Fantom-G

what the hell is that.... "sequencer" (lol?)

what the hell is that.... "sequencer" (lol?)

13 Aug 2008, 11:52
hey folks,

i bought the fantom g6 3 weeks ago and i can´t believe what the roland-guys did here... what about that crappy sequencer? is this a joke?
where is the classic linear sequencer like the juno-g had (i loved the juno for his sequencer, it was easy and qucik to use). with this one here i can´t work at all. it´s so cicumstantial and lazy to work with i can´t believe i´ve paid 2,300 euro for a high-end machine that has no use for me.
am i alone? how do you work with this machine? this phrase-stuff is so unnecessary, why am i FORCED to work with it? isn´t there a button to switch to the good old linear method? will there be any update?
i make electronic music with lots of filter-movements and stuff like that, so if i play an 8-measure-loop and copy it (that seemed cool!), a filter-event recorded on the copy affects on EVERY "phrase"... so sequencing a whole song with lots of changes on one track seems impossible. please may someone tell me the sense of this.

cheers,
schnabel

Re: what the hell is that.... "sequencer" (lol?)

13 Aug 2008, 12:03
It's easy. Just use one phrase for your sequencing. That will give you an old fashioned linear sequencer.

Just keep editing and recording to the same phrase. [update: recording to same phrase doesn't work, since it dose overwriting it, not mix recording]
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: what the hell is that.... "sequencer" (lol?)

13 Aug 2008, 12:20
thank you shakill,
but how can i merge two different phrases into one?
and how can i record only into the same phrase, i mean if i got one phrase (let´s say from measure 1-8) and start at measure 9, the fantom creates a new phrase.
thanks so far,
schnabel

Re: what the hell is that.... "sequencer" (lol?)

13 Aug 2008, 17:40
Currently there is no way of merging two phrases from the sequencer, but you can play a trick to see if this works... here it is:

Let's say you have two phrases, one on track 1, and the other on track 2.
Set track 1 and 2 output assign to EXT.
Connect MIDI OUT to MIDI IN with a cable.
Go to track 3 to record merged phrase 1 and 2.
Set Track 3 output assign to INT.
Press record and let it record until it has played all of the phrases.
Once done, hit Stop.
Assign Phrase 3 to track 3.
You can either remove phrase 1 and 2 from tracks, or just mute the track.
Hit PLAY. Phrase 3 has Phrase 1 and 2 merged data.

But the problem is once you have a phrase saved, you can not re-record to it (I know it's stupid. I don't know if it's Roland or me). If you rerecord to the same phrase location, it will overwrite it, not mix record it. You can only edit it and copy data to it. Read the manual on page 238.
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: what the hell is that.... "sequencer" (lol?)

13 Aug 2008, 19:25
Using one phrase for the whole song "sounds great" however the basic copy and past fuctions do Not work in the modify menu.

Re: what the hell is that.... "sequencer" (lol?)

14 Aug 2008, 00:10
copy paste work if you select a phrase to edit. if you use copy paste in song edit, then it will copy just the link.
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: what the hell is that.... "sequencer" (lol?)

14 Aug 2008, 00:11
copy paste work if you select a phrase to edit. if you use copy paste in song edit, then it will copy just the link.
--------------------
Fantom-G6, Motif XS6, Korg M3-m, Korg Z1, Roland MC808 and MC909.

live a musical life

Re: what the hell is that.... "sequencer" (lol?)

14 Aug 2008, 12:48
cpy and paste works in song edit but not in the modify menu.
which is what were talking about. Copying events not the phrase. Yet again you know nothing of what your talking about. If you try to copy events it does nothing. Just leaves it blank. They better fix this problem, LOL 2400$ and you cant even copy lol. Its basicaly a sound module, a good one though!.

Re: what the hell is that....

20 Oct 2011, 12:40
I just ran across this thread, and I know it's old, but for the sake of new Fantom G owners that don't know and come looking and find this...

you can now mix record to an already recorded phrase. this must have been added via an update after this thread died down...but no one came to say that the issue had been corrected...

so I figured I'd do it.

3 year old thread, but hey I found it... and the next person may find it too.
Can You Touch The Apex

Re: what the hell is that....

