Fantom-G

New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

13 May 2008, 15:31
What?!! Artemiy, no one said we could model propagation of electromagnetic waves through tilted thin films on the G.

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

13 May 2008, 16:40
I guess Quinnx is again getting desperate at this point :-)))

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

13 May 2008, 20:01
Mock me i don't mind :)
Its only taken me 3 years on this forum with the X to try get some support from all users to try benefit everyone here.
but no one followed my foot steps and its seems the only one that finally benefited from this solo quest was me alone.
and here i go again trying to give the benefit of my experience once again, but am told contrary to my own experiences and results, that doing what i suggest and have been doing for 3 years and suggesting that people do it too for the G yields no results at all.

Hmm...
Oh well i suppose im just imagining it.

(follow me get results, dont follow and just bang your heads off the 4 wall as has been done for the past 3 years and achieve nothing, its up to you)

Peace.. :)



[img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/myconfig.jpg[/img] - [img]http://forums.rolandclan.info/pub/attach/116700-UT.jpg[/img] - [img]http://www.geocities.com/cpmul/filesystem.jpg[/img]






Listen to GlassSlipper


X-Bugs.org

Results not Excuses

My Setup

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

13 May 2008, 20:24
Quinnx, you know I agree with you on this as I also believe that if we say nothing and just make the buy they will think they built a good selling machine and will put their focus elsewhere. A lot of people said they would buy it just to try it. For those who are really not happy with the many missing features and bugs then perhaps they should go back to the original plan and return the G to the store citing the many issues that we all have raised. If you don't do that then the message is that you are satisfied to pay these dollars for this machine. Money speaks here more than our emails.

I wonder if anyone will actually return their G. hmmm.

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

13 May 2008, 21:07
How long should Roland make us wait? Zero seconds.

How long will Roland make us wait? As long as it takes to get multisampling and undo right. Hopefully.

I returned my G7

13 May 2008, 22:40
for many of same reasons Quinnx has mentioned. I am not holding my breath for a new OS to appear any time soon!

More in-depth reviews please!!!

13 May 2008, 22:48
I appreciated Quinxx's detailed list of things that needed to be fixed in one of his earlier posts that went beyond the undo feature and multi-sampling. Being organized and vocal about what you want (which is not necessarily whining) is more likely to bring about change than being passive. Manufacturers respond to competition and inherently want to please.

Ck out the motifator site- Yamaha knows competition when they see it and some months back did a survey of features folks wanted, and they have a new OS update due by the end of June.

" One of the important new features is the XS will not cut off when switching channels in Mix mode. So that allows either 16 Voices on 16 MIDI channels or 4 Performances on 4 MIDI channels to be switched without sounds cutting off. BTW, this is 8 more voices than is possible in Live Mode on the Fantom G.

"Another frequent request was the ability to have 10 key input and another was to be able to use a USB keyboard or mouse for editing. The new OS will allow you to connect a USB ASCI computer keyboard for editing parameters, calling up different pages and naming in Song/ Pattern, Sampling and Mix modes.

"It's pretty cool to be able to use the USB keyboard cursor to move around the screen , then type in values using the numeric keypad. Almost every key on the ASCI keyboard has been assigned. For example the function keys F1-F12 are mapped to function and subfunction keys on the XS so you can call up any page. Tranport keys are also mapped to the ASCI keyboard so you can basically edit everything in a Song or Pattern without touching the XS itself. In reality, this is a lot quicker than using a USB mouse for editing which was the other option we looked at.

-------------------------

There you have it- competition- maybe Yamaha is the one that will get the ball rolling at Roland the fastest-

AND... I really appreciate the reviewers like Jimknopf who have something positive to say about the G and do mini-reviews. It seems like too many folks on this site assume others have experience with the X and therefore they don't need to explain what they're talking about. But for those of us coming from other boards (XS7), I have little to compare it to, which is why I read this forum in the first place.

In particular, I want to read in-depth reviews about using the sequencer, recording/inserting audio in tracks, and Live mode. I don't find the XS to be inspiring in those regards, but I haven't heard enough yet to make me think the G is all that much better.

