Fantom-S and Fantom-X

Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

2 Mar 2009, 19:46
I've been getting steadily less happy with the sound of the Fantom-X at our gigs over the last few months. Admittedly, my main sounds are Hammonds, so you could argue that I bought the wrong board.

Anyway, tonight our guitarist came over with a laptop and Logic to record some demos. Layering sounds on the tracks the Fantom-X sounded great: really clear and rich, and the sounds blended together really well, without getting muddy, prior to any mixing.

It's making me suspect that the Patches in isolated live use are too thin, but in a studio setting that special Roland warmth really comes through.

Has anyone else had this sort of experience, or does it just suggest i'm using poor Patches and Performances? :-)

Cheers
Andy
Andy

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

3 Mar 2009, 01:06
I initially was disappointed with the fantom live.

It definitely doesn't sound very good mono unless you tweak the patches for mono use (which is what I have done).

Your other option is to take 2 cables out of the A jacks and pan them left and right on the mixer to achieve live stereo.

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

3 Mar 2009, 05:08
I have always been very happy with the way my Fantom X sounds both live and in the studio. A lot depends on the speakers that you play it through though. For live use and in the rehearsal room I play it through a small stereo PA with real subs (2x900W subs + 2x300+100W tops) which sounds really, really good (warm but clean and goes plenty loud). In the studio I use the original Mackie HR824 studio monitors or sometimes quality headphones.

Hammond-wise the Fantom does leave a lot to be desired (although the Ultimate Keys SRX card improves the situation somewhat) so that's why I got a Korg CX-3 (modern digital version) to compensate for that (although I got that before I got the SRX card which I mainly got for the vintage synths). Wouldn't want to miss my CX-3 though, I just love the sound of that leslie spinning up and the growl of the simulated overdrive.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXz0UkVBZPQ
TOYZ in 60 seconds (short live video of my progrock band on YouTube)

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

3 Mar 2009, 06:26
Thanks for your responses.

Thinking about it, I suspect it's just the Hammond waves that are too thin. When we do tracks that use other sounds they always sound good.

I think stylistically I'm more of an organ player than the Fantom-X is designed to allow me to be (both control-wise and by virtue of its playing static samples or patches), and that's why I'm constantly butting heads with it over those type of sounds.

The SRX-07 board does have some great Hammond Patches which work really well for sequencing (and to a lesser extent layering), but I'm after that realtime organ control which I now accept the Fantom-X simply cannot give, again sound-wise or control-wise.

So, I've Nordered an Ord for it's Hammond sound and realtime control, so for future gigs the Fantom may well find itself taking a back seat (for Firegarden at least, as it's a big part of that sound).

It will still keep it's place at the heart of my studio set up, as with the four SRX boards installed it's a very capable machine and coupled with the Nord and an SH-32 I think I'll have a powerhouse of a set-up for my needs.

Can anyone recommend a good guitar or keyboard amp with a sub-woofer built in?

Cheers
Andy
Andy

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

3 Mar 2009, 06:33
I had a mate who played Jazz and had the same opinion of his Roland digital piano: "sounds great recorded in the studio, but rubbish live."

Took him a long time to realise the problem was actually the speakers. His corrected evaluation was: "sounds great through studio monitors, but rubbish through a cheap and nasty keyboard amp or PA system."
Nik
--------------------------------
MV-8800
Axon guitar-to-MIDI

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

3 Mar 2009, 07:07
Yeah, Nik,

I think that's about the measure of it :o)

Andy
Andy

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

3 Mar 2009, 09:44
So, I've Nordered an Ord...


LOL!!!

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

4 Mar 2009, 07:33
The same like what Andy asked if anyone could recommend any good guitar or keyboard amp with a sub-woofer built in, I am interested to hear as well. I have Roland KC-350 amp but I am never happy with my Fantom X sound when doing live gig.

Martin

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

4 Mar 2009, 07:34
The same like what Andy asked if anyone could recommend any good guitar or keyboard amp with a sub-woofer built in, I am interested to hear as well. I have Roland KC-350 amp but I am never happy with my Fantom X sound when doing live gig.

Martin

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

4 Mar 2009, 07:50
The Roland KCs are about as good as 'keybpard amps' get. If you want better, then you are talking about a compact, active PA system, such as JBL EON actives or Mackie SRM series. Electrovoice SX series are also very good. Cheaper versions of the same thing can be found with Peavey, Yamaha and Warfdale brand names.
Nik
--------------------------------
MV-8800
Axon guitar-to-MIDI

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

5 Mar 2009, 04:14
Hey Andy, You mentioned Logic on a laptop. Have you tried Logic's EVB3 in Mainstage? It works well live.

Re: Fantom X a joy in the studio but no good live

5 Mar 2009, 04:25
Hey Blues4Dog,

The laptop was on loan from his College (he's doing a degree in music technology, the lucky swine) so unfortunately, it's not an option to take it to gigs.

This thread reminds me of that old Korg advert for the X5DR (I think!) with the tiny paintbrush & the big brush. The Fantom needs a 'tiny brush' PA, not a 'broad brush' PA :o)

Andy
Andy

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X