Fantom-S and Fantom-X

considering FX purchase

considering FX purchase

24 Feb 2004, 22:29
Over the past 8 years I have owned the JV-1080 and the XV-5080. I prefered those two systems over the competition regarding their synth engine programming and performance editing, although it is a fact that the JV and XV series were not capable of truly syncing their LFOs to MIDI clock and this was aknowledged by top Roland officials. Now I have not had the opportunity to see the Fantom series to see if:
1. the same synth engine is used... I don't mean the exact chip, but rather, the same style architecture, ie, 4 stereo tones, 2 LFOs with the default destination mods, etc., etc. with offsets available in performance that address the synth engine parameters and most importantly, the ability to edit ANY synth parameter from a performance by going to the patch in question without loosing the present sonic status of that performance. But is this same ease of availabilty allowed when the sequencer is running?? 2. Has the MIDI to LFO clock sync been fixed?
Why does Roland claim (or a person here, I forget his name), that a NEW CHIP was installed into the FX verses FS to be able to allow 128 voice poly when that should be no big deal, seeing that the XV already had that.
Lastly (for now), I took a look at some of the tutorials posted on this site...very nicely done, but why in this mordern age does Roland have to resort to a cumbersome file system refering to the naming of samples. It lacks elegance.
Phil

Re: considering FX purchase

24 Feb 2004, 22:39
The FS and FX have the same style architecture as the older JV/XV synths with some additions.
- 3 LFOs with new LFO waveforms
- Step LFO waveform - 16 step programmable
- tone cycling - 4 tones can be made to cycle in order or random - nice for drum sounds with 4 different cymbal waveforms for example
- new waveforum rom compared to XV
- some new MFX compared to XV

Roland claim it is a new chip in the FX because it is faster than the FS and able to output 128 voices as you point out. Architecturally it is the same. It might not be a big deal to you, but for roland marketing it is :-)

Lawrence
Professor of Fantomology
Loz

Re: considering FX purchase

24 Feb 2004, 23:25
I had a JV-1080, and trying now to sell my old beloved JV-80.

Since I bought my FS I never looked back. Same synth style, only better.

Considering FX purchase

25 Feb 2004, 02:54
Thanks to Lawrencew and Steph3dfx :

Well, this is good news and I should be right at home with the programming.

Do you know if the LFO to MIDI sync has been corrected?

I did a quick read-thru regarding the sample/sample file management system for the F-S and I would hope to see an improvement there, but with those type of system functions, I'm sure it will be the same for the F-X.

Does the sequencer have an Event List Editor?

When editing a track's controllers, are the following minimum functions available?
Using VEL as an example:
Scale VEL by xx = Entire Track
" " " " = by KEY RANGE
" " " " = IN and OUT at

I don't wish to have anyone explain the entire OS to me, therefore, is the F-S Manual available for download? I don't believe Roland does that.
Thanks,
Phil

Re: considering FX purchase

25 Feb 2004, 06:03
not sure about the midi clock problem - but it has never been raised as a problem here


You can edit the volume in the way you ask.
However, volume is the only controller you can edit this way

Lawrence
Professor of Fantomology
Loz

Re: considering FX purchase

25 Feb 2004, 13:55
Hi Lawrence:

My question regards Velocity (VEL) not Volume, but I'm curious about your reply when you say Volume is the only controller that can be handled this way. That would make the Fantom series severly crippled regarding sequencing

Thanks Phil

Re: considering FX purchase

25 Feb 2004, 14:24
sorry, I meant velocity not volume

You can edit any individual controller value, but velocity is the only one for some reason that you can go a global edit on in the way you describe

You can erase or copy specific controllers globally from a track. But you cannot globally change their values, only each individual event

Lawrence
Professor of Fantomology
Loz

Re: considering FX purchase

25 Feb 2004, 18:43
Hmm...

I want to make sure I understand this correctly because the Fantom sequencer is, for me, one of the most important considerations in purchasing.
Taking some of the most important controllers that I would use, as an example, would be:
Velocity, Pressure (mono/poly), Mod Wheel, Control Pedal (#4), Data Slider, etc.
So, your saying, in order to edit any of these as a macro, ie: Increase/Decrease by x amount, the entire track or within a keyrange or IN at/OUT at, I would have to do this one event at a time in the Event Editor-except for Velocity!
What is the purpose, if this is true, in making a "Workstation"
that is very dependant on external devices.

Re: considering FX purchase

25 Feb 2004, 18:54
Yes - you would have to do it one event at a time.

Though this has never been raised as a problem by other FS users here. Presumably they haven't had or seen the need that you have. Personally I haven't. But then my music/sequencing tastes and requirements are no doubt different to yours.

However, now that you raise it, it does seem a little short sighted of Roland that they provide a Change Velocity function that allows the sort of edits you require, when with one extra simple parameter they could have made it a Change Controller function and allowed you to select the controller yourself. Ah well, c'est la vie

Lawrence
Professor of Fantomology
Loz

Re: considering FX purchase

25 Feb 2004, 19:49
Its not short sightedness on Rolands part, but rather, a concience decission.
This is a trend for all the manufacturers of so-called workstations, now that computers are the fashion.
It's also add copy hype when they brag about hundreds of thousands of note capacity in a sequencer whilst at the same time, the sequencer is under designed.
MIDI sequencing, despite its age, is more important now than ever, except manufactures are used to people having computers to do the work that once was required of the all-in-one keyboard.
My trusty Ensoniq SD-1, built in 1990, does all of the things I mentioned and much more-all from the front panel in an elegant manner. Roland and yamaha all have built stand alone MIDI recorders, so they do know how to do these things, but its money that is the most important item.
The same goes for the Motif ES, a dumb synth editing interface, a sequencer that is more full featured than the Fantom, but poorly designed with respect to interfacing.
I am dissapointed with all of the current workstation offerings. None of them do what I require, therefore I am being forced to consider a computer as part of my composition studio. I am unhappy about this because I do not want to be forced to bring the computer into my sound room.
For now, the Fantom will not be a choise for me.
Thanks to everyone who responded. I'll check in from time to time...Oh by the way, one all-in-one keyboard that has caught my attention is the OpenLabs Neko64. I'm sure some of you here are aware of this very full featured design. Here is the link...
http://www.openlabs.com/neko64.php
Thanks again and may you all enjoy your music.
Phil Magnotta

← Back to Fantom-S and Fantom-X