard and am having a great time writing songs exclusively with it, though I do understand the frustration when it comes to expansion as I would never pay full price for them. The $200 price range is just right for me, as it gives me the freedom to generate the sounds I want to hear without breaking the bank.

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

21 Sep 2009, 06:37
The ARX is a good concept.. (namely turbo charging your fantom with an extra synth is not a bad strategy), ...it just should not at the expense of a different requirement, namely patch expansion.

Unless Roland are losing money on SRX sales, i think it was a shot in the financial foot not to include 2 SRX slots on the Fantom mainboard.... not to mention a loss of faith from some % of the customer base.

I would sincerely hope that Roland considers something like an "ARX-S" which does nothing more than be a piggyback board to allow users to slot in an SRX module into an ARX slot..

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

21 Sep 2009, 07:00
$200 for ARX is a good deal. I have to 'guess' this SuperNATURAL technology still has some potential, albeit still shaded in 'organic' mystery for now.

One thing I'll add about SRX is that, if you happen to have a stock of SRX cards, you likely still have your X or SonicCell to run them too. I really doubt they are loosing money on expansions, those are like gold at the end of the rainbow. Plus, keep in mind the G has updated components, not to mention an engine designed to support ARX - much different than adding a extra block of waveforms.

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

21 Sep 2009, 07:05
"is G successor coming out any time soon? "

Who cares!?

The G has only just reached its 1st potential in the last update..
either way.. it does not matter.
There will never be a successor the G because roland don't make keyboards to replace previous models.
Stop wasting your time waiting around for something else and concentrate on making music..

Remember

ITS YOU THAT MAKES THE MUSIC NOT THE TECHNOLOGY



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

21 Sep 2009, 10:56
i think that if they gonna have to come with something it has to be more that it is all ready ;
check out the miko and neko from open labs those workstations r beyond all this but they are expensive ,but is the chit when u can trow any software in ur keyboard now thats dope!
but for now i stick with the fantom its a great machine...

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

21 Sep 2009, 11:20
alien
check out the miko and neko from open labs those workstations r beyond all this but they are expensive ,but is the chit when u can trow any software in ur keyboard now thats dope!


There is no need in investing to something like this. Maybe it's a full-fledged computer but it carries all the disadvantages of a windows-based computer, plus it's way too expensive. I prefer to build my own desktop PC or Mac computer and choose everything I want to put in there.
Personally I've built my studio around a PC laptop, Firewire audio interface card and my Fantom-G. It's a compact studio that gives me everything I need at the time.

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

21 Sep 2009, 20:28
Thanks everyone for your helpful replies, except for Quinnx, who wrote:
"Who cares!?

The G has only just reached its 1st potential in the last update..
either way.. it does not matter.
There will never be a successor the G because roland don't make keyboards to replace previous models.
Stop wasting your time waiting around for something else and concentrate on making music..

Remember
ITS YOU THAT MAKES THE MUSIC NOT THE TECHNOLOGY"


Your point about music is well-taken, but wow...did you get out of bed on the wrong side or something?

I just was asking because I didn't want to buy the G if some new Roland synth, which might have newer technology and perhaps more enhanced specs than the G, is being released in, say, a week. Wouldn't make much sense, would it?

Chill out, man....
Jourmalist: "So, John, how do you find America?"
Lennon: "Turn left at Greenland."

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

21 Sep 2009, 21:39
The X was a direct enhancement of Fantom-S ...

I suspect G successor could be a similar situation ... Roland will change it just enough to make it the workstation it should have been (more insert effects, bigger and better sound ROM, and a few surprises maybe ... ) Similar to how S to X progressed ...

I wouldn't be shocked if it was announced at Winter NAMM ...

A "new" product creates excitement ...
Some tunes and whatnot ...

http://www.soundclick.com/bands/page_music.cfm?bandID=405125



some tunes and whatnot ...
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/pagemusic.cfm?bandID=405125

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

22 Sep 2009, 05:10
Roland have major competitors and they are not just going to sit around while the likes of Yamaha release a new board with a much improved user interface. I bet the next model is in the works as we speak.

It's all about staying ahead of the game. The new Fantom (or whatever it will become) will be launched to compete with and hopefully outdo the other boards. Not whether or not the G is fully developed.

I predict a new Fantom will include:

4+ ARX slots
Double the G ROM
256 poly
1 stereo + 4 outputs (Total 6)
MP3 player
ipod dock
500 gig hard drive (expandable)

Predicted timeline...2011/12.
X7 All the way!!!

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

22 Sep 2009, 05:40
Buy it NOW. It's still relatively new in its product life cycle. Also, expensive synths seem to hold their resale value fairly well. A while back, I bought a used Korg Radias for only $200 less than what it sold for new. When the Fantom-G came out, I traded in my Fantom-X8 for a new G8 to my dealer, and he credited me for an amount totaling only $800 less than what I paid for the X8, when new. It was as if I rented a Fantom-X for about $100 a month until the new G came out eight months later.

IMO, the Fantom-X was severely crippled due to its ultra-clunky sample file management. The G is a huge improvement. Bigger screen, more audio tracks, etc. Although the Motif is no slouch, IMO, the Fantom-G is THE best "workstation" currently on the market. I think it would be unfortunate to deny yourself that kind of capability just to wait for the next generation.

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

22 Sep 2009, 05:45
"did you get out of bed on the wrong side or something? "

Nope!

its just been a trend i have seen over the years, that you no sooner have a new piece of gear and everyone is already clammering and willing to give it up for the next before they have fully explored the current one to the fullest potential..

This why we dont get quality new improved development from one to the other and why once its release v1.0 beta, everyone is waiting upto 3 years to get to where it should have been from day one and by that time yet another v1.0 bet device is released..

People get so caught up in wanting the latest and greatest and throw away there money and forget that they themselves make the music not the technology.
and as sure and sun rises in the east...
when the next whatever comes along, it starts all over again..
I begin to wonder,, do people realy understand the art of making music or are they just looking for the ultimate casio autoplay instant music maker?



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: is G successor coming out any time soon?

22 Sep 2009, 05:52
Quinnx, I can put my signature under (almost) every word you said.

← Back to Fantom-G