Fantom-G

G8 for drums

G8 for drums

7 Jun 2009, 23:40
Hi everyone. I'm about to buy the Fantom G8 because I'm learning to play piano and I don't want nothing smaller. My question is that the G8 got weighted keys and to make drums I think that's too difficult. I mean when you make drums, in the most cases, you want the same velocity in snares or kicks and that depends on the touch of the key. Do you understand me? Can this "problem" be solved?

Thanks in advance.

Re: G8 for drums

8 Jun 2009, 00:23
Don't worry about this. First, the action on the G8 keyboard is amazing, it's perfectly weighted but doesn't hurt your fingers, it's a great balance and you'll be comfortable with playing all types of sounds. Second, if you want, you can set the velocity to a fixed value at any time.

Re: G8 for drums

8 Jun 2009, 06:52
>Another option is to drum on the pads.

Really? Not on my pads. The velocity sensitivity on them is so random, that creating anything descent is impossible.

Some of my pads even have difficulties performing on/off functions, so asking for a nice 1-128 velocity curve is quite too much.

On a scale from 1-5 I would rate the Fantom G pads 1. They are buttons.
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: G8 for drums

8 Jun 2009, 07:42
Word to Jesse, I don't even use the pads for muting/unmuting in live sets, because I don't trust myself to hit them hard enough to work in a performance!

Re: G8 for drums

8 Jun 2009, 07:53
I'll probably sound weird, but I never had a problem using the pads in live situations, never had any of them not turn on/off what I needed. I find them reliable enough. Maybe it's that I've used this kind of pads for more than 5 years, starting with S and X models? I agree they could be much more sensitive and predictable for drums, but pads on MPD-24 I used to have were even worse.

Re: G8 for drums

8 Jun 2009, 09:22
Artemiy, maybe you actually do have physically a different pad?

Maybe some of us have a rotten batch, just like one batch of Akai MPC1000s had (and the MPD-24 I think). They were recalled and exchanged for free by Akai. Thomann had mine fixed for free, including shipping (UPS).

I've played live (perhaps 300 gigs) using Akai MPC2000XL and playing percussions live live (actually PLAYING, not just on/off) on the pads, and I know when a pad is not doing what it should.

Here's an ancient video of the kinda stuff I did back then using the pads, not just percussions:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rDlScFqWozo

There's no way I could play that without a single dis/mistriggering or getting a descent velocity out of the Fantom G pads.

Using the keys I can hit a steady 90-95 velocity for 16 bars, but with the pads I'm going to get a few 127 and a few that didn't trigger at all if I try to achieve the same.. that's how bad it is.

But like I've said in previous posts about this topic - I can use the keyboard keys to input drums, so it's not really a biggie. But I was expecting much higher quality from Roland and specially from a unit costing this much.
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: G8 for drums

8 Jun 2009, 11:52
i donno know about super un-humanly fast passages, but for the most part ive been using my G8 for drums as well and no issue. :)

in fact i made a nice cymbal for rolling the other day... wooo sounds excellente. :p

the orange keys suck. i think my washing machine has better tactile feel. lol

i use it for selecting my 'favorites' and 'midi transmit channels.'

Re: G8 for drums

8 Jun 2009, 15:38
My G pads work OK for Favorites and muting, unmuting.
They definately don't work good for drums for me.

On the Fantom X, I can perform drums quite well on the pads...I even had a song where one band member was playing the pads while I was playing keys...worked great...
www.songsforthemaster.com

Re: G8 for drums

8 Jun 2009, 16:28
Yep i agree, the pads are not yet perfect, but i only oppered another option :). I experienced the same issues

Re: G8 for drums

10 Jun 2009, 22:53
I think that is why the MPC1000 fits perfectly right next to the Fantom's pads. It's like the perfect dimensions too, like they knew the pads sucked and this is how most people would be rockin.

Re: G8 for drums

11 Jun 2009, 05:09
Yeah, and the MPC1000 has a better sequencer too! Too bad I sold mine.
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

← Back to Fantom-G