Fantom-G

fantom g compared to the m3

fantom g compared to the m3

13 Mar 2010, 21:47
ive been testing the fantom g at my local music store lately, and they had it hooked up to some roland keyboard amp/speakers, so ive been sequencing songs really quick on the fantom, but it has sounded really boring, and i think it was because of the amp they had it running through, today i went in and they had the fantom hooked up to some studio monitors. the song i sequenced on the fantom sounded really tight and clean, i was amazed, then made another beat on the m3, and was not so impressed anymore, even the gimmicky kARAMA sounds seemed to fade away from my mind. one thing i always noticed about the sounds on the fantom, was the way they seemed to blend together very harmonically and naturally when sequencing a full song. sometimes sounds would not stand out until the right sound had be complementing it in the mix, something i haven't felt with other keyboards. they also dropped the price in the past few days, the fantom g-8 is now down to 3100$, im hesitant to buy though after reading so many user gripes about bugs, however when i bought the fantom x7, i saw a similar amount of complaints about its operating system bugs, and quite honestly i never ran into any "bugs" on the fantom x7, everything worked fine that i needed to, the arps, the chord mem, the rhythm maker, pro edit, and the keys and knobs, however there were a few things i would have liked to see improved, such as a drag and drop window that makes it easier to make custom drum kits and then allowing key ranges inbetween the drum kit samples. if that makes sense, not a combi keyrange setup, just a single track set up, so say i want five keys for a snare so it has those 5 key pitches avalible.

Re: fantom g compared to the m3

13 Mar 2010, 23:25
A few paragraphs wouldn't have gone a miss by there.. lol

I am one of the biggest "whiners" here but I still love my G8. I would not sell it and I have loads of enjoyment out of it daily. (plus lots of non enjoyment when I have to play cabaret crap)

Here's the "but". I wouldn't buy one now if I knew in advance the things I do. The G probably is still the best workstation on the market and you will definately get your use out of it but as you have read Roland just isn't there on the support department which is paramount to me. This is only my opinion and there are many people here who are happy without the support.

My advice is to spend as much time with it as you can before purchase and if there is nothing missing for yourself go for it, just don't come here moaning about anything broke or missing afterwards =]
Whine whine everywhere and not a drop to drink ;)

Re: fantom g compared to the m3

13 Mar 2010, 23:38
The song i made though in the fantom was way cool, i think they stepped up the presets a little bit more in this one after hearing it through studio monitors.


I still would like to know though, when they manufacture newer boards, do they correct these features? or have all the boards been made at the same time and no new ones get made?

Re: fantom g compared to the m3

13 Mar 2010, 23:59
All boards would be made to the same spec. The only thing that changes is the OS version (Firmware) you are running which anyone can update.
Whine whine everywhere and not a drop to drink ;)

Re: fantom g compared to the m3

14 Mar 2010, 12:41
yeah thats what i thought, i enjoy now how there is no undo redo button, and you can just cancel the recording if you messed up, or save it if it was nailed, makes perfect sense, not that i ever mess up, i nail everything on the first take.;..

Re: fantom g compared to the m3

14 Mar 2010, 13:07
There is an undo button.. They just added it afterwards and hid it in the "menu" button.
Whine whine everywhere and not a drop to drink ;)

Re: fantom g compared to the m3

15 Mar 2010, 01:52
flumpster are you serious? about the hidden undo feature in the menu? (forgive me if that was stupid..., you just never know)
Can You Touch The Apex

Re: fantom g compared to the m3

15 Mar 2010, 01:54
Yes you press MENU and it's on F5 I think.

Re: fantom g compared to the m3

15 Mar 2010, 08:49
as I said, they hid it. Daftest place in the world to put the undo button imo. ;)

I'm waiting for them to add the solo button and put it in skipback sampling screen ;)
Whine whine everywhere and not a drop to drink ;)

← Back to Fantom-G