21 Oct 2011, 01:25
from what i know this has been fixed in update 1.3 last time...we can either record Mix or Replace on the same phrase..

hence, a very noob question..how do i record the automation (from Ed Diaz youtube video he recorded in a blank phrase & then insert the automation data in 2nd track below the midi phrase)? in step by step guide..since i seems not to be able to do this right LOL, or maybe i'm just plain dumb :P

Re: what the hell is that....

21 Oct 2011, 06:07
You can even recording multitimbral sounds in one and only midi phrase !. Read carefully your user manual : it's all in it...

Re: what the hell is that....

5 Nov 2011, 05:25
why do people hate the fantom G Sequencer so much....

I've used Hardware sequencers since the MC50 days and used perhaps every hardware sequencer since then,(Including all the MPC line) and the Fantom G is by far and away the best hardware sequencer inside a workstation to date,I also have an MV8800 and whilst its not as feature full as the MV,the Fantom has a great sequencing environment and to me is the workstation to set the bar for all the other Manufacturers in terms of a decent Audio and MIdi composers tool,it perhaps doesn't have the best Rompler engine but by golly its sequencer beats the competition hands down.

Nowadays there are people out there who buy things and expect it to write their music for them,if you think the Fantom has a poor sequencer,check out the lame crap that Korg bolted into the Oasys or Kronos,they don't have a patch on Fantom's Sequencing interface,Roland did a great job on this workstation just wish they had continued to update it and not just ditch its support

Re: what the hell is that....

5 Nov 2011, 06:45
The Fantom g came after the mv and yet it's sequencer is not as good as the mv.. That is Progress?.. If you figure out why then you will start to see why.. Customer do not expect things to get worse, or lose functionality in new, "better" equipment.
With a sounds library like the mv such that samples could be loaded into a new project, and a sequencer exactly like the mv the two largest issues in the FG would not exist. Roland had the technology already coded and yet put in r&d effort to change it and make it worse.
MC808ter wrote:
why do people hate the fantom G Sequencer so much....

I've used Hardware sequencers since the MC50 days and used perhaps every hardware sequencer since then,(Including all the MPC line) and the Fantom G is by far and away the best hardware sequencer inside a workstation to date,I also have an MV8800 and whilst its not as feature full as the MV,the Fantom has a great sequencing environment and to me is the workstation to set the bar for all the other Manufacturers in terms of a decent Audio and MIdi composers tool,it perhaps doesn't have the best Rompler engine but by golly its sequencer beats the competition hands down.

Nowadays there are people out there who buy things and expect it to write their music for them,if you think the Fantom has a poor sequencer,check out the lame crap that Korg bolted into the Oasys or Kronos,they don't have a patch on Fantom's Sequencing interface,Roland did a great job on this workstation just wish they had continued to update it and not just ditch its support

Re: what the hell is that....

5 Nov 2011, 08:10
The problem is the MV is aimed at a different type of genre mainly hiphop/beats type of users,I agree the MV ported into the Fantom would have been the perfect sequencer,but I kind of get the impression that these machines are all headed by a seperate team of designers,rather than a collective group who design every device,because surely if the same team headed all the sequencer designs then why would they create a perfect solution like the MV then go and change the work flow with the Fantom.

Well when you compare it to the MV it perhaps has flaws,That aside its still a really great sequencer,and unless your of experience with the MV then I don't see why so many put it down,I've yet to see a decent Workstation sequencer that is as flexible and user friendly as the Fantom G

Re: what the hell is that....

5 Nov 2011, 10:20
my first real sequencer was a MMT8. before that i had some 2 track sequencer from yamaha which i dont even remember the name. lol

the FG's sequencer is fine if you're into this type but for me it has to have a simple and quick piano-roll editor (the FG editor appears it does but you cant drag/drop/edit note lengths with the curser which to me is basically useless) and less buttons to edit something on the fly. the FG requires too many steps to fix a note ending up with me just doing a re-take or resort to my daw. the first cubase i had in my classic2 in 1989/1990 had much more usable features for MIDI vs the FGs internal sequencer.

← Back to Fantom-G