Fantom-G

MIDI setup with multiple keyboards - help please?

MIDI setup with multiple keyboards - help please?

21 Aug 2010, 04:14
I've always recorded MIDI with computers, starting with software instruments then moving on to hardware synths only recently, so I'm not that up on MIDI routing with standard MIDI cables between instruments.

I have the Fantom G, a Korg M3, Yamaha XS and a Roland JP 8000. I've been recording these on various DAWs using MIDI over USB on the FG, M3 and XS with a USB midi interface which has enabled them all to be on their own midi ports so routing has been relatively easy.

With the great sequencer on the FG, I now want to simplify my setup and record everything into the FG without using a computer so I can leave the laptop at home when on stage. Although the FG has 128 midi tracks and 16 external midi channels, it only has one set of midi in/out/thru ports on the back. How can I connect all of my synths in a daisy chain so I can record them into the FG AND play back the sequences without having to constantly swap midi cables over?

I have tried having FG midi out to M3 midi in, M3 midi out to XS midi in, XS midi out to JP midi in, JP midi out back to the FG midi in to complete the circle, with all instruments set on various independent channels. However only the M3 receives the midi sync signal so any arps on the XS or JP don't sync. If I use midi thru between the M3, XS and JP, then the sync signal is available for all but I don't receive midi notes from the M3 or XS into the FG.

Do I need extra equipment like some sort of midi splitter, patch bay or similar? Or is there a better way to do what I'm trying? All suggestions gratefully received.

Thanks

Dave

Re: MIDI setup with multiple keyboards - help please?

21 Aug 2010, 05:32
Yes, I'd suggest that you get a MIDI thru box, which will sport 1 or 2 MIDI inputs and 3 or 4 MIDI outputs, so that you will connect the Fantom-G to all your synths at once.
This way you can make sure that you won't have any MIDI connection problems, like MIDI lag.

Re: MIDI setup with multiple keyboards - help please?

21 Aug 2010, 08:03
Tricky, and as the Fantom's sequencer can send out 16 MIDI channels as you said, so you will have to do some pre-planning.
You will have to decide what instrument plays on what channel. The M3, and XS no doubt are multitambral, so you will need to create a set-up which assigns them to only work on certain MIDI channels.

As you want to record performances from these other instruments. I suggest a MIDI patchbay. Tricky to get hold of these days, as most people use the multi input MIDI interfaces, as you have so far..
I've an old 'Function junction' unit, offers multi MIDI merge, midi filtering, spilt points, channelization, plus whole bunch more.
Rare as rocking horse do-do...

A MIDI selector switch might be the easiest, and cheapest route:
http://www.philrees.co.uk/products/selector.htm
There's a 5 channel switch. All the other MIDI out's from the other synths (except the Fantom) plug into it, and it's out goes to the MIDI in of the Fantom.

Then a MIDI thru box on the Fantom's MIDI out to send the data to each of the devices.
("Fantom" MIDI out--> MIDI in of "thru box" MIDI outs to MIDI in's of the rest)

Without the thru box, you can use the MIDI thru connections on the instruments:
"Fantom" MIDI out--> MIDI in "M3" MIDI thru-->MIDI in "XS" MIDI thru--> MIDI in "JP8000"

NB you don't need to arrange the instruments in that order, as long as each has a MIDI thru port. If one doesn't, and onlt has MIDI in, and out. This will have to be the last in the chain.

Re: MIDI setup with multiple keyboards - help please?

21 Aug 2010, 10:54
I agree with Cyclops and S-E-A's posts, but just to add on that and from my own experience, in order to do what you want, you really need a more elaborated PATCHBAY, so you can merge the M3, XS and JP MIDI out ports back to the Fantom in order to be able to record ...

Like the EDIROL UM-550/880 (maybe you will find some second hand ones still...), or like the MOTU 8x8 Midi Express ($395), or the 4x6 Micro Express($295), both with enough specifications to allow all possible combinations.