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

14 May 2008, 01:23
See what's the problem?

The problem is that some people might not known about some initial shortcomings like lack multisampling, they may not even know what it is now. But these kinds of discussions, which cross the line a bit at times, are embarrassing for them and make them distracted from making music and enjoying their Fantoms.

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

14 May 2008, 02:12
One of the important new features is the XS will not cut off when switching channels in Mix mode. So that allows either 16 Voices on 16 MIDI channels or 4 Performances on 4 MIDI channels to be switched without sounds cutting off. BTW, this is 8 more voices than is possible in Live Mode on the Fantom G.
Interesting. They don't make mention of the effects applied. Roland's been able to transition single sounds for ages, it was just that the effects glitched. Is Yamaha saying that if they utilize a 16-channel performance with all the effects active that switching to another 16-channel performance with all different effects active will be perfectly seamless?

It'd have to be some clever DSP, because the G pulls it off because those extra 8 effects are, presumably, being saved in a buffer (dynamic effects allocation).

If Yamaha's only talking about the patches within the performances, then big whoop—Kurzweil's had that for going on two decades.

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

14 May 2008, 02:18
Ditto what Audacity said. I am sure it's only patches, as the XS has something like 8 effects units in total. So despite Yamaha's claim (and what a shame to do it publicly!), Fantom-G is still a few years ahead.

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

14 May 2008, 06:06
I think it's ok to adress your issues when you think you have right to it. I think it's ok to join others with the same goal. I think it's ok to try to bring the most people you can to your cause. I think it's ok to send your complaints to Roland. But to do it all over and over again will just get the opposite result: more people tired of the same ol' subject over here and Quinnx email adress added to Roland's "spam" list.
I have already send my concerns to who I believe I should do it: my Roland rep. I was promised an answer, whatever that may be. I don't believe that sending an email to Roland US or Roland UK will do me the same. Stating here that "I sent an email and that I hope Roland to fix bugs in the next few days" will change nothing.

I've already said it in another post today: I bought my G8 for what it is TODAY. I bought it AS IS. I believe everyone should do a thoughfull buy and think to what extent you can live without whats missing and gain with whats there. Everyone that keeps "hoping" for something nobody knows when and how is going to happen is just wasting time. I'll look at any "G update fixing bugs and adding what was left from the X" just as an improvement to what I already have.
:-)

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

14 May 2008, 06:30
Ck out the motifator site- Yamaha knows competition when they see...
Well it seems not.
BTW, this is 8 more voices than is possible in Live Mode on the Fantom G.
We're not obviously talking about the same thing and its just a shame that someone from Yamaha is just deviating their users atention with false statements.
It's pretty cool to be able to use the USB keyboard cursor to move around the screen , then type in values using the numeric keypad
I bet it is. It probably is the ONLY way to find your way around the XS ;-)

Seriously, I think it's always good to have improvements. Soundwise is always a matter of taste but trying to make it look like this will make the XS a step over the G is pure nonsense.

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

14 May 2008, 06:41
Very good and totally true comments, V-CeeOh.

Re: New Firmware (how long should Roland make you wait?)

14 May 2008, 12:41
Well, it's unfair to compare newer product to older one anyway and Yamaha did this to stay competitive which is good for its users (not to mention all the deals they throw in for current users: XFactor DVD, Loyalty disk, sounds discount from keyfax, Cubase and Motif instructional dvds). They also surveyed the XS users what features to be included in the next OS release (free). This is exactly how competition benefits end users :)

I used to own Fantom X (without Audio Track) and Roland wanted $49 from me which should have been free IMHO to upgrade (or at least charge a handling fee only). I really want to see when the table is turned, could Roland do what Yamaha did to its customers?

We'll see... (so far they charged to upgrade Fantom X to X 2.0 and they release unfinished OS for the fantom G and we don't know yet when the new OS will be there). I think Roland needs to learn from Yamaha in this sense. In the end, us, lowly users are the one benefiting from it ;)

just my $.02

PS: Korg just emailed out a workstation survey. Something is brewing and it'll be interesting to see what they'll come up with.
------------------------------
I Play for God

← Back to Fantom-G