I can't help you on the yamaha AW front (Although the products I have used from Yammie tend to be logical to Easy use)but being a total newbie to the MV and Roland Workstations,I suppose I can help on the view of the MV8800
I've come from Korgs way of thinking,infact I have only ever bought Korg workstations since the very begginings of the M1.
After all these years using them I never found one single unit that offered me the ability to expand my potential without turning to software in where the Korgs lacked functions to cover them and so I have been after a decent hardware sequencer but without a massive learning curve,sadly Korg had nothing too offer me so I turned to the Roland brand....To see if there was something there...
I didn't want another synth so the Fantom line was out of the Question...Had a reccomendation from a mate about a second hand MV8000,But no luck so turned to the newer model instead
Before buying the MV8800,I was a little apprehensive as to whether I would get on with a Roland unit (Having never used any workstations or grooveboxes of theirs,except for a few synthesizers)and my experience of there Synth manuals from the 80s were....to say the least not the best...so that dampened my enthusiasm a little,but having plenty of years under my belt with technology,thought Ok with a little time and patience I can learn a new Manufacturers way of thinking
Well lets put it this way...
I have briefly read the Manuals and must say,whoever wrote this literature needs to work for all synth manufacturers,its the most logical and practical Manual ever,,even if you don't understand how things work the manual gives you a proper step by step account that even a layman could follow,but thats not to say the MV is not a pro's tool,because it definetly is,and the way it allows you to work shows it is,its geared for the Musician to express yourself easily without having to go round the houses or Kill your enthusiasm in the proces of setting up the machine to lay down ideas,this machine is immediate...just what I was after
infact the whole operational aspect of the MV8800 is superb,I've felt comfortable with it from day one(something that usually takes a few weeks of average use in the Past),the MV is a breeze to use,I bought the MV because of its relationship to operate in a software way with using the Mouse/VGA,
I haven't actually used it in that sense(other than to hook it up to see whats it like) because I have been too busy using it standalone,I thought it would have been the other way round,but this machine is wonderful to work with,all the functions are really easy to work out without too much manual digging,I have only had to reference the manual on a few things,but pretty much is self explanatory and logical if you apply the right common sense.
I class myself of a reasonable Intellect,plus having used plenty of technology over the years there seems to be a sort of logical way of how things work anyway,so I Guess having experience helps and the way the MV works is very much like working with software but in a hardware unit,the sort of machine I have been after for years ....
its so easy to slip into its working methods without too much fuss So I took to the MV like a duck to water,this is definetly a machine that works for you and not the otherway round
Infact a single song would have taken me a few days(2-3) to construct from start to Finish on my Triton,I have the MV now as the main writing tool and I've written and structured 4 songs with it in 3 days!!!
this machine certainly has sped up my workflow massively
I can't praise Roland enough for the operational aspects of the MV,I had always considered Korg the Workstation masters,but no longer,this MV was designed from the ground up by the right People who possibly work in this way all the time,not just a couple of white collar workers who only invent the code.....there are couple things that could be updated with an OS revision on the MV8800,but so far top marks to the R and D at Roland...
The one thing I hope for at the moment in the OS is the support to utilise up to 1Gb of memory,512mb is ok but I can see it being a limit the longer I use it ,but at the moment I have an external sampler which can double up