I'm quoting the MOTU's 4x6 Micro Express specs:

**Feature Highlights
MIDI interface for Macintosh and Windows

MIDI Time Stamping (MTS) ready
Stand-alone MIDI patchbay/merger/processor (when powered via USB)
SMPTE tape sync in all formats
4x6 MIDI merge matrix - connects any device to any other
Front panel presets for plug-and-play convenience
4 independent MIDI IN
6 independent MIDI OUT
96 MIDI channels
Supports MIDI Machine Control transport messages
Pedal input for momentary foot switch
Audio click input - converts audio click into MIDI data
16 presets with 8 programmable, battery-backed memory
Includes software for Mac and Windows
USB bus-powered
**
In this case, all you need is to connect each device's IN/OUT MIDI ports to each MOTU's pair of MIDI Ports like:
- FG OUT --->MOTU IN 1
- FG IN --->MOTU OUT1
- XS OUT --->MOTU IN 2
- XS IN --->MOTU OUT2
- M3 OUT --->MOTU IN 3
- M3 IN --->MOTU OUT3
- JP-8000 OUT --->MOTU IN 4
- JP-8000 IN --->MOTU OUT4

Then program the Matrix in order to have:
MOTU OUT1 ---> MOTU IN2, MOTU IN 3, MOTU IN 4 (this will minimize the chain lag...)
MOTU OUT2, MOTU OUT3 and MOTU OUT4 ---> MERGED, and connected to MOTU IN1

P.S: I have an EDIROL UM-550, that I had the BIIIIG luck to find on Ebay in 2008 that costed $175

Cheers,
PauloF
Make Music and be Happy !!
PauloF

Re: MIDI setup with multiple keyboards - help please?

21 Aug 2010, 15:17
Thanks guys. It looks like the MOTU Micro Express would do the trick and I double checked the specs on MOTU's website. Unfortunately it looks like it's been discontinued, but they still have the Micro Lite in the range. Would this do the same though, as it doesn't say it has midi merge?

From MOTU.com...
micro lite is a 5-in/5-out MIDI interface ($149, compatible with Mac and Windows).

Built from the same technology found in MOTU’s flagship MIDI Timepiece, the micro lite is a professional MIDI interface that provides portable, plug-and-play connectivity to any USB-equipped Mac or Windows computer.

The micro lite provides 5 MIDI IN, 5 MIDI OUT, 80 MIDI channels and compatibility with all Mac and Windows software. Large front-panel LEDs illuminate to indicate MIDI activity.

The micro lite takes full advantage of USB, giving you high-speed MIDI throughput, sub-millisecond timing accuracy, support for “hot-swapping” and plug-and-play expansion. Need to connect another sound module or synth? No problem. Just add another MOTU USB MIDI interface via any available USB port. And the micro lite is powered by the USB port — no wall wart or AC plug.

With its attractive yet rugged metal casing, the micro lite slides easily into a shoulder bag or briefcase for ultra-compact portability and convenient desktop operation. Removable rack attachments, as well as a custom center-joint fastener, are included and allow you to easily mount two micro lites side by side in a standard 19-inch equipment rack.

No other MIDI interface offers this much value, performance and portability at such an affordable price.

Features
MIDI connectivity - Five MIDI inputs and outputs provide 80 MIDI channels.
Expansion - MOTU MIDI interfaces grow with you. Expansion is simple. Add additional MIDI ports by plugging in another MOTU MIDI interface.
Compatibility - Works with your favorite software. Includes drivers for Mac OS9, Mac OS X and Windows Me/2000/XP/Vista/Windows 7. High-speed USB connection.
USB-powered - Bus-powered from USB connection. No additional power necessary.
Rack mountable - With rack ears attached, fits one half of a standard 19 inch (48.26 cm) rack at 1U high. Excluding rack ears, chassis dimensions are 9.5 x 7 x 1.75 inches (24.13 x 17.78 x 4.45 cm).

If not, I'll have to keep checking ebay until a used one comes available.

Re: MIDI setup with multiple keyboards - help please?

21 Aug 2010, 17:53
Strange to be discontinued...it is still available on the MOTU website...

However the Micro Lite seems to be a sub-product of the MIDI Timepiece, which has all the Bells and Wistles, like:

MIDI and Sync
MIDI Processing
Merge any inputs to any outputs
Route any inputs to any outputs
Mute any MIDI data on any cable
Re-channelize on input and output

And it costs half of the Micro Express
I don't know, maybe you should check with MOTU for the MIDI/Synch specs of the Micro Lite...
Make Music and be Happy !!
PauloF

← Back to Fantom-G