Fantom-G

arx-3 is brass

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 04:27
alright! not bad..... thanks for posting it...

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 04:48
Ok. Looks like **I will sell my Fantom G** after the album I'm currently working on is done and look for some other alternative.

With this pace, the Fantom G will never be a 'finished' workstation.
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 04:55
I'm thinkin the same, but I feel a small rest of hope for the G...
So I wait till the end of Namm and if they haven't anything interesting for me concerning the G, I might think of selling it too...

greets
Luke
Visit my Blog:
www.synthuniverse.blogspot.com

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 05:03
Jesse, did you purchase your Fantom-G for what it may be in the future? How can you know what will be in the future? Only Roland know that, since they design the future. Although, they never tell WHEN that future will come... hmmmm... ;-)

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 05:15
Artemiy wrote:
>Jesse, did you purchase your Fantom-G for what it may be in the future?

Yes I did expect Roland to update and bugfix the Fantom G and provide their users with ARX cards and sound expansions when I purchased it.

Just like when I bough an Apple Macbook, I was expecting Apple to release an new OS and new 'expansions' like iWork09 and iLife09 that help me with getting my work done.

When buying, I even thought Roland would bugfix the Fantom G quickly so the users could actually use the G and so the Fantom G would sell better and get better reviews. That is usually how companies work. Usually.

Roland is not providing me with any of that. There is a lot of bugs and quirks unfixed and there are a lot of features that are very lacking, specially the sequencer and with the pace the updates keep coming, it will be 2023 before the synth will be at 2008 standards imho. The ARX-03 brass is very unexciting news to me and I think they should have provided better brass out-of-the box anyway. Seems they left it crippled on the brass side on purpose.

After one year of it's release, Roland offers 0 sound expansions to the Fantom G. Yes, Sinevibe is offering sounds, but as the only 3rd party afaik and that is not much compared to other platforms.

I hate to be negative, but Roland leaves me no choice as a customer to be anything else.

The Fantom G is still stuck at 70% anf that is not my fault. I have personally provided all the user feedback I could to make the G better.
Jesse J / The Fantom G Facebook group - Please join!

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 08:33
Yeah, this is going to be it for me too. I bought the G hoping Roland would produce B3 and VA cards. It looks like that's not going to happen. Kurzweil PC3, here I come! :)
Roland Fantom G6 (2), G7, VK-8M
Korg M50, CX3

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 09:07
Jesse, Apple is a very streamlined company with a much different tactics. If Roland were Apple, they would have only three synth lineups: budget, middle-class and pro, and would refine them year after year. But the computer markets, where you define most of your product's functions within the software, is much different from MI market, where people demand for much more variety. Hence Roland has a lot of time to dedicate to a wider product lineup and it may not be exactly where you'd wish they are in one year from now.

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 10:26
Art, that's all true, but for any company a lot will depend on the better or not so good reputation of the amount of support their flagships get. If you don't set a clear priority there and act strong and trustworthy, you are spoiling your own market.

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 10:36
brass??? really?? How many times do i use brass horn instruments in a song? I KNEW this was gonna happen! Nothing useful like a Dance, guitar, vintage synth card that you can use in majority of your work. Or, better yet, keep the ARX and just update them 1995 jv1080 sounds! Watch the next ARX be Classical piano! That's it. Ebay here i come. This has got to be the most disgruntled group of people on a forum on the internet. I'm gonna go download my free 256 mb Motif XS sounds now, and look for a M3. Holla!

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 10:39
billw wrote: "I bought the G hoping Roland would produce B3 and VA cards. It looks like that's not going to happen. Kurzweil PC3, here I come! :)"

I sure hope you bought a musical instrument for that kind of money for other reasons than that! It's like buying a $10,000 Skoda hoping that they will upgrade the engine so that it would make 0-60 in 4 seconds.

Come on, guys. How can you buy someting that expensive and hope/expect something that you don't know for sure? You'll never be satisfied with the G, that's your biggest problem.

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 10:45
For crying out loud, Mobetta! These kind of posts piss me off, to be honest. (Pardon my French)

This shows how different needs we have. I NEVER use the dance/techno/guitar sounds on the G but I would be happy for those who do if Roland would release a card with those sounds. They can't release ARX-boards for every taste on the planet, can they?

For you it's useful, for me... No.

You say that you knew it was going to happen. Well, why did you get it then?!?!

Re: arx-3 is brass

15 Jan 2009, 10:59
I can not agree at all, FatBrass.

First, the G is no Skoda to be developed further, but rather a BMW running half of its cylinders and on tricycle wheels.

This synth is a real top keyboard workstation rather in the Oasys range, just not fully developed. That's ok so far if you hurry to get it developed to it's full potential, or at least set clear priority to give it a lot of it's full potential as fast as possible. What we see, makes another impression: Keeping the G owners hanging around while giving them just enough to keep in touch, including the danger of losing them altogether.

@Mobetta:
I definitely defend the ARX brass decision: it is an effort to fix the biggest quality hole in the G library (though better SRX sound choices should have been first priority right from the start, as Mada pointed out). So I will not critisize Roland for a moment to publish this one next.
But a B3 clone is quite urgent as well. And VA highly desirable, then perhaps acoustic and electric guitar specials. One card in a year is not overwhelming and does not give G owners the impression that this flagship is updated as it should, if it wants to become THE top workstation it could be.

← Back to Fantom-G