Fantom-G

The Natives are restless... ;)

It's better ...

17 Oct 2008, 15:06
... having ***ONE*** thread that allows people to voice their concerns, than have 10 threads with complaints, and 10 threads complaining about/against the complaints.

I think jim and jesse have created 2 threads that do just that, and I think we should leave it at that. People who dont like looking at complaints simply dont click on that thread :) It's ***THAT*** simple!

Now what's the purpose of this thread again (Somehow it escapes me)?

I've said all I needed to in those threads ... so keeping this short!!

;) Manish
;) Manish

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 15:06
Eh, sorry Jim, but I don't follow you here... I can't see how these two things are connected. But I do know this:

This dialogue between the two of us proves in a clear but sad way where this forum is going if we don't do what Jesse and others have suggested. Keep the number of threads down (see earlier post by jessej). You are referring to something I posted in another thread and here I am in a different thread trying to defend myself for something that wasn't even aimed at you.

This forum just lost a member.

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 15:10
Artemiy, it may not be a part of your understanding of democracy that someone repeats an issue which is not solved. I regard is as natural democratic right and won't call you names our tell you you have a disease, if you don't agree with me on that.

I regard your post as *very* offensive, and can hardly believe that you act this way. Is that the behaviour of the main moderator of this forum? If Tasha had spoken that way, you would probably act as moderator.

I agree to keep threads together and will stay in my own thread concerning this topic. Manishkurup and others are right about that. I just have to get past the disappointment about the behaviour of a few in here, of whom I had really thought they act more respectful and less offensive...

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 15:15
Well... I guess Artemiy's patience is wearing off (I'm not surprised...) .
A good option would be to "suspend" the "Fantom-G" forum until the update comes.

It's very difficult to read this forum right now. I am with all of you who think the update is overdue... but this is too much...

I think I will start checking the forum once a week... before all of this fuss, the forum was about creating music with a workstation, now it turned the opposite way.

Regards,
LL

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 15:19
No Art,

The section should be called "Broken Records" or something.

Frankly I'm getting more annoyed at the constant bashing and, yes, whining than with the "limitations" of the G. (and I'm quoting myself here, no-one in particular, god forbid!)

All good comes to those who wait and I will not start bitching until Roland want's to actually charge us for our finding bugs, be it this month or at Winter NAMM.

And if you really can't use your G, do like Diametro does: make some nice pictures and share your work!

How about a forum gallery section for his and other's work?

100 yrs from now:
"ahhh, yess this was D in the prime of graphic-career....it's from the post G 1.1 with a hint of pre G 2.0 period. You can tell by HIS subtile use of sharks, while every one ELSE was into whining whales....this work is so much better.....

......wait.....HOW MUCH!?!?!?"

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 15:22
See Jim, you do not even understand what I am saying and to whom, how can we ever have a forum-level issue solved then? ;-)

First and foremost, my post was not directed at you personally (please re-read it if needed), but to those people who post the same stuff over and over again. It is not just me who is tired of reading the same whines each and every day, there are thousands of forum readers who are tired too. Think about them, not just yourself.

The other thing is - you may be surprised - I do not believe in democracy! It might have worked in heaven, but here on Earth, it doesn't. Most people do not even know what they want, what they need, what they're doing, how they affect other people's lives.

What I believe in is a well-thought-through, positively-directed dictatorship!

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 15:26
before all of this fuss, the forum was about creating music with a workstation, now it turned the opposite way.
Yeah, I left for a while because there weren't any new issues—They were just the same complaints over and over again.

I've been to forums where bug reports were consistently placed within a bug report thread. Feature requests were always thrown in a feature request thread. If the Fantom-G project head in Japan were to visit this site, how would he be able to suss out the legitimate issues from those based on misconception or misunderstanding? How would he be able to even find them? Roland would have to hire a person full time just to swim through our shark-infested waters.

But I will admit it's really annoying when the Motivator and Korg forums use the comments on our forum as an excuse to slag the Fantom-G. And I'm sure the Yamaha and Korg sales reps use our "work" to feed anti-G sentiment in retail outlets. Great job, guys.

At least the vitriol is less than that for the OASYS when it was first announced. Sheesh.

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 15:31
I even made this page (expecting nothing in return) hoping to "distract" the complaints/bug requests out of the forum to keep it clean, without success.
Only a few posts there...

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 15:34
Artemiy:
What I believe in is a well-thought-through, positively-directed dictatorship!
Sure, and who's to say Roland Clan is a democracy at all? The terms of service we all agree to limit what we can say and do.

If anything, most online forums are less like a large nation of unique personalities free to do whatever they please... and more like a large house party, where if a guest gets out of hand, they're asked to behave—or occasionally get tossed out the door and beaten up in the back yard.

The repetitive complaints are akin to that one drunk frat guy screaming the same retarded, unfunny Dane Cook punchline over and over again. "Who the hell invited him?"

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 15:56
As a Greek, I am not happy that you guys are critical of democracy one of our most famous (or maybe infamous , depends on your politics I suppose) inventions. Roland give the people want they want i.e. New os update...! now that would be democratic....
Aster

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 16:07
If people whine about whining.. what do you call them?

Come on!! There is no whining. Relax! Take a deep breath! Ignore the whining! Love your Fantom G! Play with it! Make music! Dive Deep! Hit the wall! Join the whiners!
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 16:11
Stop bitching about the whiners! ;)
Septimo ,'^)
X6
XT
MV-8800!!!!!!!

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 16:12
Who are the bitchers?

Who are the whiners?

Who are the complainers?

Who just bends over and takes it?

;-)))
Septimo ,'^)
X6
XT
MV-8800!!!!!!!

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 16:12
Whiner or not, anyone can turn any thread into a pointless nonsense. That's what I call a real community!

Re: The Natives are restless... ;)

17 Oct 2008, 16:14
Oh and I forgot, who are the pointless nonsensors? ;)
Septimo ,'^)
X6
XT
MV-8800!!!!!!!

← Back to Fantom-G